Re:Baby Gene Edits Could Affect a Range of Traits
by carbocation on Saturday December 15, 2018 @01:02PM
(#18689497)
We are in violent agreement about the ethics.
For UK Biobank, there is a GWAS of ~everything: http://www.nealelab.is/uk-biobank/
The lack of diversity in genetic studies is a huge problem. This one isn't just moral, either: we're ignoring the richness of allelic diversity that is found in people throughout the world (particularly in Africa, which has the most genetic diversity because of its pre-bottleneck status). There is an awareness and I think you'll see big changes here in the next few years.
And it's good we are sharing this info. But we are far from having high-powered GWAS for all of human's traits and diseases. And often what we do know is from a single demographic (fwiw mostly caucasian, not chinese). How gene variants influence outcomes in different genetic backgrounds, or within certain environments (think developmental nutrition in africa vs asia) is typically a big questionmark. So IMO performing CRISPR edits to mitigate a problem that was completely avoidable by other means was unethical at best.