There is a menu bar across the top with 'why x', 'demo', 'features', 'blog', 'signup' or 'pricing', and 'login'. Below is a nice picture or screen shot with a punch line and a big call-to-action button. And below that is misc boxes of text trying to communicate more about the product.
This seems to be a lot of what you want to communicate to potential buyers and is claimed to be one of the most effective designs (one source is the book Start Small Stay Small http://startupbook.net). It seems to be a standard of sorts. It would be interesting to know if this design is proven to be the most effective basic design known for selling web apps, or what is better.
http://www.bohemiadesign.co.uk/
http://www.sproutfund.org/spring/
http://www.thirdculturestudios.com/
http://www.unconventionalguides.com/
I don't agree with your opinion about his taste either. He's pointing to 30 sites which generally focus on driving new sales of their products. While they may have a similar approach, the list does contain a variety of styles and variations. I suspect the similarities in the designs speaks more to the selling process and the mainstream techniques used to drive sales rather than the author's "boring taste".
Interestingly enough, the most obvious web app amongst your links (http://www.boxee.tv) does indeed have a somewhat similar design to those find in the original article.
Nope. It's just that all the designers currently like ripping off 37signals. In a few years there will be another hard-on-inducing design, and then everything will look like that.
Is that because the design is "right" in some way? Because to me, it just means that some of these website designs don't stand out in any way.