The cost basis alone of the Times website is clearly and massively wrong. At the very least if this business decision is good (losing 99% of your audience and hiding yourself from Google is at best dubious), but if it still makes sense, someone else can come along and undercut them on cost and make even more money.
People will pay more for quality. No offense to you, but your blog would likely not be considered that by 100k people, at least not enough to pay. (Neither would mine). Quality content costs real money to produce, some schlub like you or me writing our opinions online does not.
Charging certainly wouldn't work for bloggers, but it just might for outlets like this or the WSJ or the NYT. There's a market for both.
You'll essentially be making $1/hour. Advertising doesn't generate anywhere enough revenue to cover a journalists salary let alone the overheads of a news gathering organization.
According to the NYT's 10-K [2], 53% of revenue comes from advertising! Yet in 2005, 66% did [3].
Also remember as print subscribers fall off, those costs fall off too. The raw cost of materials was around 30% of subscriber revenue, although I think they trimmed the size of it down to help out there. Wages for the actual print side are another fair portion.
So, contrary to other claims, it would seem that advertising generates quite enough revenue to cover journalists.
EDIT: Perhaps _online_ advertising isn't enough to cover salaries, but that's a separate issue. The newspapers are trying to make a transition as that nice money from advertising (especially classifieds) dries up. They can whine and complain about people "getting stuff for free" but it doesn't change the fact they are painfully adjusting to a new business model.
1: http://www.naa.org/TrendsandNumbers/Advertising-Expenditures... 2: http://investing.businessweek.com/research/stocks/financials... 3: http://www.nytco.com/pdf/annual_2005/2005NYTannual.pdf
I think it has a valuable lesson for entrepreneurs that sometimes taking the unpopular route can be the correct business decision.