News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Antitrust, the App Store, and Apple by dep_b on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @11:14AM (#18543555)
Browsers are huge attack vectors as they allow you to run arbitrary code. I wouldn't say there isn't a case to not allow third parties to run a platform in your platform.
Re:Antitrust, the App Store, and Apple by kllrnohj on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @12:59PM (#18544766)
Nonsense. If Apple was worried about arbitrary code they wouldn't have allowed apps in the first place. Browsers are restricted to the same security context that Apple trusts anyone who pays them $99 with.

They just don't want competition on their platform, and Apple is typically remain small enough to get away with that position. Particularly in stronger pro-anti-trust places like the EU, where iOS is less than 30% market share.

Re:Antitrust, the App Store, and Apple by dep_b on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @05:38PM (#18547530)
Either you don't understand what arbitrary code is or you're just too angry with Apple to want to understand it. But apps either run static code or use the Safari JS engine to run code. That's all the flavors you have. Statically compiled Swift code is much easier to deal with than whatever creative things somebody can come up with with JS.
Re:Antitrust, the App Store, and Apple by kllrnohj on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @03:35PM (#18555388)
Static code IS arbitrary code. Apple didn't author it and didn't vet it. They ran a static analyzer over it (not remotely foolproof) and then trusted the actual security to the process sandbox.

Besides, nothing stops you from still running arbitrary code in iOS downloaded from the web. You're simply restricted to doing that either interpreted or via Apple's JIT. In either case you're still getting arbitrary execution that Apple never statically analyzed, interacting with any APIs that the app wants that code to have access to (intentionally or not).

Re:Antitrust, the App Store, and Apple by shmerl on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @06:23PM (#18547831)
All browsers should care about security. All browsers can have vulnerabilities. It's not an excuse to ban competing browsers if users want to install them. That's the essence of the matter. Apple's behavior is anti-competitive in doing it.

In fact, I'd argue that it reduces security, since users can't install more secure browsers than Apple's own one (and no one would care to even make one since it won't be usable).

Re:Antitrust, the App Store, and Apple by shmerl on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @11:28AM (#18543694)
It's not an excuse to violate anti-trust. MS were blasted for this, but Apple got away with this foul behavior.
Re:Antitrust, the App Store, and Apple by ubernostrum on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @11:48AM (#18543905)
Microsoft got hit for using their monopoly in one market (the market for operating systems) illegally to try to obtain better/monopoly status in another market (the market for web browsers.

If you have an evidence-based argument to make that Apple has a monopoly in the market for mobile operating systems and has illegally used it to try to obtain a monopoly in the market for web browsers, I would be intrigued to hear it.

(in other words, not every bundled web browser is automatically a violation of antitrust law; nor is every attempt to forbid something on iOS automatically a violation)

Re:Antitrust, the App Store, and Apple by shmerl on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @12:43PM (#18544569)
In other words, you are giving an excuse to Apple, based on the current handicapped anti-trust practice by the courts.

I don't see it as a valid excuse. Apple are clearly damaging the industry and market with their behavior. By blocking major features in their browser and banning all other browsers, they are forcing others into supporting their specific requirements, because otherwise they won't be able to reach iOS users. Examples like trying to sabotage DASH for video streaming by not supporting MSE on iOS are quite obvious.

Anti-trust was intended to prevent such kind of outcomes. But it was diluted to the point of being practically useless, allowing the likes of Apple to run amok with their monopolistic garbage.

Re:Antitrust, the App Store, and Apple by ubernostrum on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @01:09PM (#18544879)
Your argument is based on what you personally think the law should be, and that's not the same as what the law is.

Microsoft did things that actually broke the law. Nobody's yet convinced a court that Apple has done things that broke the law. And Apple is demonstrably not doing the thing Microsoft got in trouble for.

So you're free to argue that in your ideal world, if you made all the laws, Apple would be put out of business. But you're not free to argue that that's what the actual laws in the real world say to do.

Re:Antitrust, the App Store, and Apple by shmerl on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @03:39PM (#18546444)
So you are saying "since the law is full of holes, don't blame Apple for being crooks". I disagree. Whitewashing monopolistic abuse based on how neutered by years of lobbying by monopolists anti-trust laws are, is quite bad in itself.

> in your ideal world, if you made all the laws, Apple would be put out of business.

In the ideal world with functional anti-trust, they'd be held accountable for their disgusting anti-competitive behavior and they'd fix it. In the current world their monopolistic abuse runs unchecked, causing damage to the industry and progress.

Re:Antitrust, the App Store, and Apple by TheForumTroll on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @11:46AM (#18543879)
Are you okay with Microsoft doing the same thing then or do other rules apply for non-Apple?