News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by NorthOf33rd on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @01:40PM (#18666504)
Instagram is not a person. Don't ask it to be decent.

Those ads are not your friends. Don't expect them to treat you like they care.

You're not sharing your information with a human. You're sharing it with a business who is tuned to maximize profit. The ROI on dealing with still births for advertising is probably negative.

They don't care about you. You've made the decision to let a business deep into your personal life, a space once reserved only for loved ones. These are the consequences.

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by allemagne on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @02:52PM (#18667173)
This is mostly very true, but I think the author understands this better than you're implying. The point of this tweet is to influence public opinion. This:

>The ROI on dealing with still births for advertising is probably negative.

would hopefully not be true anymore due to negative PR, companies would take action out of pure self-interest, and it would stop this situation from happening to future people.

There's of course still the broader problem of companies ravenously and irresponsibly gathering as much data on individuals as possible. To me any increase in a company's liability for the information they're hoarding, even in the form of righteous outrage that on its surface seems to anthropomorphize them, is a step in the right direction.

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by BeetleB on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @04:45PM (#18668030)
>This is mostly very true, but I think the author understands this better than you're implying. The point of this tweet is to influence public opinion.

I suspect your parent understands this, and you're not understanding his/her perspective, which is that the general public needs to have a better understanding of how the Internet and monetization works. And that it is problematic to expect almost anything of value from a company you are not paying money to.

They key takeaway in the comment is something everyone needs to understand:

>You've made the decision to let a business deep into your personal life, a space once reserved only for loved ones. These are the consequences.

Yes, the tweeter may be able to influence the company's decision in some minor way, restricted to still births. And it will solve only one small problem. You'll still get plenty of these problematic ads in bad circumstances.

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by kapad on Friday December 14, 2018 @01:17AM (#18678839)
I don't think the author of this tweet is trying to educate the general public. I simply think she is trying to engage companies so that their ad targeting accounts for her case and someone else in the same situation doesn't face what she faced.
Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by totallynotcool on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @07:08PM (#18668801)
> would hopefully not be true anymore due to negative PR, companies would take action out of pure self-interest, and it would stop this situation from happening to future people.

Company X spends Y months advertising baby items to you, then at month Z- due to no fault of your own- a still birth occurs. Company X continues to advertise baby items for A time frame until the algo realizes you are not interested. Unless there's a market for people advertising for services/products for still births- they need better adwords- then there's no loss to the company being paid for the advertisement.

Although extremely sad and very common- not so much so in a 1st world country- company x has no reason to stop. It's the advertisers who are "at fault" and even then, who are they to care about someone else's feelings? Maybe people using these 'free' services need to utilize better coping skills.

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by VikingCoder on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @02:34PM (#18666990)
Any person can ask others to change their behavior.

And if they get the attention of the company, the company may change its behaviors.

Whether out of sympathy or self-interest is kind of immaterial.

As users, we'd like the companies to change their behavior.

Companies rely on users' good will. Once they depend on users for revenue, they need to act to a certain degree as though they care about those users. Or users may leave. These are the consequences.

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by krageon on Thursday December 13, 2018 @08:30AM (#18672129)
They don't rely on goodwill at all. Companies rely on you spending money. The odds of any one person having an attention span long enough to hold a grudge that might have an impact on their wallet are so vanishingly small that they really only need to care about milking everyone for all they are worth. I prefer this explanation, because you can see that it meshes very well with what happens in practice.
Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by VikingCoder on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:45AM (#18673104)
> They don't rely on goodwill at all.

Wow, of course they do.

> The odds of any one person having an attention span long enough to hold a grudge

So... that's why people draw attention to issues like this. To try to organize users just enough to encourage a company to change its behavior.

Or, failing that, to get government to lean on companies to get them to change their behavior.

> I prefer this explanation, because you can see that it meshes very well with what happens in practice.

Companies have been successfully boycotted before. Advertisers leave when consumers get mad enough. Maybe not all of them. But at some point, the platform does actually make some changes, sometimes.

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by ordu on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @04:13PM (#18667824)
> Those ads are not your friends. Don't expect them to treat you like they care.

Why? Why they don't care? Is it technically impossible or what? You know, they can try to care and try to become a friend, maybe ads would work better in that case? How do you think?

