Re:MySQL Editions
by robin_reala on Thursday November 04, 2010 @04:37AM
(#1868176)
GPL doesn’t mean you can’t sell it; it means you have to provide source and allow derivative products within the constraints of the license.
Isn't that what I said? It's GPL, so why are people so worried that they are also selling it?
Edit: I guess I can see how you can read it in reverse from what I meant.
Re:MySQL Editions
by randallsquared on Thursday November 04, 2010 @09:26AM
(#1868720)
Isn't that what I said?
"Selling software" is distinct from "preventing others from selling copies of [said] software", and confusing the two is the source of much fear, uncertainty, and doubt about the GPL, so some people get a little defensive when they're conflated. When I ran a small software shop, most of the work I sold to small business was built on libraries and other works that were GPL, but this didn't prevent me from charging money for it, it just meant that I couldn't prevent them from selling or giving away copies themselves. Of course, few small businesses are interested in paying for software and then providing it to their competitors, so in practice that never mattered.
Re:MySQL Editions
by dangrossman on Thursday November 04, 2010 @04:37AM
(#1868174)
You are making the assumption that the GPL is appropriate for everyone that will use MySQL, which is incorrect. ISVs and other businesses that want to distribute MySQL as part of an application can buy it from Oracle with a non-GPL license so they don't have to GPL license what they're selling too.
So clearly they can not be selling software, I can only assume these are prices for support, not for software.
Have they taken down download links? Removed source code?