News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Talent Wants Transit': Companies Near Transportation Gai... by ip26 on Thursday November 29, 2018 @03:06PM (#18563453)
people in the latter group do not want just to live in houses with gardens. They want to live in houses with gardens where their neighbours also have houses with gardens.

If the apartments threaten to block the sun for your garden, is it really totally irrational to care?

You might think gardens are stupid, but you've got to admit gardens generally require sunlight!

Re:'Talent Wants Transit': Companies Near Transportation Gai... by Sharlin on Thursday November 29, 2018 @04:21PM (#18564125)
Which is why tall buildings are not generally built right next to and to the south of low buildings, never mind gardens. This is straightforward planning 101.
Re:'Talent Wants Transit': Companies Near Transportation Gai... by dantheman on Thursday November 29, 2018 @04:04PM (#18564000)
I'm sure the neighbors will be happy to sell the air rights above their buildings so that plants can get that sunlight. Which I'm sure would promptly sold by the garden owner o because its worth a lot of money. It's a classic, well I don't personally profit and in fact lose a little so I'll stop them from doing it -- I could try to bargain with them (compensate them, etc) but I choose not to.
Re:'Talent Wants Transit': Companies Near Transportation Gai... by ip26 on Thursday November 29, 2018 @04:16PM (#18564090)
I think it's simpler than that; I think there's a subconscious application of the doctrine of prior use. If I'm using the sunlight to grow plants, I feel like somebody shouldn't be able to roll in next door and shade my garden with solar panels. There's plenty of precedent, see water law in the West.
Re:'Talent Wants Transit': Companies Near Transportation Gai... by estebank on Thursday November 29, 2018 @10:35PM (#18566438)
And California also has problems dealing with water pricing during draughts due to the that precedent.
Re:'Talent Wants Transit': Companies Near Transportation Gai... by pessimizer on Thursday November 29, 2018 @05:34PM (#18564777)
> I'm sure the neighbors will be happy to sell the air rights above their buildings so that plants can get that sunlight.

Or the majority of the people that live somewhere will have all "air rights" controlled by the city, and dictate how tall things can be built. "Air rights" aren't a thing unless the jurisdiction makes it a thing; you can't charge a toll for planes passing overhead.

Why would you "bargain" with someone who doesn't own anything that you want? You're talking about compromise, not bargaining, and that involves a friendly relationship; the kind normal people living in a home don't have with anonymous developers.

Re:'Talent Wants Transit': Companies Near Transportation Gai... by dodobirdlord on Thursday November 29, 2018 @10:53PM (#18566521)
> you can't charge a toll for planes passing overhead

You can up to at least 365 feet, and sometimes higher depending on jurisdiction.

Re:'Talent Wants Transit': Companies Near Transportation Gai... by stale2002 on Friday November 30, 2018 @03:06AM (#18567527)
They almost certainly do own something that you want. That thing is usually money.

I am sure that the vast majority of garden owners would be willing to accept a couple thousand dollars in exchange for having slightly less sun hitting their house.