News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Baby Gene Edits Could Affect a Range of Traits by subroutine on Saturday December 15, 2018 @04:36AM (#18687772)
This was the immediate concern shared by me and several genomics researchers - gene variants that are often shown to be good for one thing may be bad for another. However, the way genome wide association studies (GWAS) currently works, is that gene variants are identified that have unexpectedly high frequencies in 'case' group compared to a control group; but follow-ups to see what other phenotypes are associated with those variants are rarely done.
Re:Baby Gene Edits Could Affect a Range of Traits by nordsieck on Saturday December 15, 2018 @05:55AM (#18687934)
> This was the immediate concern shared by me and several genomics researchers - gene variants that are often shown to be good for one thing may be bad for another.

I think it's certainly possible to get mixed or even bad results with gene editing by trying to push the technology farther than we really understand.

That being said, the basic priority for gene editing is probably to prevent/reverse bad genetic conditions that we understand well. No more downs syndrome.

That seems to be an unmitigated win to me.

Re:Baby Gene Edits Could Affect a Range of Traits by Valmar on Saturday December 15, 2018 @06:11AM (#18687974)
One thing that worries me is, that by attempting to prevent and/or reverse one set of conditions, other issues may pop up because of adding/removing/changing something we don't understand the full functionality of and how it interacts with other parts of DNA.

DNA looks mightily like an extreme and profoundly complicated, complex piece of programming, with unnecessary redundancies removed, and useful redundancies left in, as well pieces of code that call lots of other pieces, as well as being called by others.

If the genome is analogous to a computer binary... we don't understand the file format, and how it is read and interpreted.

Nature knows far-and-away better than we do how to make it all work 99.99% of the time, with occasional errors due to radiation, poisoning, interbreeding being accounted for so that things don't get out of hand.

Well, these assumptions held... until we intelligently stupid creatures came along, using our intelligence to create dangerous tools that are most abused by those least worthy to wield them...

Re:Baby Gene Edits Could Affect a Range of Traits by Retric on Saturday December 15, 2018 @08:51AM (#18688370)
We understand a lot of about the DNA ‘file format’ and how it works. That’s been a major priority of research.

Nature does not ‘know how’ to make it work 99.99% of the time. Nature very frequently aborts pregnancy’s when any number of things go wrong. Getting all the way to birth is a huge checksum that validates the majority of critical DNA.

Which gets it the larger point. Evolution focuses more on species propagation than individuals.

Re:Baby Gene Edits Could Affect a Range of Traits by Valmar on Saturday December 15, 2018 @11:18AM (#18688957)
> We understand a lot of about the DNA ‘file format’ and how it works. That’s been a major priority of research.

We may understand a lot, but nowhere near enough to be able to confidently edit DNA, and know that it won't causes a ton of unforeseen issues down the line.

We don't know what we don't know ~ that is, as much as we like to believe that we understand a lot about DNA and how it works, odd things pop up all the time that prove us wrong. I dare say that there are far deeper mysteries about DNA that we have no current understanding of.

> Nature does not ‘know how’ to make it work 99.99% of the time. Nature very frequently aborts pregnancy’s when any number of things go wrong. Getting all the way to birth is a huge checksum that validates the majority of critical DNA.

This is merely an example of nature getting it right ~ abort if there are serious issues.

> Which gets it the larger point. Evolution focuses more on species propagation than individuals.

It is about both ~ the individual matters most ~ species propagation doesn't even register in importance to a majority of individuals. Having children does. They're subtly different ideas.

Re:Baby Gene Edits Could Affect a Range of Traits by Retric on Saturday December 15, 2018 @02:21PM (#18689873)
> confidently edit DNA, and know that it won't causes a ton of unforeseen issues down the line.

That’s a question of code not file format. I may understand C, but that does not mean I can edit any C program safely.

> abort if there are serious issues.

That stance suggests there is no way to fail as death is the worst option. But even that fails as a significant number of women died due to pregnancy or birth before modern medicine. Even now pregnancy’s are higher risk than most things people do.

Re:Baby Gene Edits Could Affect a Range of Traits by ryacko on Saturday December 15, 2018 @02:27PM (#18689905)
The genome is spooky action at a distance. A lot of physical traits seem connected to personality which indicates studies are insufficiently rigorous.
Re:Baby Gene Edits Could Affect a Range of Traits by Retric on Saturday December 15, 2018 @02:31PM (#18689919)
Personality presupposes so many things working that you have basically won at that point.
Re:Baby Gene Edits Could Affect a Range of Traits by tormeh on Saturday December 15, 2018 @02:53PM (#18690036)
Nope. Many people both have personalities, and need staff looking after them 24/7. Some of them can't even speak.
Re:Baby Gene Edits Could Affect a Range of Traits by Retric on Saturday December 15, 2018 @08:09PM (#18691203)
They are a tiny fraction of people who died from DNA issues.

People with personalities also have neurons and wonder of wonders a centural nervous system.

PS: It’s hard to get good numbers for this stuff as but many things like drug use my pregnant mothers can cause significant developmental issues. But, everyone has several random mutations and mental problems from them seem to be far less common than other issues. Especially when you exclude things getting passed down over time and just look at new mutations.

Re:Baby Gene Edits Could Affect a Range of Traits by TheSpiceIsLife on Saturday December 15, 2018 @10:19AM (#18688655)
It could be argued that miscarriages due to genetics that are incompatible with life to whatever degree are nature getting it right.
Re:Baby Gene Edits Could Affect a Range of Traits by Retric on Saturday December 15, 2018 @02:40PM (#18689958)
That’s a near tautology.

