News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Competition Is Dying, and Taking Capitalism with It? by lgregg on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @11:53PM (#18558200)
I think when people say "fake capitalism" or "true capitalism" they're talking about unrestricted and unregulated free markets. It's also important to realize that the thought tied to Communism and Capitalism is one in the same; I'm sure most would be surprised that Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels were the ones that coined the phrase and idea of Capitalism.

> Capitalism sets up incentives for people to figure out regulatory capture and lobbying in whatever regime you come up with. Capitalism sets up incentives for companies to influence the public to believe that certain forms of government intervention are perfectly natural (take copyright, for instance - if you convince everyone to get rid of copyright, you'll just set up incentives for companies to convince everyone to bring it back). If you think this isn't working right, please work with the folks who want to figure out an alternative.

I like your line of thought but I'm unsure if I agree with the fact that copyright could be incentivized to come back but that's just an opinionated view of mine. It started with the structure of the government from the beginning making it was a day 0 idea. There are also different types of capitalism; China's capitalism is different from US capitalism. So, that also is something to consider with the "fake capitalism" issue you brought up.

Overall, I think one baseline to be able to tell if capitalism is working is if one can actually go from rags to riches in today's time. I also think what people are picking at is the imbalance that happens at an economy of scale when a company becomes so large that it is the market.

Re:Competition Is Dying, and Taking Capitalism with It? by why_only_15 on Thursday November 29, 2018 @01:12AM (#18558445)
Capitalism lacked a single intellectual backing in the way that communism did (speaking in general terms). Wikipedia also says differently on the etymology of capitalism - Louis Blanc was apparently the first person to use it in the modern sense [0].

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capitalism#Etymology

Re:Competition Is Dying, and Taking Capitalism with It? by TangoTrotFox on Thursday November 29, 2018 @12:56AM (#18558403)
I think the key distinction is capitalism vs corporatism. Corporatism is feudalism wearing a capitalist mask. The elite companies in the top do operate in a free market, but the story for the rest of society is radically different. I think in the US today we have a corporatist society. Your kid wants to setup a lemonade stand on the lawn? Get ready for a visit from the police. A multinational corporation wants to produce and sell a product that involves a real possibility of poisoning the groundwater? Sure, we're all about capitalism!

It's a really ridiculous system and it's the consequence of the fact that regulatory organizations have started to become a tool for multinationals to exploit at their whims, rather than a tool to effect positive change in society as a whole. So it ends up in a system where individual to small business capitalism is hyper over-regulated whereas big business and multinational capitalism is regulated on paper yet laissez faire in practice.

Re:Competition Is Dying, and Taking Capitalism with It? by int_19h on Thursday November 29, 2018 @02:29AM (#18558672)
Capitalism is simply the private ownership (including ability to transfer) the means of production. This is still true of the corporatist variety - unlike feudal fiefs, corporations can be bought and sold, and that makes all the difference. The only way for a feudal to aggregate more power is to go to war with other feudals for more lands, because a fief is land tenure, not property. In capitalism, because capital is property, it can be aggregated by buying it, and the more you aggregate, the more powerful you become, letting you acquire more capital etc - a positive feedback loop which means that monopolies are inevitable in pure unregulated capitalism.

Regulation is orthogonal to all that, so long as it does not interfere with the ability to aggregate capital. You can tax the corporations heavily, you can impose various safety standards on them, you can have consumer rights commissions etc - it makes it harder for them to make money from the capital that they own, but it doesn't change the fundamental equation of capital -> money -> more capital, and therefore the result is still capitalism. The only way you can stop this cycle is by imposing a limit on how much capital can be held in one hands.

Re:Competition Is Dying, and Taking Capitalism with It? by TangoTrotFox on Thursday November 29, 2018 @04:23PM (#18564152)
Artificially limiting the 'means of production' (which is such an increasingly inappropriate and dated concept to use for these sort of discussions) is precisely the issue. Imagine a kingdom where a king created rules that, in effect, named exactly one black smith owning [puppet], one tavern owning [puppet], one brothel owning [puppet], etc. And these individuals were free to buy, sell, and trade these businesses so long as the transactions remained within the regulations of the king. That's not capitalism, not even a little.

And that is really the issue. The further you limit the ability of people to engage the market (as buyer and seller) the further away you move from capitalism. And that is precisely what our current system is doing. Repeating the same example just because it's so stupefying. In most places in America today you cannot legally setup a lemonade stand and start selling lemonade on your own property. We're creating a culture of passive consumers driven by extreme regulations against everything except such!

Re:Competition Is Dying, and Taking Capitalism with It? by int_19h on Thursday November 29, 2018 @07:16PM (#18565467)
We don't have a problem with monopolization of lemonade stands, though. But we do have a problems with large corporations monopolizing their respective markets, and they are doing that not because they are granted said monopoly from up above, but because they are able to consolidate it.

Limiting the amount of capital one can own is not equivalent to your scheme, by the way. The rule isn't that only one guy can own a tavern, or that there can only be one tavern - the rule is that one guy cannot own more than one tavern (just as an example - I don't think that's the level at which we should actually cap capital).

