News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Firefox Dilemma by dTal on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @05:33AM (#18654365)
>I think about Chrome’s usurping of Internet Explorer (IE), and I wonder (antitrust and all aside) would Chrome have usurped IE if it wasn’t for IE stagnating? I remember when I was younger and jumped ship to Chrome - personally, it wasn’t about using Chrome because it wasn’t IE, it was about Chrome beating IE in a foot race and offering me a clean user experience.

Chrome ate Firefox's lunch, not IE's. Firefox was the first browser to take a chunk out of IE, in large part because of the stagnation of IE6. People were switching away from IE at a fairly consistent rate. When Chrome came along, the rate remained the same, but people started switching to Chrome instead of Firefox.

This graph shows it clearly (starts a little late to catch Firefox's initial bump but you can see the trend): http://i.imgur.com/7bP2pmj.png

Re:The Firefox Dilemma by toyg on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @06:42AM (#18654666)
I agree, and Chrome did that in one simple way: marketing and monopoly power. They leveraged their position in search and webmail to push people to switch, and hammered the message in mainstream advertising (on buses and newspapers, even in Europe). If they had pushed FF instead of building their own browser, now FF would be in that position - regardless of technical merits (which were minor, and basically boiled down to a single one: process-per-tab, which meant the browser never crashed if a single website misbehaved).

FF was not without responsibilities (they got bogged down in backend work on gecko that never really delivered, then got distracted by side bets like FFOS and friends), but without Google's other properties and market share, this would never have happened.

Re:The Firefox Dilemma by kiriakasis on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @07:27AM (#18654863)
> which meant the browser never crashed if a single website misbehaved

I might have faulty memory, but this is not some minor detail. It is world changing.

For young teenager me, Chrome had a vastly better UX than both IE and Firefox when it debuted.

(now I prefer Firefox though)

Re:The Firefox Dilemma by josteink on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @12:51PM (#18657146)
> I might have faulty memory, but this is not some minor detail. It is world changing.

I never had Firefox crash on me, so I never saw it as a selling point.

I however saw tabs crash all the fucking time in Chrome, so to me it just seemed like a workaround for bad engineering.

If anything was world changing to me, it was that now we were being told that tabs crashing all the time was normal.

Re:The Firefox Dilemma by jcbrand on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @07:29AM (#18654870)
> I agree, and Chrome did that in one simple way: marketing and monopoly power.

When Chrome came out, it was much faster than Firefox.

IIRC, it was also an evergreen browser from the start and you could install plugins without restarting.

It was in many ways a superior product.

Re:The Firefox Dilemma by toyg on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @09:49AM (#18655594)
That is not my recollection. When Chrome debuted, some people had bazillion of FF extensions that were bogging it down, installed an extension-free Chrome, and went "much speed so wow". Later Google started pushing JS performance.

It doesn't matter that much anyway - Google didn't make the difference by converting FF users, but by being better than Mozilla at pushing IE users to switch. Which, again, was not a technical issue at all. I would bet that 90% of those users never even tried FF. A lot of them installed Chrome on Windows so they could synchronize settings from their main device, i.e. an Android phone.

Re:The Firefox Dilemma by tapoxi on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @11:05AM (#18656218)
V8 and multiprocess were a huge part of the original announcement comic: https://www.google.com/googlebooks/chrome/

At the time I remember this was a huge performance gain on my machine with my workflow (dozens of tabs), since you could easily open up the Chrome Task Manager and see which tab was causing problems. It was also the first browser to make updates invisible, so I installed it on every family member's PC.

Re:The Firefox Dilemma by webwanderings on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @09:03AM (#18655327)
You would have been down voted to hell for saying this here when Chrome came out. But I bet you know this already.

Google did to Firefox what it did to Yahoo, Altavista, Excite etc. When you can sell ‘6 minutes Abs’ who would buy ‘7 minutes Abs’?

Chrome was faster when it came out. I was on Win7 back in the days and I was being down voted. The proof is in the pudding.

Re:The Firefox Dilemma by doublepg23 on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @10:08AM (#18655746)
I was an earlier believer in FxOS and while it made huge mistakes, I don't think it was a waste of time. A lot of the work that went into getting Fx running well on bottom-of-the-barrel specs (256MB RAM, 4GB flash, 1GHz single CPU etc.) I would argue we still see gains from today. They also helped pioneer Web APIs, improve web permissions, and even useful web tools were made for FxOS that could be used for Fx on Android. Hell, even Google thought the main ideas were solid - look at ChromeOS! A fantastic write-up of FxOS is written about here: https://medium.com/@bfrancis/the-story-of-firefox-os-cb5bf79...
Re:The Firefox Dilemma by Eridrus on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @07:36AM (#18654900)
This seems like an attempt to rewrite history. I was an avowed Firefox user, but Firefox was slow. I bought a EEE PC and Firefox was just too heavy to run, whereas Chrome ran fine.

Eventually all my computers ran Chrome because Firefox wasn't the best option anywhere any more.

Re:The Firefox Dilemma by Yoric on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @07:48AM (#18654954)
As an avid Firefox user, I must admit that Chrome was better for a long time – largely due to two reasons:

- Mozilla diverting devs towards Firefox OS;

- Mozilla attempting to maintain the old XUL/XPCOM-based add-ons architecture.

Both of these hurt Firefox a lot. Since Firefox 57, though, Firefox is back to being really quick.

On the other hand, most (non-dev) people I know who installed Chrome did it for marketing reasons – oftentimes simply because they had installed an anti-virus or Flash, which came bundled with Chrome – not out of actual merit.

Re:The Firefox Dilemma by deuzj on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @08:06AM (#18655037)
That's dishonest. At least, mark it as your point of view. I was eager to switch to Chrome when it came out because Firefox was very slow. Firefox 3 was terrible in that regard and it never got any better.
Re:The Firefox Dilemma by rchaud on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @10:42AM (#18656011)
This is what I remember. Back in 2008 I had a Intel Core Duo laptop with 1GB RAM, and Firefox 3 (I think that was the version number), was horribly slow on it, when previous versions ran extremely smoothly.

When Chrome came out sometime in Fall '08, I used it, and it was faster than whatever FF version I had installed. So I kept using it.

Re:The Firefox Dilemma by jeremyjh on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @05:48AM (#18654445)
That graph begins with IE at 60% share and ends with it at 20% share. It indicates pretty clearly that most of Chrome's growth came from IE, I'm not sure how you can interpret it another way.
Re:The Firefox Dilemma by dTal on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @05:51AM (#18654458)
Look at the slope in the beginning. People would have switched away from IE anyway. The release of Chrome didn't change the number of people switching away from IE, but it stopped Firefox's growth dead in its tracks.
Re:The Firefox Dilemma by zhte415 on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @07:53AM (#18654975)
IE6 stagnation was hated by developers and users alike. Growth of any browser came from something-must-be-better-than-this.

FF had the upper hand against Opera, who were still quite the serious contender. I'm sure someone has done a PhD thesis on this, and if not well worth doing on multi-factor influences on market share for web browsers. Very multi-disciplinary too, covering tech, consumer understanding, embedded incumbents, marketing (a big part in Chrome's boom in my opinion).

Chrome's growth came from IE, yet. But at the time, anyone's growth could have come from IE. Chrome did it better and faster.

* I was still using IE6 in a corporate enviornment in 2013. I have friends that still require IE6 on XP in a company because funding for the system upgrade can't be made. The system's not internet facing, not explicitly. IE6 tried to define the internet, thankfully the internet moved on, and would have moved on. FF was at their tails, Chrome sped that.