News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Companies use smartphone locations to help advertisers an... by izacus on Monday December 10, 2018 @07:18AM (#18647322)
That does nothing for IP based geo location though. Every rest request to modern cloud services gets geotagged and those tags can be surprisingly accurate in populated areas for people that use wifi.
Re:Companies use smartphone locations to help advertisers an... by bad_user on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:32AM (#18647737)
IP-based location isn't very accurate due to IPv4 addresses becoming a scarce resource.

Mobile 3G/4G data networks are reusing those IPs, so at best you'll get a country or state-level accuracy.

The IP of home / business connections can be static and the accuracy can be good, however you're not taking that IP with you when on the move. So in order to track a user's movement, online services have to link that IP to some unique identifier of that user.

It's not insurmountable of course and native apps have no problem in generating such unique identifiers per user, however without consent it's now illegal to use a user's IP for tracking his location under GDPR and it's also illegal to generate unique identifiers for users without consent. Even logging IPs is now illegal, unless you're doing it for security purposes and only for a limited amount of time.

Also the Terms of Use documents aren't sufficient, there are already many lawsuits active and we'll soon hear of the fallout.

Re:Companies use smartphone locations to help advertisers an... by reaperducer on Monday December 10, 2018 @05:44PM (#18651783)
Mobile 3G/4G data networks are reusing those IPs, so at best you'll get a country or state-level accuracy.

If you're lucky. Right now I'm on a Verizon connection that reports me being in New Mexico.

My phone's AT&T connection currently says I'm in Los Angeles.

I'm half a continent away from either of those places.

Re:Companies use smartphone locations to help advertisers an... by mariusmg on Monday December 10, 2018 @07:29AM (#18647382)
>That does nothing for IP based geo location though

Of course, since ip "geolocation" is just ip data + location agregatted from ISPs. How can the OS maker "fight" this ?

Re:Companies use smartphone locations to help advertisers an... by esc861 on Monday December 10, 2018 @07:45AM (#18647458)
Android requires apps request location permissions in order to access Wi-Fi IP info.
Re:Companies use smartphone locations to help advertisers an... by gbear605 on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:03AM (#18647561)
Aren’t they able to get the ip just by connecting to any server?
Re:Companies use smartphone locations to help advertisers an... by esc861 on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:23AM (#18647681)
Yes, although they won't get the whole Wi-Fi scan list, which means no fine grained triangulation, and also no BSSID, but it's definitely imperfect.

It's also very frustrating if you are using the Wi-Fi APIs for legitimate purposes. Having to explain to a user why you need location permissions in order to set up a Wi-Fi peripheral isn't easy.

Re:Companies use smartphone locations to help advertisers an... by izacus on Monday December 10, 2018 @09:54AM (#18648283)
That doesn't matter at all if your request is being location stamped because it came from a Starbucks / your home WiFi IP.
Re:Companies use smartphone locations to help advertisers an... by izacus on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:26AM (#18647705)
By introducing VPN I guess (I think Google offers one on their Fi service) - I don't seen any other solution, especially since telcos sell your data as well.

It's just worth noting that flipping a switch in your OS might not do much in terms of location tracking.

Re:Companies use smartphone locations to help advertisers an... by scarface74 on Monday December 10, 2018 @09:02AM (#18647920)
And then unless you are hosting your own VPN, you have no way of knowing whether your VPN provider is selling your data...