Re:Competition Is Dying, and Taking Capitalism with It? by TangoTrotFox on Thursday November 29, 2018 @11:08PM (#18566590)
The issues are intrinsically connected. People don't just start out e.g. going from nothing to building let's say a telecoms company. Entrepreneurship and creating businesses is a cycle of growth. For instance Bezos' first 'gig' followed a summer of work at McDonalds, which he hated. The next summer he setup a week long education camp for younger kids. He only got a dozen or so signups, but he probably made more from those signups than he did in last year's work at McDonalds. When you start making entrepreneurship difficult from the bottom up, you're going to end up with a really distorted picture of capitalism at the top since you're going to have some sort of strange bias in the companies represented.

And this is where I think corporatism excels. There are now just an immense number of rules and laws that are all increasingly esoteric even to operate quite simple businesses. And that's before you get into the countless fees and costs the government demands before you've even sold your first product. In other words when you kill off entrepreneurship and start moving away from capitalism, you invariably head towards corporatism which is itself headed much closer to feudalism than capitalism.

As for the king example, this was relating to the feudalism -> capitalism -> corporatism -> feudalism loop, not your specific suggestion. As for your suggestion, there are two big issues. The first is the same as discussed here. Capitalism and competition is a growth system. The reason e.g. Elon Musk was able to create a competitive rocket and vehicle company was because he earned hundreds of millions of dollars in another venture. No individual has any personal need for hundreds of millions of dollars, but it is strictly required if this individual wishes to engage in large scale ventures - the sort of which stand to massively improve society.

The second issue is probably the bigger point. We already have countless laws, on the order of thousands of pages, of laws relating to competition, anticompetitive behavior, restrictions on mergers and acquisitions, etc. These were all geared minimizing anti-competitive ownership. But the general rule in a corporatist society holds true. We have the FTC approve mergers between e.g. AT&T/Time Warner/Charter while rejecting mergers between far smaller companies that could eventually become the competitors for these sort of behemoths that increasingly stand above the law, and perhaps even above government.

In other words, write the laws and expect to see you and I only be able to own e.g. one tavern. But expect to see the king's friends somehow manage to own thousands. Corporatism in a nutshell.

Re:Competition Is Dying, and Taking Capitalism with It? by int_19h on Friday November 30, 2018 @03:31PM (#18572358)
Our anti-monopoly enforcement is actually much scaled back compared to what it used to be for most of 20th century. More importantly, the focus was changed. The original monopoly busting approach, at its peak under FDR, was all about ensuring that the markets stay competitive - it was hindrance to competition that had the feds cracking down on you, not e.g. jacking up prices on consumers.

That was changed under Reagan, and the new approach was that monopolies were only to be regulated if they start to affect consumers. And that's very much by design - according to the people who devised this regime, monopolies are not in and of themselves bad, because they're more efficient due to economy of scale. So, for example, if a merger happens, the reason why they can block it is if they can demonstrate that it would raise prices or reduce quality of service. If they can't prove that, that's too bad - even if the sheer size of the resulting behemoth is obviously a problem for market competitiveness, it's just out of scope.

I don't think it's a coincidence that monopolies dominate the market under these new rules, in a way that they haven't done before.

Re:Competition Is Dying, and Taking Capitalism with It? by TangoTrotFox on Saturday December 01, 2018 @12:15AM (#18575322)
Mostly agreed - we're saying the exact same thing here.

You'll also find that going back in time there were also far fewer rules against individual entrepreneurship. And where there were rules they were enforced in a more sane fashion. E.g. - even if a kid's lemonade stand isn't obeying regulation 3753 section 3, or city ordinance 4725-4 or whatever, you don't go and shut down the stand as the stand is doing nothing but good for everybody.

But as we transition towards corporatism rules against large companies start to disappear or fail to be enforced, while those rules against small companies and individuals start to grow and become unreasonably burdensome as well as extremely actively enforced.

The one part we don't agree on is why corporations are allowed to merge. For instance it's quite evident that Time Warner alone has already exploited their monopoly to increase prices unreasonable. Internet service in America is far more expensive than in many parts of the world, yet the quality is not particularly remarkable. And there's no justifiable reason. It's just companies agreeing not to compete and then jacking up their prices. Because of this it's not reasonable to suggest they're being technically allowed to merge/acquire further competitors because there's no evidence that they won't do what they're already doing. This is just another aspect of corporatism where rules disappear as companies grow large enough.

Re:Competition Is Dying, and Taking Capitalism with It? by geofft on Thursday November 29, 2018 @12:36AM (#18558332)
> I think when people say "fake capitalism" or "true capitalism" they're talking about unrestricted and unregulated free markets.

As far as I can tell, by "fake capitalism" the author means the opposite of "competitive free markets" (emphasis mine), not unregulated ones. In fact, the author says, "The federal government has done little to prevent this concentration, and in fact has done much to encourage it." - i.e., the author supports increased regulation and government intervention as long as it's in the appropriate direction.

Re:Competition Is Dying, and Taking Capitalism with It? by lgregg on Thursday November 29, 2018 @09:55AM (#18560564)
Yeah, I agree with your assessment of the author. I should have detailed that I was getting at more of my personal experience talking with some hardline libertarians and free market anarchists.