News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by kinkrtyavimoodh on Friday December 14, 2018 @11:30AM (#18682013)
> bad idea about personal finance

Such as?

Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by jartelt on Friday December 14, 2018 @11:50AM (#18682213)
The vast majority of people should just be maxing out their 401k and investing in index funds.

They shouldn't be using Robinhood to buy individual stocks, buy cryptocurrency, or do options trading.

Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by dwild on Friday December 14, 2018 @01:46PM (#18683368)
> They shouldn't be using Robinhood to buy individual stocks, buy cryptocurrency, or do options trading.

What if they do it for fun?

Personally, I would have fun having a few thousands there (but I'm Canadian), it's not worse than having a few thousands over a gaming computer, or gambling at the casino.

If you consider Robinhood as the way to finance your retirement, well you are doing something pretty bad, but that was always true for any stock trading.

Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by vec on Friday December 14, 2018 @05:11PM (#18685340)
If you understand what you're signing up for and still want to dabble in stock trading for fun then sure. Go wild. Everyone needs a hobby. But the homepage of robinhood.com has the following call to action above the fold:

> Investing, Checking & Savings. All for Free.

> Robinhood gives you the tools you need to grow your savings, invest in your future, and do more with your money.

Does that sound like "this is not an appropriate way to finance your retirement" to you?

Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by anthuswilliams on Friday December 14, 2018 @07:10PM (#18686078)
What should their ad copy say instead? "Robinhood gives you the tools to lose all of your money making impulsive decisions" ?

All brokerage accounts advertise themselves as investments, even if the reality is that idiots open them and lose all of their money trading options.

I mean, if you really have this expectation of marketing copy, I don't blame you, that's a totally legitimate position to hold. It's just not one I would expect many people to share.

Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by vec on Friday December 14, 2018 @08:50PM (#18686526)
The grandparent talked about treating it like fantasy sports, and if they advertised themselves like, say, Draft Kings does then it would be one thing. As it is, though, the more thoroughly you trust their representation of how their product should be used the worse off you will be. I usually take that particular trait as a big red flag that a the universe would be better off without the company in question.

And yes, this criticism does apply to most brokerage accounts. Most brokerage accounts don't have half of Silicon Valley fawning over them, though.

Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by SnowingXIV on Friday December 14, 2018 @03:17PM (#18684290)
This is a big part of it, which true some people get burned and lose money. But that doesn't mean they shouldn't do it. In fact, I'd argue it's slightly healthy to have a little bit of skin in the game to understand how these things work. If you're into numbers, it's nothing more than a game or say fantasy football and you can cheer for your favorite players (companies).

Robinhood presents a nice way of making it easy to get into the stock market with a pretty interface and without going through a cumbersome broker and paying fees for things you don't understand. Do seek professional help if you are looking for 401k and retirement guidance.

If anything, RH is sophisticated gambling.

Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by jldugger on Friday December 14, 2018 @12:37PM (#18682687)
I just use Robinhood to buy ETFs for SP500 and AGG without trading fees. I don't have that much left over after maxing out all my tax advantaged options, so trade fees aren't insignificant.

But people like me should recognize that the people using Robinhood to trade individual stocks, buy cryptocurrency, trade options or trade on margin are effectively subsidizing those who do. Along with the participants of Robinhood's funding rounds, I guess.

Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by jkqwzsoo on Friday December 14, 2018 @02:54PM (#18684040)
But you could buy those same ETFs with the same $0 fee on Vanguard (or Fidelity and a couple other platforms now), a substantially more established financial firm, and you could keep your residual cash in well established money market funds like VMMXX, also with $0 fee, or VMSXX for tax-exempt growth.

The only real reason to have money in RH, IMO, is if you're gambling with <$1000 on penny stocks and options-cum-lottery tickets.

Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by te0x on Friday December 14, 2018 @11:35PM (#18687051)
I buy Vanguard ETFs and many other index funds (that Vanguard doesn't offer) on Robinhood. The user interface is 100x better, and why wouldn't I want to keep it all in 1 place? They just need an IRA product and most people would be set.
Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by jkqwzsoo on Saturday December 15, 2018 @01:17AM (#18687326)
What index funds doesn't Vanguard offer?
Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by stickfigure on Saturday December 15, 2018 @10:25AM (#18688673)
Why isn't "the user interface is 100X better" enough of a justification?