What you are doing in your comment is just stating facts that are known for everyone already. For what reason you are doing it? What are you trying to achieve? Are you showing us how cynical you are, that you've grown enough to get lost your naivety completely? It is the case, or there are some other reasons behind your message?

I can say what Gillian is trying to achieve and I believe she is succeding: she will make system more human centered, more friendly to humans. I can understand her, but I cannot understand you.

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by NorthOf33rd on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @04:37PM (#18667974)
She will not succeed in making the system more human centered or friendly. She will succeed in changing the ROI of dealing with advertising to mothers of stillborn children, as another poster stated, by creating negative PR. Those are not equivalent.

You are exactly the person I'm trying to influence by reminding you that these systems care about revenue, not you or your well being.

These facts may be well known, but you are certainly not considering them when choosing your language. You are letting an amoral entity into your very personal life for dubious reasons and expecting it do be "friendly to humans," when they are designed to be friendly to shareholders wallets. It will be exactly as "friendly" as it needs to be, no more. And, if shareholders decide the cost of being friendly is greater than the benefit, then the "friendly" feature will be turned off.

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by trophycase on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @05:00PM (#18668121)
These systems are sociopathic. Full stop. It is in their nature.
Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by sgroppino on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @06:55PM (#18668733)
It'd be depressing if they tried to sell you a funeral service after you let them know of your misfortune... Just avoiding this would be a big win.
Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by wu-ikkyu on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @07:28PM (#18668902)
They did end up showing her an ad for adoption
Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by ordu on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @07:16PM (#18668843)
> You are exactly the person I'm trying to influence by reminding you that these systems care about revenue, not you or your well being.

There are no need to remind me that. I know it. But I know some more. These systems are part of more complex systems of society and of humanity in a whole, these systems are adaptive and reflective. All of them are adaptive, as a small so a large ones. They probably would not change just because some women told they should, but such a system will change itself if there are prospects of greater earnings or treats of losses. PR is important thing that influences earnings and losses, so it is improbable for them just ignore that women. It is less improbable for them to ignore all other similar cases and to react just for stillborn, but I the worst scenario they would need a few more open letters, and then they'll search for all cases like that preemptively, not waiting for an open letter.

Look at Google, it learned to pay attention to AI biases preemptively. Yes, we can argue that google doesn't respect anything except money, but it would be arguing about hidden states of such a system as a google. At the same time "to pay attention to AI biases" is behaviour which you can observe. Shouldn't we prefer to speak about observable phenomena, not about some hidden ones?

> These facts may be well known, but you are certainly not considering them when choosing your language. You are letting an amoral entity into your very personal life for dubious reasons and expecting it do be "friendly to humans,"...

Please, stop making ungrounded assumptions about me. I'm using adblockers aggressively and see no ads. If some ads slip through my defences, I go into troubles to create custom filters to block them nevertheless. I'm blocking even more then just ads, annoying gifs for example (hate them for moving and disturbing my attention). I clear my cookies immediately after tab closes. I'm not using proxies or VPN, but I'm behind NAT and, I believe, there are at least few hundreds others with whom I share IP. Moreover this IP changes time to time. I use ~5 browser profiles with different sets of addons. I'm paranoid about tracking and any ad I can see makes me nervous. So I beg you, do not try to diagnose me by the singled fact I used word "friend" while speaking about advertising company.

And yes, I'm not considering my language, because I just do not look at reality through lens of morality. Morality is not a some kind of shiny fundamental law, morality is a dirty tool in hands of society. Or in hands of some groups. It is really dirty disgusting tool, each time you hear word "morality" you should be alert, the most common reason to speak about morality is to convince others that something amoral is moral, that black is white. So I do not think about morality at all, and when I'm speaking about someone I'm speaking about behaviour, or about hidden reason that leads to observed behaviour. When I'm speaking about "good" or "evil" I always point for whom it is good and for whom it is evil, because there are not abstract "good" or "evil", it is always dependant on point of view. And this case is not an exception. And yes, "friendly" doesn't mean "moral" for me, though it doesn't mean "immoral" too.

> It will be exactly as "friendly" as it needs to be, no more. And, if shareholders decide the cost of being friendly is greater than the benefit, then the "friendly" feature will be turned off.

It is precisely what I meant when I spoke about corporation trying to be friendly. I just omitted the obvious part about money.

