I think the parent post has the right idea -- use the existing situation (consumers and producers) and gamify it in such a way that reduces hoarding.
That said, maybe there's a simpler way yet to do that.
2) "We believe you are hoarding, and this is why: . . . "
3) Terminate charging account of hoarders.
There is no theft. If these companies don’t want those contractors doing that, don’t incentivize it or remove them from the platform. Then if they continue to interact with the scooters after being banned, then it’s probably theft.
If these docked at a specific location, the case for “theft” might be an easier sell. But they are literally designed to be left ANYWHERE.
Most theft laws require "intent to permanently deprive" or similar.
If so it’s the taking them without checking them out part that is clearly the problem here.
Come to think of it this might present an easier solution for Bird. If the scooter is moved without being checked out, it’s charger reward price should be frozen at whatever it was at that time.
That can be reset after some period to account for cases where the scooter is moved by a non hoarder, possibly also checking to make sure there are less than N other scooters in a 50m radius to identify those cases where the scooter was moved and dumped on its own and really does need a properly incentivized charger to go find it.
If you're lucky it will end up in the database of stolen bikes and if they come across a stolen bike by accident they might check that database. I haven't personally heard of any bikes retrieved by the police so far.
Alternatively, as others have suggested, you can change the incentives to minimize hoarding.
What do you think sounds more scalable/feasible?
Sure looks like a private company dumping their trash on the streets for profit.
If I was to dump stuff on the street, I'd be cited for littering. And LiIon batteries are hazardous waste.
Second you could just add something to the terms and conditions which allows them to cancel people’s rewards in these obvious cases. “Oh you happened to have 20 scooters at your address for two days and then suddenly charged and returned them. We’re cancelling your account.” Assign someone again to find these obvious examples of people hoarding scooters then cancel their accounts or whatever is appropriate.
As this poster shows, the man power involved shouldn’t be all that much. Browsing on a map. Etc.