I'm not a Robinhood user, but I use simple.com as a bank. It's like every other bank in that it holds money. If anything it's somewhat less convenient than banks with physical branches. But the online UX is so vastly superior to every other bank I've used (large sample size) that I'm a rabid fan.

Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by jkqwzsoo on Saturday December 15, 2018 @03:03PM (#18690090)
Oh, I didn't want to address that because I wasn't sure if the person above was generically referring to all ETFs and ETNs as "index funds", when I was specifically responding to someone who was suggesting that they were using Robinhood for buy-and-hold index investing, buying things like S&P 500 etfs (eg. SPY, VOO, IVV). I was trying to think of what investment-quality ETFs Vanguard might not offer. Leveraged ETNs (TQQQ, DRIP, SPXS, etc.), commodity futures ETNs, and volatility products (e.g. SVXY) may not be offered by Vanguard (I'm not sure, actually), but these products are !!!not!!! buy-and-hold investments which, again, was what I was responding to.

[Anecdotally, someone on r/tradexiv or r/tradevol or somewhere on Reddit had a post about their Vanguard advisor cautioning them about buying XIV earlier in the year, telling them, more or less, "you're either exposing yourself to a lot of risk, or you're too smart to be trading with Vanguard" ...... he was not, it turned out, too smart.]

My claim was that RH should not be where you have money that you use for long-term buy-and-hold investment, even outside of an IRA. I think using RH for speculative investment is fine(-ish) if you accept that their order execution is poor (you don't really see this until you get into options), the company has severe product issues (e.g. the options order error the other day causing them to halt all options trading), and the company is not very well established (so there is a non-zero, greater than average, default risk).

I think it's undeniable that RH's UI is prettier than most other brokers. However, I think it's obvious that "prettier" and "better" are not necessarily the same thing. Again, if you are a buy-and-hold investor (which, again, is what I was responding to), being able to make a quick trade is not important, since you should probably only rebalance your portfolio once a quarter (maybe monthly or biannually, depending on your level of engagement).

But specifically, RH's UI is deliberately minimalistic, to a degree that I think is starting to verge on dangerous. They only recently moved from spark lines to offering optional OHLC bars, and their charts have no axes, which makes it difficult to get a sense of the products price movements. RH doesn't show you historical OHLC data, or historical dividends (just yield). The app offers no stock screening. The charts offer no volume analysis, which makes it difficult to see whether or not you'll be able to exit a position. My mom (who thankfully understands that she should only put money she's willing to lose into RH) recently told me she entered into a position with some low-volume real estate company, and couldn't exit the position for some days due to lack of buyers. She was unaware of the liquidity of the product she was trading (and complained that RH should have warned her... but that's another story).

Even worse is their options platform. At minimum, it's useful to show the days-to-expiration when selecting the expiration date. The options platform deliberately hides important information, such as implied volatility (probably the most important figure for an options contract), Black-Scholes greeks, volume and open interest, and a probability of profit estimate, behind an unlabeled corner button after you've selected an option to purchase. RH introduced multi-leg orders over the summer, but these still don't really give you the tools you need to construct strategies like spreads, calendars, straddles, strangles, condors, and butterflies. These are fairly complex trades with non-linear responses to spot and volatility changes, but RH won't even show you your net position delta before placing a trade (it will show it to you after you've entered a position). If you want to see what a real options trading platform looks like, you can demo ThinkorSwim or Tastyworks. Yes, it's more complicated, but that's because it's necessary.

So no, I disagree with the claim that RH's UI is "100x better". I think it's UI is maybe "50x prettier", but I don't think it's "better" for the user (and I've seen some wretched UIs, like Ameritas). In options trading, I think that RH's interface is objectively worse than those offered by other platform. Unlike checking and savings, which are generally regarded as low-risk activities, I think that RH's UI is deliberately designed to encourage risky behavior, and minimize "information overload" (in favor of "blissful ignorance") in what is inherently a risky activity for which most customers are not adequately prepared, under the thin guise of "democratization" (hence its beeline from stock investing (risky) to stock investing on margin (riskier) to cryptocurrency meme investing (extremely risky, and launched during peak bubble) to options trading (extinction-level-event risky for novices)).

Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by jldugger on Saturday December 15, 2018 @10:09PM (#18691544)
> I wasn't sure if the person above was generically referring to all ETFs and ETNs as "index funds", when I was specifically responding to someone who was suggesting that they were using Robinhood for buy-and-hold index investing, buying things like S&P 500 etfs (eg. SPY, VOO, IVV).