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by NorthOf33rd on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @08:42PM (#18669265)
>And yes, I'm not considering my language

Then we're done here.

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by wu-ikkyu on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @07:43PM (#18668970)
>she will make system more human centered, more friendly to humans. I can understand her, but I cannot understand you.

Any marginal increase in human friendliness this may cause is negligible because advertising in general is a inherently "thing" oriented industry worth hundreds of billions of dollars.

It is at odds with human satisfaction and survival.

I am reminded of an MLK quote:

"We must rapidly begin the shift from a thing-oriented society to a person-oriented society. When machines and computers, profit motives and property rights are considered more important than people, the giant triplets of racism, extreme materialism and militarism are incapable of being conquered".

Advertising is the driving force behind the current state of insatiable materialism/consumerism that is leading to the destruction our ecosystem.

With all that being said, "advertising" can indeed be used for "good", human oriented goals, but as it stands it's mostly being used for exploitation.

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by BeetleB on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @04:48PM (#18668045)
>What you are doing in your comment is just stating facts that are known for everyone already.

For the HN crowd, yes. For the general public: Still no. In my experience, most people do not understand this. A lot of people, particularly young people, think that they are entitled to free services like email, instant messaging, and pretty much any service an ad-driven company provides (Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, Snapchat, etc).

>I can understand her, but I cannot understand you.

Read the last line of his comment. (S)he is trying to say that there are negative consequences to revealing so much about yourself to strangers.

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by save_ferris on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @02:12PM (#18666784)
I don't disagree with this, but this argument fails to acknowledge the responsibility of social media companies to communicate what information they gather about you and how they choose to use it. On both fronts, they're still entirely too opaque.

It might not be a fair comparison, but I feel like this argument is the equivalent to smoking for 40 years without realizing that it causes cancer because the hypothetical tobacco companies didn't have to disclose that information. When you go to the doctor and the doctor blames you for your failing health, is that fair for the doctor to do? You did something that was enjoyable and seemed novel without understanding the cost to your health.

Informed consent in social media is still laughable in 2018, and we don't really discuss that aspect of the issue enough IMO.

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by NorthOf33rd on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @02:31PM (#18666962)
Social media companies are incredibly clear about what information they gather and how they will use it: everything and however they want. Is anyone actually unaware of this? The individuals may not consider the consequences, but twitter has no responsibility to tell you that they'll use your pregnancy post to advertise to you, and what the ramifications of that might be. Advertising algorithms are amoral tools put into this world by amoral entities.

The woman's situation is a use case with an ROI attached to it. It's a PBI for Twitter.

Elsewhere in this thread there's a transgender individual. Their use case is another PBI.

The transgender person's use case will be solved first because the transgender community represents more advertising dollars than a grieving mother.

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by danaris on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @04:18PM (#18667862)
> Social media companies are incredibly clear about what information they gather and how they will use it: everything and however they want.

OK, but...the thing is, that's not actually true, however much their less ethical executives might prefer it to be.

They don't, for instance, collect data on what games I play on my iPhone, because that information is not available to them. But while I have enough technical knowledge to understand that they don't have access to that, a) not everyone does, b) while it's true on iPhones, I don't know if it's true on Android—and there may be different answers for "can Facebook track that on Android" and "can Google track that on Android", and c) there are probably things they can do that, despite my relatively good understanding of the subject, I'm either unclear on or at least suspect they can't do.

Similarly, there are many things they don't do with it, because they can't, due either to technical or legal restrictions, or because it's just not profitable. But I'm much less clear on what these things are, and I would very much like to know.

Of course, they don't want us to know either of these things. Right now, most people generally fall into one of two categories: those who, like you, have just thrown up their hands and said, "They collect everything, and there's nothing we can do about it!", and those who don't really know/understand much of anything about it.

Being forced to be clear and open about what data they collect and how they use it would draw attention to it, and make it possible for people who don't want to live like digital doomsday preppers in bunkers to take some reasonable precautions to safeguard their data. It might also get (more) people to say, "Hey, the way you're doing that is wrong, and we should make laws to make that illegal."

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by NorthOf33rd on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @04:44PM (#18668025)
Should have said, "Everything they can that's potentially profitable," but overall I'm aiming for pith over nuance.

