Think about how different the official Twitter client would be for example. Refreshing the feed by dragging the list of tweets down; something that feels intuitive, just right, on the iPhone and iOS; would seem weird and retarded on OS X.
Or how about when you swipe over a Tweet (or any list-view item) to manipulate it? Works great in a touch/direct manipulation interface. That would be incredibly poor UI design on OS X. Astoundingly bad. Buttons and widgets would be oversized on OS X. Form factor and layout would be needlessly limited. Etc, etc.
We've created a new class of direct-manipulation apps on the iOS devices that we just can't bring to the other machines without using a mouse...or turning them into iPads.
iOS apps on OS X would feel terribly weird and out of place, since, again, they're made for an entirely different user interface paradigm.
They'll make a lot of money off the Mac App Store though; because the software on it will be great. As opposed to weird.
vertical touch = bad : horizontal touch = good
That pointer gives you increased accuracy, speed, etc. But it also means your hands and fingers don't block your view of the screen. All things put together you end up with a drastically different way of interacting with your computer.
People who aren't UI or UX designers may gloss over these things. But Apple is obsessive about this stuff.
I too think that Apple cares deeply about UX, but you're probably discounting the enormous amount of money/users that could be made if this evolution could be made to fly?