Specifically, I have a boring investment strategy of SP500 and AGG. I'm just seeking the lowest cost means of investing in those two indices. When I opened the brokerage account RH was mostly top of mind. Things have gotten more competitive lately, with Fidelity's 0 expense ratio funds and maybe I should look at Vanguard more carefully. Although 'Vanguard is more established' isn't particularly resonant personally, so to my mind they seem relatively equivalent.

I completely recognize that RH's platform enables a lot of unsophisticated traders to make unwise trades, and leaves sophisticated traders wanting.

Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by artosispylon on Saturday December 15, 2018 @10:37PM (#18691614)
You've convinced me of your point, but I only understood about 25% of what you said. How can I get more educated on this subject? I'm not really interested in actually executing any of these strategies you mentioned, just learning about them.

The extent of my knowledge just comes from reading /r/wallstreetbets for entertainment, while doing passive index fund investing for personal finance.

Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by jkqwzsoo on Sunday December 16, 2018 @09:15PM (#18696489)
I'm far from an expert. I don't trade professionally (i.e. I don't derive my income from it), and I'm a chemical engineer by day.

I think the best resource for anyone starting out investing would be "A Random Walk Down Wall Street" (Burton Malkiel), and maybe "The Intelligent Investor" (Benjamin Graham), even if you don't intend to be a traditional value investor. I think these books (I'll admit I haven't read all of The Intelligent Investor) set your expectations. I also listen to Masters in Business, Odd Lots, and P&L podcasts by Bloomberg (P&L is more short-term, while MiB and Odd Lots are more generally applicable). Both of those books might be floating around the internet.

I also really enjoyed "The Physics of Wall Street" (James Weatherfall). It's a look into how financial mathematics got started and how it has grown and been increasingly applied in modern finance.

If you're interested in options and other derivatives (I find derivatives to be the most interesting, and least arbitrary, financial product), I'd start with John Hull's "Options, Futures, and Other Derivatives", which is a textbook at maybe the sophomore or junior level. I hear the PDF is freely circulated online. I think understanding how options and futures work is essential for understanding finance. A slightly more technical text, "Dynamic Hedging" (Nassim Nicholas Taleb) is also good (and maybe also available online somewhere...). It is less philosophical and polemic than his other books, but doesn't resist calling you an idiot either, as is Taleb's style.

You might also find work on non-ergodicity (Ole Peters), the Kelly criterion, universal portfolios (Thomas Cover, 1991), and Ed Thorpe (a mathematician who derived a precursor to the famous Black-Scholes model) of interest (Ed Thorpe is an incredibly interesting person in his own right). If you find yourself wanting to get into technical analysis, I'd recommend "Evidence-Based Technical Analysis" by David Arons (a spoiler: the evidence is not good). If you're interested in ML applied to trading, I keep seeing references to Advances in Financial Machine Learning (Marcos Lopez de Prado), although I haven't actually read it.

Regarding other financial products, CME has a large number of resources available for understanding futures trading, although futures are generally too high value for regular traders to use safely (the highly liquid /ES contract controls ~$130,000 exposed to the S&P500 and allows one to take about 22x margin, or even as high as 250x for intraday trading). Similarly, there are some nice introductions to the forex market, but again I'd caution you to stay away. And as much as I'd similarly caution you about blindly following their advice (and in general about being a "volatility seller"[1,2] -- see Taleb's book), TastyTrade produces a ton of videos on options trading (particularly retail options trading), which include the mechanics of options trading and how their trading platform works (which is similar to TD's platform -- the CEO/Founder, Sosnoff, was involved in the development of it when he was at TD). You can download TD's ThinkorSwim and paper trade options, or just "preview" their application with delayed prices and see how options work.

Finally, rather than r/wallstreetbets (which is now 99% low quality memes and loss porn), I'd recommend checking out r/options and r/thewallstreet, which are more professional forums, and potentially forums such as EliteTrader and Nuclear Phynance as well.

[0] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/audio/2018-12-07/why-part-of-...

[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-11-29/broker-se...

[2] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-02-06/credit-su...

Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by city41 on Friday December 14, 2018 @01:36PM (#18683281)
You can buy index funds in Robinhood. That's how I use it. Just a simple, to the point, interface for buying and holding index funds.
Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by pertymcpert on Saturday December 15, 2018 @03:09AM (#18687587)
How do you do that?
Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by astura on Sunday December 16, 2018 @01:19AM (#18691996)
ETFs are traded exactly like stocks. For example, if I wanted to invest in the S&P 500 index, I could just buy a few shares of $IVV on Robinhood.
Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by pbreit on Friday December 14, 2018 @04:02PM (#18684731)
You can buy Vanguard and other ETFs in Robinhood. For free.
Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by guelo on Friday December 14, 2018 @09:45PM (#18686724)
No, you have to explain why robinhood is worse than etrade. You can buy the same index funds or individual stocks with either brokerage.
Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by scrumper on Friday December 14, 2018 @11:44AM (#18682162)
Single stock trading sold as an investment product to the low-end of the retail market (i.e. people like me who's limited investment dollars should be dumped into passive, diversified funds.)
Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by kinkrtyavimoodh on Friday December 14, 2018 @11:47AM (#18682183)
As a user of RobinHood I have not felt any specific push for buying single stocks. A lot of people just buy index funds on RobinHood. If RH had made it more difficult to buy those compared to single stocks, your claim might have some weight...
Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by eclipticplane on Friday December 14, 2018 @12:01PM (#18682342)
Push notifications around a pre-defined 'watch list'? Notifications of major stock movements? Showing 'popularity' of a stock? 'Most Popular Under $25'? Gifting people free stock for referrals?
Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by tomnipotent on Friday December 14, 2018 @12:18PM (#18682512)
I had a good laugh at this. I expect a certain level of professionalism from financial businesses, and this sort of fluff marketing / gamification makes my skin crawl... mostly because it tells you about the rest of the maturity of the organization if the product and marketing team is sending out this kind of amateur crap.
Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by Androider on Friday December 14, 2018 @12:55PM (#18682849)
You've got it backwards. The output of the product and marketing team is expertly tailored to target the amateur. Don't for a second think they don't know exactly what they're doing.
Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by ryandrake on Friday December 14, 2018 @12:39PM (#18682708)
Just wait for really fun stuff, like the huge "Buy Stock" button with a tiny "Maybe later..." 8pt link below it. Or "Let us scan your photos and location and have AI generate a TOTALLY LIT suggested portfolio for you!" Or even better: "5 of your friends are currently pumping NVDA! Tap here to write a few naked puts!"
Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by tomnipotent on Friday December 14, 2018 @01:09PM (#18682994)
I can't wait until they bring in all the dark patterns from travel sites; "1,213 people currently considering this stock" or "act now; only 6MM shares left!"
Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by whatshisface on Friday December 14, 2018 @03:09PM (#18684190)
>1,213 people currently considering this stock

If I had browser data from everyone on RobinHood, and was able to track which stocks they were looking at, I might be able to make money front-running.

Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by dontparticipate on Friday December 14, 2018 @06:11PM (#18685770)
The HFTs they are likely selling their data to are probably already way ahead of you.
Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by dunpeal on Friday December 14, 2018 @12:14PM (#18682461)
Right. It would be strange if RobinHood didn't encourage active single-stock trading, since that's how they made their money.

If all RobinHood users followed sound "buy diversified ETF and hold" investing advice, my understanding is that they'd go bankrupt.

Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by kpwagner on Friday December 14, 2018 @12:44PM (#18682748)
I remember hearing one of the founders talking about users trading stocks. He explained their data shows people get better at trading stocks with more experience. I can't remember the source, but I think it was on This Week in Startups podcast. This is really suspect--kind of like a casino telling blackjack players they will get better the more they play.

If Robinhood is incentivizing or encouraging frequent trading by users, that's not really good in my opinion. It doesn't make them worse than other brokerages, but it doesn't make them better either. And with a name like Robinhood, they are positioning themselves as white knights.

Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by acjohnson55 on Friday December 14, 2018 @03:11PM (#18684206)
I've got no problem with people who want to trade as a hobby. They should just treat it like Vegas money. Know you're going lose most of it.
Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by jahewson on Friday December 14, 2018 @11:46AM (#18682175)
Good advice: Normal folks should put their money in index funds - not individual stocks and certainly not options.
Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by rootusrootus on Friday December 14, 2018 @12:50PM (#18682806)
For anybody who isn't comfortable learning a small amount about diversification, index funds are probably the easiest way to guarantee an average return. Probably a good choice.