I'm not throwing up my hands, I'm here saying: consider the things you're letting into your life and their motivations. There are plenty of things we can do about it. Not share every single detail about ourselves on social media being a good start.

This isn't private data we're talking about with the authors post. It's data she made very public, by choice.

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by danaris on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @06:22PM (#18668598)
But I think that her post highlights some other obvious holes in what we know about what information these companies collect and what they do about it.

Did they notice the posts she made and the behaviour she exhibited after she lost her baby? Did their algorithms capture it in any way, and they just aren't tuned to do anything about it because it's unprofitable?

Or are their algorithms dumber and less all-consuming than we give them credit for?

The whole point is we don't know, and we really, really should.

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by ryanlol on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @07:06PM (#18668791)
>Or are their algorithms dumber and less all-consuming than we give them credit for?

How do you mean? Advertisers can tell exactly how well these algorithms work, they see how much they spend and what they get in return.

It's not necessarily a significant problem if your ad is only relevant to 1% of the people who see it, as long as it's profitable.

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by danaris on Thursday December 13, 2018 @08:35AM (#18672169)
Sure, but there are two separate questions here:

1) Did they successfully determine that she had a stillbirth/miscarriage?

2) If so, did they use that information to improve their ads?

The answer to 2 is clearly "no". Thus, the remaining question is not whether they found it profitable to use the information, but whether they were able to gather it in the first place. Particularly given NorthOf33rd's claim that they're gathering "everything."

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by sigstoat on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @05:50PM (#18668424)
> They don't, for instance, collect data on what games I play on my iPhone, because that information is not available to them.

they would like to reconstruct that information from what they've got, if they could, and they'd probably be more successful than most people would believe if you gave them a zeroth order explanation of "they can't get data outside of their app".

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by save_ferris on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @03:28PM (#18667451)
Technology professionals are well-aware of what information is gathered and how it's used, but I don't think the broad public understands at all. Terms and conditions are still bogged-down piles of text that nobody reads, and the leaders of the big tech firms still dodge many questions directed at them by members of congress, the media, and the public at large.

> Advertising algorithms are amoral tools put into this world by amoral entities.

Are you saying that social media companies aren't subject to moral and ethical scrutiny? I'm really confused by this statement.

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by stabbles on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @02:10PM (#18666773)
It's possible to interpret your comment as a direct response addressing the mother who put out the tweet, which seems very inappropriate. The point you're making might be true, but maybe it's better to rephrase it.
Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by matty22 on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @02:16PM (#18666828)
I also read it as a direct response to the mother who put out the tweet and it seems pretty appropriate to me? What part of the parent comment is inaccurate?
Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by munificent on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @02:48PM (#18667136)
Whether or not it's accurate matters a lot less than whether or not it's kind.
Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by NorthOf33rd on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @02:57PM (#18667220)
She put out a public letter on the internet. We're here discussing it. If she stumbles across this thread, I'm sure she'd be aware that I'm discussing the letter. Not responding directly to her.

If I posted this point to her twitter feed, I would soften the language. But I would do my best not to change my point.

I would soften the language because I have a moral imperative- unlike twitter and instagram.

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by DisruptiveDave on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @02:59PM (#18667243)
Kind doesn't really make for healthy discussions when your definition of kind includes leaving out pertinent information and points of view.
Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by heartbreak on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @03:22PM (#18667408)
Kindness and empathy, or lack thereof, are the point of this open letter. She's asking for more empathy from tech companies. The comment we're discussing lacks empathy altogether.
Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by legostormtroopr on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @04:56PM (#18668098)
If you publish an open letter you invite open responses. Doubly so if you do it on the Internet. Triply so if you work in the media.
Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by anigbrowl on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @08:21PM (#18669166)
It'd be real nice if people stopped using the public aspect of discourse (and especially virtual discourse) as some sort of general-purpose excuse for acting like an asshole. While such behavior is often framed as telling hard truths or suchlike, more often than not it turns out to be trite cliche deployed for sadistic effect.
Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by samirm on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @04:55PM (#18668091)
This is flawed on so many levels.

1. Just because a thing isn't a person, doesn't mean it can't/shouldn't be decent.

2. That thing was designed by humans which, inferring from your post, you can ask to be decent, ergo you can ask their thing to also be decent.

3. It would make a lot more sense for the business to care in the long term, rather than the short term, that's where maximum profit is.