Cell division is one of those things you need or get right or you don’t get a pregnancy.

It’s not like the mother needs or do anything at that point, the result is just death by default.

Re:Baby Gene Edits Could Affect a Range of Traits by carbocation on Saturday December 15, 2018 @06:49AM (#18688055)
Follow-ups to see what other phenotypes are associated with GWAS hits have occupied a meaningful fraction of the mindshare of statistical genetics over the past few years: GREML, BOLT-LMM’s REML, and MTAG are examples of tools for evaluation and exploitation of the genetic correlation between traits.

I would add that PheWAS is often performed with specific genetic instruments of interest, and can be performed with aggregate measures such as a genetic risk score. This lets you see association across a slew of traits at once.

Re:Baby Gene Edits Could Affect a Range of Traits by subroutine on Saturday December 15, 2018 @08:02AM (#18688225)
I was aware of the Broad tools, but point taken. There's also databases like GeneCards (e.g. bit.ly/APOE_genecards ) or just the NIH genome viewer: (e.g. bit.ly/APOE_NCBI ) which have SNP accession numbers, and annotations for disease-linked variants.

And it's good we are sharing this info. But we are far from having high-powered GWAS for all of human's traits and diseases. And often what we do know is from a single demographic (fwiw mostly caucasian, not chinese). How gene variants influence outcomes in different genetic backgrounds, or within certain environments (think developmental nutrition in africa vs asia) is typically a big questionmark. So IMO performing CRISPR edits to mitigate a problem that was completely avoidable by other means was unethical at best.

Re:Baby Gene Edits Could Affect a Range of Traits by carbocation on Saturday December 15, 2018 @01:02PM (#18689497)
We are in violent agreement about the ethics.

For UK Biobank, there is a GWAS of ~everything: http://www.nealelab.is/uk-biobank/

The lack of diversity in genetic studies is a huge problem. This one isn't just moral, either: we're ignoring the richness of allelic diversity that is found in people throughout the world (particularly in Africa, which has the most genetic diversity because of its pre-bottleneck status). There is an awareness and I think you'll see big changes here in the next few years.

Re:Baby Gene Edits Could Affect a Range of Traits by trashE on Saturday December 15, 2018 @05:29AM (#18687882)
The same thing happens with IVF babies. It shakes up their epigenetics and causes a wide range of health problems which are less common in natural born populations.
Re:Baby Gene Edits Could Affect a Range of Traits by im3w1l on Saturday December 15, 2018 @06:33AM (#18688019)
People get IVF babies because they can't get normal babies. Wonder if it would happen the same if you did IVF with normally fertile people.
Re:Baby Gene Edits Could Affect a Range of Traits by daxorid on Saturday December 15, 2018 @08:34AM (#18688321)
Do you have a source for this? My understanding is that IVF babies have more problems because you are scraping the proverbial bottom of the barrel in terms of egg (or sperm) quality to begin with.
Re:Baby Gene Edits Could Affect a Range of Traits by im3w1l on Saturday December 15, 2018 @06:35AM (#18688025)
So uh how ethical would it be to hypothetically know all that but do it anyway for the knowledge it will provide us for the next iteration.
Re:Baby Gene Edits Could Affect a Range of Traits by subroutine on Saturday December 15, 2018 @11:01AM (#18688877)
If the goal was to prove that CRISPR can be performed safely and reliably in humans I think the first edit should have been in a non-coding segment somewhere far away from genes and gene-regulatory elements; a locus with enough uniqueness (e.g. not a CpG repeat island) to make it extremely improbable that the guide RNA would match another locus resulting in off-target mutations. Why even risk messing around with genes in the very first attempt in humans?? And naturally, like Jiankui, I could be completely off-base (no pun intended), so my biggest qualm was that the decision on where/when/how to edit should have been made by a team of seasoned (perhaps the world's top) geneticists and molecular biologists so they could pool their expertise and come to a consensus.

Many people are interested in seeing CRISPR push forward, and mention something like you have: but what about the "knowledge it will provide us for the next iteration". Trust me, I'm just as eager as anyone. However, if this mavrick experiment fails, and something is remotely off about these little girls (u can bet they will be under a constant magnifying glass), this will end up being a huge setback. It will spook the public, and the legislation factory will churn out regulatory policy that nobody wants.

Re:Baby Gene Edits Could Affect a Range of Traits by Valmar on Saturday December 15, 2018 @11:21AM (#18688974)
If there are issues, then it is very important to abort the experiment, and go back to studying DNA. Altering something so crucial to life, and its life-long health, is fraught with many-faceted issues.

It's dangerous to tinker without a truly full knowledge of what one is doing.

Re:Baby Gene Edits Could Affect a Range of Traits by subroutine on Saturday December 15, 2018 @04:20PM (#18690399)
"Abort the experiment"? Yeah... since we're working with humans now, you can't exactly "abort" the experiment unless the mother has an actual abortion. This plays-off what I just mentioned above; there are a heap of politics to consider now. If tomorrow's headlines read:

    CRISPR Twins Aborted
...it's suddenly a political issue. An issue that could result in ~half the US population calling for regulation due to safety concerns and the other half demanding regulation from an ethical pretext (so, religious reasons).