But seriously, even if you consider phones as more distracting than papers, well keep in mind that many people in cities just don't want to be talked to, especially not on their daily commute or what not. I mean, try striking up a conversation with someone on the Tube when in London. They'll probably look at you as if you're mad, and that's been the case for decades.
Hell, they even tried that recently, and people weren't having any of it:
https://www.citylab.com/life/2016/09/tube-chat-no-thanks-say...
Makes me wonder if large cities/groups in general kill conversations and people's interest in being social more than anything else.
I do see the 'tourist asks if they can get to ___ on this train' conversation but don't really consider that in the context of the OP.
Where I live there seems to be an agreement that interactions are limited to a smile and a hello how are you? The expectation is that you will respond with something positive. Nobody really wants to know your depths of dispare. I have a feeling that if somebody did really respond that they were desperatley lonely then in general most people would engage with a noncommiting conversation.
People were walking around looking at their cellphones before smartphones or social media took off. They were sending SMS messages. Or playing snake in monochrome. Or would you ban SMS as well? What about phone calls?
Block map sites, people would ask others for directions.
Chronically lonely people aren't going to get any meaningful fix asking strangers for directions.
Block movie streaming sites and people would get to the cinema more often.
Again, if you are lonely and have no friends, going to the cinema is just being in a room full of strangers. People go with their own groups. It's probably more alienating than just chilling out at home because it emphasizes your loneliness.
The thought is that technology replaces human interactions and that is not always good because it might lead to less people to people communication.
Religious services also made people come together in the community but nowadays people are less religious.