4. I highly doubt she actively made "the decision to let a business deep into her personal life" since most of these services are opt-in by default.

There's really no need to be so narrow-minded and out of touch with reality...

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by anigbrowl on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @08:10PM (#18669112)
You've made the decision to let a business deep into your personal life, a space once reserved only for loved ones. These are the consequences.

Nice victim blaming there, let's hold individuals responsible for the bad experiences they have with the vast data collection and ad targeting infrastructure they're virtually forced to interact with. If only they had been studying the blade instead.

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by NorthOf33rd on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @08:47PM (#18669291)
Victim? She's not a victim. She's upset she saw an advertisement. Aggrieved, offended, dismayed, rightfully very upset about the loss of her pregnancy, but she's not a victim.
Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by throwawaymath on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @09:13PM (#18669390)
I didn't read that as victim blaming. Maybe it's a little callous but I don't think the commenter is trying to shift the blame or responsibility from the companies to the author; instead I read it as trying to change expectations about the level of empathy and humanity the author will receive.

> If only they had been studying the blade instead.

Uh, what?

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by anigbrowl on Friday December 14, 2018 @02:49PM (#18683987)
It's a meme that pokes fun at callous personas. https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/i-studied-the-blade
Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by Riseed on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @03:25PM (#18667431)
> Those ads are not your friends. Don't expect them to treat you like they care.

> You're not sharing your information with a human. You're sharing it with a business who is tuned to maximize profit. The ROI on dealing with still births for advertising is probably negative.

Considering only the profit aspect (because the ethics, social responsibility, and public opinion aspects have already been addressed elsewhere in this thread and on twitter):

Surely it's a better ROI to have a user than to lose a user. Hence, it makes more sense for e.g. "stillborn" be a trigger word that stops/blocks pregnancy-related ads for X time than for the user to be so brokenhearted by the platform itself that they leave.

Surely it's a better ROI to show relevant ads than offending ads. Hence, it makes more sense to show e-counseling ads to grieving eyes than to show them tragedy-reminder ads.

Honestly, this seems like a no-brainer from any perspective.

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by TeMPOraL on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @05:47PM (#18668410)
> Hence, it makes more sense for e.g. "stillborn" be a trigger word that stops/blocks pregnancy-related ads for X time than for the user to be so brokenhearted by the platform itself that they leave.

Only iff you can be confident that the occurrence of this trigger word means that a person indeed experienced stillbirth, and wasn't just researching this, reading up on it because of fear, a non-native speaker looking up the definition of the word, etc. Metrics like this are really only weakly correlated with what (you'd think) they're trying to determine. Even targeted advertising is essentially a shotgun approach, as we don't even know what actually makes a person click on an ad.

Also: as long as (probability of losing an user X their expected lifetime value) is lower than (probability of ad hitting a gullible person X money got from the ad), it's more profitable to just display the ad. People all over the thread seem to think that it's only about losing vs. not losing a user. But there's opportunity cost to not losing a user, and frequently it's judged not worth it.

(It's good the author is raising a stink over this, it shifts the ROI calculations a little bit towards being more humane.)

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by Riseed on Thursday December 20, 2018 @01:07PM (#18727335)
> Only iff you can be confident that the occurrence of this trigger word means that a person indeed experienced stillbirth

As the original tweet pointed out, if there are only searches for "stillborn" and "baby not moving", followed by days of silence (especially with no "vacation" trigger), then an algorithm should be able to figure it out. Especially if friends and family are all commenting with crying emoji and the user has said pregnancy adds "aren't relevant to me".

But of course, I haven't created a multi-billion dollar social network, while Jack Dorsey and Mark Zuckerberg have, so I clearly don't understand how to maximize advertising ROI.

Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by rconti on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @04:02PM (#18667732)
And not only are hashtags stupid, meta-hashtags are vastly more stupid. You're intentionally labeling a thing that no end-user will ever use for its alleged purpose. Nobody has ever wondered what else they will see when they search #justarandomcommentimadeintoahashtagfornorealreason
Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by leowoo91 on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @01:50PM (#18666601)
For integrity of the darkness, I guess they would advertise some sort of a positive psychology product?
Re:An open letter to FB, Twitter, Instagram regarding algori... by MarkMc on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @06:47PM (#18668698)
This is a pretty insensitive comment