News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Crypto Market Crash Leaving Bankrupt Startups in Its Wake by orbifold on Sunday December 09, 2018 @10:46AM (#18641347)
Given that the biggest threat humanity faces is climate change, support for crypto currencies in their current form is morally corrupt. Also I don’t see a reason why I should buy into some scheme that disproportionately benefits early adopters. I’m already forced to participate in one tilted economic playing field, why expose myself to another one.
Re:Crypto Market Crash Leaving Bankrupt Startups in Its Wake by dsgriffin on Sunday December 09, 2018 @11:56AM (#18641821)
Not all cryptos are the same in this regard. DAG-based ones such as Nano use an absolutely tiny amount of electricity compared to Bitcoin: https://cryptodisrupt.com/nano-is-found-to-be-significantly-...
Re:Crypto Market Crash Leaving Bankrupt Startups in Its Wake by spookthesunset on Sunday December 09, 2018 @04:42PM (#18643460)
Hah! Nothing like recommending a "currency" that lost 97% of its value from it's all time high. Yeah. Sounds good. Where do I buy!?

https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/nano/

Re:Crypto Market Crash Leaving Bankrupt Startups in Its Wake by gskoylvgcfxd on Sunday December 09, 2018 @09:06PM (#18644659)
Re:Crypto Market Crash Leaving Bankrupt Startups in Its Wake by drb91 on Sunday December 09, 2018 @11:47AM (#18641761)
I don’t see how it’s any better to put your money in the bank and have no control over how it’s invested—guns, tobacco, drugs, etc.
Re:Crypto Market Crash Leaving Bankrupt Startups in Its Wake by fastball on Sunday December 09, 2018 @12:26PM (#18642017)
If the promise of crypto plays out, it will have a huge positive impact on climate change.

What a lot of people forget to realize when they talk about how much energy crypto uses is how much energy the systems that are currently in place are already using, which crypto has the potential to replace.

One such example might be property ownership and title companies. Title companies are big business. They have large buildings, they have many employees. The sum total of the resources being used by title companies have a huge carbon footprint.

Crypto could eliminate title companies. A blockchain is the perfect solution for storing records of property ownership in a way that is incredibly well-suited for the mostly digital age we find ourselves in, and would be vastly more efficient than the way we currently manage property ownership and transfer.

If blockchain tech becomes relevant to the point where we should be concerned about its carbon footprint, that means it's replacing things which currently exist which already have a huge carbon footprint.

Re:Crypto Market Crash Leaving Bankrupt Startups in Its Wake by ac29 on Sunday December 09, 2018 @01:00PM (#18642218)
> Crypto could eliminate title companies. A blockchain is the perfect solution

Ah yes, nothing like losing the title to your house because you can't remember the password to decrypt your private key.

Re:Crypto Market Crash Leaving Bankrupt Startups in Its Wake by fastball on Sunday December 09, 2018 @04:42PM (#18643462)
Why do you think you would need to maintain 100% ownership of your private key?

The more relevant aspect of blockchain in this example is the hashed distributed ledger, not the transactional nature of it. In fact, there is no reason you'd need to use PKC type transactions at all.

Re:Crypto Market Crash Leaving Bankrupt Startups in Its Wake by saati on Sunday December 09, 2018 @01:19PM (#18642324)
Bitcoin uses as much electricity as a small sized country with industry and everything, all the banks in the world use way less energy.
Re:Crypto Market Crash Leaving Bankrupt Startups in Its Wake by fastball on Sunday December 09, 2018 @05:19PM (#18643658)
You're joking, right?

All the banks in the world expend far, far more energy than any small country, probably any medium country as well. And banking is only one of the many things that could be changed by blockchain tech.

Re:Crypto Market Crash Leaving Bankrupt Startups in Its Wake by saati on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @04:14AM (#18662455)
Do you have any proof for that?
Re:Crypto Market Crash Leaving Bankrupt Startups in Its Wake by fastball on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @05:02AM (#18662641)
Math?

There are thousands upon thousands of banks around the world. Each one of these banks is going to have at least one branch. Some have tens of branches. Some have hundreds. A few might have thousands. Each of these branches is going to have at least a handful of employees. Some will have more like 10-50. Then there are the corporate structures to the banks, entirely outside of retail locations. Thousands upon thousands of corporate employees for the big banks, hundreds as you go down.

The result is hundreds of thousands of retail bank branches (if not millions), and definitely millions of bank employees.

That is just relevant to the people and building upkeep (air condition, lighting, etc) for retail locations.

Then you have the fact that big banks will have their own datacenters. Any bank with online banking will need to be consuming a lot of electricity to host those services. Any bank with telephone banking needs to consume energy in order to keep those phone lines available. A lot of these banks will then either be integrating with each other or integrating with a 3rd party for more modern settlement. Either way, this process consumes electricity.

Then there is the amount of paper / other supplies that these countless banks are consuming. It's a lot. All of these things have an associated energy cost.

