Prop 19 was spectacularly flawed. Among other things:
* It created a new protected class of employees in California with a clause that said "discrimination" against pot smokers was unlawful, modulo only circumstances where an employer could claim marijuana was actually harming job performance. The bill actually says that! Race, color, religion, gender, national origin... and pot smoking.
* The bill was remarkably fuzzy about the driving issue. Yes, it says you can't smoke and drive. But it also created circumstances where you could clearly be under the influence of marijuana and operate a motor vehicle.
In both cases, the underlying motivations behind these egregious overreaches seems to have been the concern that MJ metabolites are long-lived, and people would get fired or lose their licenses for smoking several weeks ago. At least as regards the driving situation, that seems like a valid concern... but the answer to that problem isn't a law with gargantuan loopholes.
Prop 19 may have lost in part because its campaign was incompetently run, but it also lost because the proposal was incompetently written. And those two issues fed on each other: read the political analyses to hear about the pro-pot groups that sat this one out because of the flaws in the measure.
I choose not to interpret this as a setback for legalization, but as proof that prohibition is in its dying throes.
I'm pretty sure some people believed that in the 70s as well.
I was not alive during that time, and any clarification would be appreciated.
A 45% showing makes it a definitively non-fringe opinion and moves the http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overton_window
We'll end prohibition eventually, but we need to vote on it in an election year where voter turnout isn't based on how much they fear the president.
I think you're probably right. 45% is close enough to winning that I can easily imagine this succeeding in 10 years time.
It's not really a recent trend or specific to the Christian Coalition variety of conservatives; a belief in the importance of a stable social order, and an avoidance of rapid change or rampant hedonism, is a pretty core part of conservative political thought going back centuries (Edmund Burke is a frequent point of reference).
My observations of who libertarians grit their teeth and vote for is that it depends on which kinds of government power bug them most. Are you most angry about taxes? Or about the war on drugs? About business regulations? Obscenity laws? Permits and fees? Sodomy laws? Etc.
As much as each side tries to brand itself with various ideological sympathies, their actual politicians don't differ that much on most of the issues - and their supporters will excuse them endlessly and hector you about how the other guys don't even give you the wonderful lip service they practice.
There are a lot more conservatives than reactionaries, most of the tea party is talking about rolling back spending/government to right about the day President Obama was sworn in. They didn't suddenly become Libertarians.
"a conservative wants to preserve the status quo"
A fourth-grade textbook explanation, but one that has little connection to the ideology or to the political party most commonly deemed "conservative". What's status quo about wanting things like overturning Roe v Wade, constitutional amendments to stop gay marriage, stringent anti-immigration efforts, or invading the Middle East? Hell, what on Earth was status quo about 2001-2008?
"this is not a slight on libertarians, just making it clear there is a distinction between people who like what we have now and people who want to roll back even what we have now"
More making it clear that you don't know much about libertarians, or are only dimly aware of libertarians not wanting particular government programs you're fond of. What's "reactionary" about wanting to abandon the military imperialism of the last, oh, century or so? What's "reactionary" about open borders, or wanting to end the drug war, the war on terror, agriculture subsidies, and eminent domain abuse?
ETA: And how do anarcho-capitalists fit into this setup? :)
Results are still coming in, but given how close most of the major races were (+/- 5% points in many cases) I don't think you can say conservatives weren't favored. If it was 80/20 I think you could say they were not favored.
Looking back to previous elections, this has been a big turn out for GOP in CA
Also, some Republicans like John Dennis were actually pro 19 (http://www.baycitizen.org/elections-2010/story/san-francisco...)
Obviously the monied interests will have a louder message (prison unions, growers).
Also, why did you use "agin'" rather than "against"?
Sharp lines were drawn. For example, the founder of the first (then unlawful under state law) dispensary -- and a kind of "father of the moment" was quite against Prop 19. He and the author of the proposition had a falling out and parted ways in a joint business activity.
Various growers were against it. They are already dealing with falling prices and the perception was that Prop 19 would greatly accelerate that. That kind of political sentiment easily "trickles down" through the various supply chains.
Within the industry the main monied supporters look like folks who expected to make a cool quick few million in retail trade.