Still not a panacea, course. What was the ROI on the S&P 500 between, say, 1997 and 2009? Ouch. We've been on a beautiful bull run for the last decade, at least up until a month or so ago. I wonder what the next decade or two will look like.

Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by C1sc0cat on Friday December 14, 2018 @12:22PM (#18682554)
Depends on how well off normal folks are and how long they have been doing it.

I started at £120 a month and it was ten years before I started now my minimum buy is £2000 and I only do the occasional single stock even now 20+ years later.

Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by Swquenzer on Friday December 14, 2018 @11:44AM (#18682155)
Idk why this was downvoted, but I would like to know as well. I feel like a know a decent amount about personal finance, and Robinhood is amazing. Primarily, I can trade stocks with zero fees. The app is easy to use. It's not outwardly pushing me to make bad decisions as far as I can tell. If there are issues on the business side, that's a separate concern(?)
Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by vec on Friday December 14, 2018 @12:02PM (#18682345)
Offering stock trades with zero fees is pushing you to make a bad decision. The vast, vast majority of investors should be making as few trades as is humanly possible, and the small fraction who should be making frequent trades are essentially by definition working with large enough sums of money that the brokerage fees are negligible.

This isn't to say you can't make money as an individual by day trading, but it is to say that the median day trader would have made more money by buying an index fund and sitting on it for a decade.

Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by wuliwong on Friday December 14, 2018 @12:27PM (#18682603)
I don't know. It seems like mental gymnastics to say that zero fees hurts someone without a lot of money. It sounds more like you believe that people with access to limited capital can't understand the markets as well as people with access to large amounts of capital. If you didn't believe that I think you would conclude lowering the fees for trading opens up the possibility for less wealthy people to participate in methods previously only afforded the rich.
Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by vec on Friday December 14, 2018 @04:32PM (#18685010)
I do believe that people with limited access to capital can't understand the markets as well as institutional investors, and you should too. It's not about intelligence, it's about access. The rich have more current information about state of the market than you do and can act on that information sooner than you are able to, which allows them to systematically make slightly better trades than you can.

Stock trades aren't instantaneous, and they're not guaranteed to resolve in the order they were submitted. Wealthy traders can throw money at a combination of locating their servers physically closer to the exchanges and just straight up purchasing preferential treatment from them in order to ensure that their trades will always resolve ahead of yours. Moreover, the "price" of a stock is essentially the rolling average of all the buy and sell offers currently in open. When you "buy" a stock from Robin Hood, what you're actually doing is creating an offer to purchase at or below a specified price point.

One of Robin Hood's main sources of revenue is providing access to that stream of trade offers to investment firms who can use it to "predict the future" in ways that will systematically erode your profit margins. There are any number of ways this happens, but probably the easiest one to understand is that after they see you place a buy offer they can use their position near the front of the queue to accept the cheapest available sell offers ahead of you and immediately resell them to you at your offered price, pocketing the difference.

That's the catch with normal humans trying to play the stock market. You can't actually participate in the same way that wealthy institutional investors do, because you can't afford to pay to be near the front of the queue. In fact, the way you participate essentially guarantees that, no matter how well you do, the institutional investors will be able to do slightly better.

One way to work around this is for normal humans to pool their resources so that they can collectively act as a wealthy institutional investor too. That's essentially what index funds are.

Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by guelo on Friday December 14, 2018 @09:53PM (#18686753)
This is elitist bullshit. I don't have a huge amount of money save but I use about a dozen index funds to stay well diversified, stocks, bonds, international, domestic. And I periodically rebalance my portfolio to stay within my diversification targets. I appreciate not paying a couple hundred dollars a year for my trades.
Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by thesausageking on Saturday December 15, 2018 @12:22AM (#18687203)
There's no such thing as "zero fees". Robinhood is making money by giving your trade orders to hedge funds who then front run them, so you end up paying for it by getting worse prices for your trades.
Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by kgwgk on Friday December 14, 2018 @11:54AM (#18682256)
Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by matte_black on Friday December 14, 2018 @11:38AM (#18682102)
Crypto, options, and margin investing for the unwary masses.
Re:SIPC Says It Has Serious Concerns About Robinhood's New P... by liveoneggs on Friday December 14, 2018 @11:43AM (#18682148)
impulse/app-driven day trading? selling spread as "free"?