---

But you think there is the slightest chance that bitcoin/ethereum/etc are consuming an equivalent amount of energy and resources? Really?

Throw in the fact that a lot of mining operations are utilizing waste energy and you have yourself a consumption comparison that is laughable considering how tiny blockchain is compared to banking.

Re:Crypto Market Crash Leaving Bankrupt Startups in Its Wake by rdiddly on Sunday December 09, 2018 @12:51PM (#18642167)
A worthwhile argument, though it would benefit from having some actual magnitude numbers for comparison.
Re:Crypto Market Crash Leaving Bankrupt Startups in Its Wake by tim333 on Sunday December 09, 2018 @11:00AM (#18641440)
If you're worried about climate change you can choose one that doesn't have proof of work (of the top 5, EOS and Stellar with maybe Ethereum to follow). Not sure about early adopters - if buying into early Amazon, Apple etc made the buyers rich is that a problem?
Re:Crypto Market Crash Leaving Bankrupt Startups in Its Wake by gammateam on Sunday December 09, 2018 @11:37AM (#18641691)
The majority of cryptocurrency mining by hash rate is done using renewable energy.
Re:Crypto Market Crash Leaving Bankrupt Startups in Its Wake by IAmEveryone on Sunday December 09, 2018 @12:33PM (#18642056)
Yeah. Because previously, China built all these hydro dams in the wilderness, unconnected to the grid?
Re:Crypto Market Crash Leaving Bankrupt Startups in Its Wake by gammateam on Sunday December 09, 2018 @01:47PM (#18642477)
The connection to the grid doesnt make it a nonrenewable or an increased environmentally unsound proposition?

The additional energy draw is using renewable sources for most of the mining hashrate

Re:Crypto Market Crash Leaving Bankrupt Startups in Its Wake by randaouser on Sunday December 09, 2018 @12:58PM (#18642199)
Animal farming is the biggest cause climate change; before you try to rid the world of crypto, you can personally go vegan and make a larger impact
Re:Crypto Market Crash Leaving Bankrupt Startups in Its Wake by decentralised on Sunday December 09, 2018 @10:52AM (#18641380)
I bet you feel the same way about minerals whose extraction process is vastly more damaging to the environment.

Early adopters benefit because they incur more risk than later adopters.

Re:Crypto Market Crash Leaving Bankrupt Startups in Its Wake by woodruffw on Sunday December 09, 2018 @11:02AM (#18641452)
> I bet you feel the same way about minerals whose extraction process is vastly more damaging to the environment.

I don't understand this reasoning: is "X is bad but Y is worse" supposed to convince people that X is actually good?

I think everybody with sufficient information would agree that we should limit both harmful mineral extraction and the runaway energy usage of cryptocurrencies.

Re:Crypto Market Crash Leaving Bankrupt Startups in Its Wake by decentralised on Sunday December 09, 2018 @11:08AM (#18641486)
>I don't understand this reasoning: is "X is bad but Y is worse" supposed to convince people that X is actually good?

Maybe don't read things that are not written or said? My point is that you think cryptocurrencies have a negative impact on global warming so I think you probably feel the same way about mineral extraction.

Most people will fight any new information that contradicts their held beliefs so I won't suggest you look at the use of renewable energy in cryptocurrency mining or try to convince you that most miners optimise their costs by using solar and hydro power.

Re:Crypto Market Crash Leaving Bankrupt Startups in Its Wake by woodruffw on Sunday December 09, 2018 @11:21AM (#18641570)
> My point is that you think cryptocurrencies have a negative impact on global warming so I think you probably feel the same way about mineral extraction.

Phrased as such, it sounds like you're calling me or the GP a hypocrite. But to be clear, I do care about mineral extraction, and I try to make choices as a consumer that limit my (relatively small) effect on the overall market.

I have quite a few friends who work in the cryptocurrency space (either at ICO'd firms or as professional auditors), so I'm familiar with the economics of choosing clean energy sources. But that neither factors in the net increase in grid demand nor the double-bind of hydro power in places like China. So I don't think we're off the hook, morally speaking.

Re:Crypto Market Crash Leaving Bankrupt Startups in Its Wake by DonHopkins on Monday December 10, 2018 @04:05PM (#18651157)
Cryptocurrencies are China's way of exporting coal through the atmosphere.
Re:Crypto Market Crash Leaving Bankrupt Startups in Its Wake by elorant on Sunday December 09, 2018 @11:18AM (#18641551)
Minerals have a use though. What exactly is Bitcoin's use?
Re:Crypto Market Crash Leaving Bankrupt Startups in Its Wake by decentralised on Sunday December 09, 2018 @11:52AM (#18641788)
Money.
Re:Crypto Market Crash Leaving Bankrupt Startups in Its Wake by coderzach on Sunday December 09, 2018 @11:00AM (#18641431)
The problem is that if the state were to provide secure public-private key cryptographic identity, there would be absolutely no need for PoW or PoS. Eventually we'll figure that out, and all of this work will haven been useless.