Re:Johnson & Johnson knew for decades that asbestos lurked i...
by lixtra on Friday December 14, 2018 @05:15PM
(#18685366)
> It should be cautioned, however, that no final product will ever be made which will be totally free of respirable particles.
What is the definition of particles? I’m not surprised that talcum powder contains respirable (talc) particles.
Re:Johnson & Johnson knew for decades that asbestos lurked i...
by mikeyouse on Friday December 14, 2018 @05:29PM
(#18685484)
The important distinction is "Respirable" not "particles". Respirable particles are those that are small enough to get into the alveoli of the lungs. Most talc particles are much larger, >25μm, which are easily caught in the nasal passages or cilia in the throat but there's a huge range of sizes depending on the talc source. Small particles (<10μm) can move to the lungs, hence the air quality warnings at PM2.5, PM7.5, and PM10. Particles of that size are particularly dangerous, but moreso when they contain fibrous silicates like asbestos, which are known to cause cancer when respired.
In the Reuters documents, you see repeated references from scientists / consultants to just swapping the talc for corn starch since it has a larger average particle size and a smaller distribution of sizes -- and importantly, doesn't have any fibrous silicates which can't be guaranteed with mined talc.
https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/5080806-2018-lab-rep...
> "Based on the results of our analysis, it can be stated, that individuals who used 1978 Johnson's Baby Powder would have, more likely than not, been exposed to fibrous amphibole asbestos."
Caveats that this likely came from a plaintiff's attorney, but the methods seem solid.
Another fun one from J&J's scientists in 1973:
https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/5005205-April-26-197...
> "The talcs contain widely varying amounts of tremolite or fibrous talc. Our Baby Powder contains talc fragments classifiable as fiber. [...] It should be cautioned, however, that no final product will ever be made which will be totally free of respirable particles."
They knew their product had respirable particles, including nonzero quantities fibrous particles.. they lobbied the FDA to use less sensitive tests so that their products wouldn't fail tests, and they lied about it for the past 40 years. I'm shocked they only lost 10% of their company's value today.