News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An online dating site for ugly people - welcome to reality by mattmaroon on Monday November 01, 2010 @11:27AM (#1856765)
I see two primary problems with this idea.

#1. Most ugly people don't want to date someone else ugly. This is especially true for men, who typically care far more about their mate's appearance than their own.

#2. Most ugly people aren't conscious of their ugliness, or if they are, they at least aren't comfortable enough admitting it to sign up for this service.

Re:An online dating site for ugly people - welcome to reality by rokhayakebe on Monday November 01, 2010 @11:45AM (#1856862)
1- True, but if you are ugly and have little else to offer than you will settle for ugly.

2- I think we will see lots of decent looking people signing up because they think "in a pool of ugliness I will beauty queen", and that will help. For example in the latest members section, the girl on the top right is not ugly.

Re:An online dating site for ugly people - welcome to reality by quizbiz on Monday November 01, 2010 @09:37PM (#1858951)
But who wants to meet a future spouse on a dating site for ugly people? Rather, an ugly person would prefer a dating site for smart people or mac enthusiasts or music enthusiasts, etc.
Re:An online dating site for ugly people - welcome to reality by discolemonade on Tuesday November 02, 2010 @09:00AM (#1860224)
There's still an element of stigma around online dating. When you combine that with the fact that nobody wants to admit to others and especially to themselves that they settled, this site is a trainwreck in the making... assuming it isn't some sort of a prank or something. Nobody intentionally goes out looking for ugly people to date.
Re:An online dating site for ugly people - welcome to reality by pedanticfreak on Monday November 01, 2010 @01:27PM (#1857280)
#1 People of similar attractiveness do tend to gravitate toward each other.

#2 People of all levels of attractiveness are able to measure other people's attractiveness on the same scale with relative accuracy.

Dan Ariely has a very good talk on this over at bigthink.com:

http://bigthink.com/ideas/20752

Given this, I think stratifying dating sites on attractiveness would actually improve successful match rates. Whether you can do this all in one site or need to create stronger logical boundaries is really a matter of implementation.

Re:An online dating site for ugly people - welcome to reality by rogerclark on Monday November 01, 2010 @03:14PM (#1857775)
OkCupid already has a form of this stratification in place. I'm just not sure how obvious it is (or whether people should even know about it).

If people consistently rate your photos higher, after the ratings clear a certain threshold, the system considers you "attractive." The system sends you an email congratulating you and about how "you'll be shown more attractive matches from now on."