Those are the lines of a feud. Hence, the regionalism of "Are ya fer it? Or again' it?" [traditionally stereotyped as a question that comes from someone pointing a shotgun at you while asking].
A fair number of casual users were looking forward to their 5x5 personal plots and/or safe and (state-level) legal dealing --- but others were scared away by the "no" campaign's characterization of the implications of Prop 19.
It came down to the fact that conservatives by their nature like order, hierarchy and organization and liberals tend not to. Liberals won't come together to discuss an agree to the same media talking points where as the conservatives love to -- and more importantly they'll all stick to them which amplifies the message. This is what is leading to the total pwnage of the lib's by the cons in mainstream media.
The issue for Prop 19 is that you have a very organized and disciplined conservative movement in the NO corner and a very sparse group of liberals who all have their own perspectives with no serious critical mass in the YES corner. Paul Buchheit may have given $100k to the YES campaign, but did that group officially represent the existing legal pot growers, smokers advocacy groups, etc? I don't believe it did - they couldn't organize themselves because there are no aligned interests there.
As a European, I consider myself a liberal by US politics if that is relevant. I've never smoked marijuana but I've found this campaign to be incredibly interesting as a barometer for current political landscape
(You can listen to the program at http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/417/t... - see "Act II - Mr Hitt goes to Washington")
It is a crappy argument when we make it, too.
The conservative political establishment is much, much more fractured on the issue of drug legalization than you appear to believe they are. The most influential conservative opinion magazine in the country is pro-legalization and has been for, literally, decades now. It is quite contentious within the Republican Party. See also immigration.
Not saying it's all conservatives, just a significant chunk. And, yeah, cultural liberals exist too but we don't have the anger level, you never see liberals get angry about the heartland the way conservatives are angry about "libs".
EDIT to reply since I'm heading out the door: Yeah, signs at rallies, plus Rush Limbaugh, Glenn Beck, Sarah Palin, several people I met while canvassing, every outspoken conservative in my hometown that I've heard from..
Yeah, SF contrarian-libertarians don't talk like that. But a significant subset of the conservative movement does. We'll see if it changes now that they don't feel so emasculated after taking the house.
I'm a midwesterner, by the way. And libertarians kind of drive me nuts. I'm talking about Republicans.
Yesterday was really the worst.
Always keep in mind that these guys (and yes, their equivalents on the Left) are not experts in political science and philosophy. They are entertainers first and foremost, and their job is to be provocative. The day they say "You know, today everything is copacetic" is the day people stop listening and they lose their jobs.
Whether or not those guys are stupid (and I agree that they are), they certainly have a constituency and are representative of a big chunk of the Republican party. Heck, anytime a Republican politician says anything bad about Limbaugh they wind up apologizing for it.
Honestly, I think that this is just so much self-congratulations on the part of the Liberals.
Brian Eno made exactly the same observation in his published diary. Liberal tendencies might prove adaptive in the longer term though, if they keep the left ahead of the right WRT social and demographic change.
This was a legalization measure that, before anyone else much cared, split the pro-pot base. Many commercial (grey and black market) growers were agin' it (fearing a market crash). Many medical pot providers were agin' it (fearing being taxed to death and/or getting shut down in the ensuing chaos, stranding needful patients either way). In "the community" of casual tokers, BS rumors were all around about various ways in which Prop 19 was eeevil.
So, right off the bat, the base was split.
Then, for everyone else, comes a lot of other BS like "this will legalize driving while stoned; this will legalize getting stoned at work; etc. And all because -- while legalization might be a fine idea -- this law is badly flawed."
Well, actually, a lot of that BS was pretty far off the mark but it was convincing enough to scare away a lot of voters who might otherwise have been fine with legalization.
NOBODY on the yes campaign made the serious and needed case about lowering the incarceration rate, about undermining organized crime, etc.
Frankly, I never saw any serious message from the "yes" campaign. I couldn't tell you their talking points if I wanted to. Meanwhile, the "no" campaign's are easy to tick off one by one.
Prop 19 lost because the "yes" campaign was very -- amazingly -- incompetently run.