Re:The Baseline Costs of JavaScript Frameworks
by gedy on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @12:10PM
(#18553274)
These "carefully engineered solutions" typically aren't - and instead random js bolt-ons to whatever server side language. UI state is smeared across layers, and ability to test, share and modularize suffers. SPAs usually are better engineered UIs than the alternatives.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Baseline Costs of JavaScript Frameworks
by dancek on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @01:08PM
(#18553982)
Do you have data to back that up, or are you speaking from personal experience? I know how it can go wrong, but SPAs can become a mess too.
I had one project where we built a very beautiful, modern site that had about 50 lines of js in total. Of course your page-change times are going to be around 0.5s with an MPA, but SPAs are often slower than that anyway.
Re:The Baseline Costs of JavaScript Frameworks
by fold_left on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @03:34PM
(#18555377)
I don't know but with a service worker you could possibly reduce that 0.5 in your MPA further by caching likely next pages ahead of time.
Re:The Baseline Costs of JavaScript Frameworks
by gedy on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @03:54PM
(#18555577)
Yes, mainly personal experience. SPAs can definitely be a mess too. Mostly calling out that managing state in one place makes unit testing easier, which usually results in a better quality codebase
Re:The Baseline Costs of JavaScript Frameworks
by malvosenior on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @12:59PM
(#18553845)
The backend has to handle all of the scale. That's where the real difficult engineering comes in and if you're using JS there, you're going to pay a huge price. It doesn't seem like many front-end JS developers understand that pulling data from different places isn't actually a hard problem but instead correctly storing and managing that data at scale is where the actual engineering happens.
Re:The Baseline Costs of JavaScript Frameworks
by sebazzz on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @01:16PM
(#18554061)
State management is hard. That is the core issue.
Note you can still use an MPA and have a dynamic UI using React/Knockout/whatever. It is just usually not done that way and most go full SPA.