The opponents point to the large number of green energy jobs that can be directly attributed to AB32 plus the obvious environmental benefits.
Personally I find the job loss argument hard to quantify because there is no direct correlation while it is pretty easy to count the number of green energy companies and the resulting jobs that have sprung up in California.
Also, it is pretty much impossible to ignore the fact that the proponents of prop 23 that are touting blue collar job losses as the reason to suspend AB32 are not the folks who traditionally would give a crap about blue collar job losses.
The list of Donors for prop 23 is pretty telling:
http://www.ballotpedia.org/wiki/index.php/California_Proposi...
Compare that to the list of opponents:
http://www.ballotpedia.org/wiki/index.php/California_Proposi...
Pretty amazing that 42% (as of the current numbers) voted Yes on this one.
Where did you find a logical discussion on this topic?
Who is Texas Oil? What are the positives about the environmental bill that would be lost? Scare? Does that mean there's no logical argument for potential job-loss?
You can find more details on wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Proposition_23_(2010...
It covers the three refineries that are the primary donors, two from texas and one in kansas city. the fact that ab32's suspension would be for very long time (because unemployment is unlikely to be below 5% for a year for a very, very long time -- if ever.)
There is an argument, but it's assumptions aren't good. The long-term job growth from green business will FAR outpace job loss from AB32. Further, if job loss was a real concern, one would expect to see pro-labour interest groups come out in support of prop 23, which did not happen!
Even the California utilities (who will lose fiscally) from AB32 have come out against Prop 23.