News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by nine_k on Monday November 26, 2018 @11:11AM (#18534309)
With fusion devices having trouble to confine the plasma for long times, I wonder if a massively-parallel fusion plant woud be feasible.

Let's assume that plasma destabilisation does not damage the device, and is a mundane event.

Build 10 or even 20 fusion devices (economy of scale!) feeding the common heat buffer, e.g. a large reservoir of a molten salt or metal. Feed conventional turbines off the heat of the heat tank. The tank evens out the input power jumps.

Now we can restart the fusion in every fusion device every so often, provided that restarting it is made a mundane operation, too. It, of course, takes a lot of electricity to pump into the magnets. Conveniently, we have a mighty power plant right here. Dumping the magnetic/electric energy from the magnets requires a huge sink. Luckily, we already have such a sink co-located.

Building the plant takes a massive investment. Luckily, the architecture allows to build it piecemeal, feeding the next added unit with the power of the already built units.

BTW the waste heat could be directly reused in some kind of chemical processing, like smelting, or maybe even synthesis of carbohydrate fuels from ambient carbon dioxide and water.

Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by Retric on Monday November 26, 2018 @11:47AM (#18534621)
Ok, several issues with this. First restarting these devices takes a lot of electricity, which drastically reduces your net efficiency. So, you still really want to solve this problem.

Second, fusion devices scale very well so one device at 10x the scale is vastly better than 10 different devices at x size. Third, storing and pumping heat involves losses, where there is a huge range of great options for storing electricity. Fourth, it takes massive turbines to turn heat into energy, so you need to scale several things on both sides of your merged heat system in your modular design.

Finally, X independent fusion devices don't have single points of failures shared between them. Your combined design would.

Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by nine_k on Monday November 26, 2018 @11:58AM (#18534713)
> there is a huge range of great options for storing electricity

Producers of wind and solar power would love to hear about them!

Re SPOF: since the fusion devices are much less reliable, as of now, than reservoirs of hot liquids, I suppose the reservoir is much less of a concern.

I understand that fusion efficiency grows with size; this is why we are surrounded with colossal self-initiated fusion reactions, and have one nearby! But before we can scale, maybe we could still turn net-positive with smaller, less reliable devices. Remember how unreliable first cars were.

Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by Retric on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:02PM (#18534746)
> Maby we could still

Early computers where huge and broke down all the time. They where built that way because it was the easiest option at the time. Nobody wants to build multi billion dollar devices if you could get away with spending 1/10th as much or even test several designs at the same time they would.

PS: The grid absorbs solar and wind interment nature just fine without much in the way of storage. That might suggest something about large scale energy storage. Building something that can store GW’s worth of heat for minutes at a time is going to be huge and expensive.

Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by saagarjha on Monday November 26, 2018 @04:08PM (#18536814)
> The grid absorbs solar and wind interment nature just fine without much in the way of storage.

I was under the impression that this was because we have a bunch of natural-gas power plants that are turned on when necessary to meet peak load.

Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by Retric on Monday November 26, 2018 @08:44PM (#18538604)
This is regional, the general factors are over supply is required to deal with failures. So, their should always be excess capacity which can be routed around at 1/3 the speed of light. Demand can be adjusted in response to increased prices. Relatively tiny amounts of storage allow for time to react.

Large scale hydro for example can act as storage ramping up and down in minutes to cover demand spikes.

PS: Sure in the US it’s a lot of cheap natural gas right now. But many places don’t and still need to deal with the same issues.

Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by red75prime on Monday November 26, 2018 @11:40PM (#18539430)
> The grid absorbs solar and wind interment nature just fine without much in the way of storage

Not so fine, judging by [0] (page 57): "Ontario has committed to install about 2,500 MW of solar capacity in both its 2010 and 2013 Long Term Energy Plan.70 However, Ontario also has committed to install 7,500 MW of wind generation. These two commitments combined create a serious energy management problem for Ontario’s power system engineers and operators."

And they have hydroelectric, nuclear, natural-gas power plants, and sell electricity to neighboring states to compensate intermittent power supply.

[0]: https://www.ospe.on.ca/downloads/March-2016-Research-Report

Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by adrianN on Monday November 26, 2018 @11:19AM (#18534380)
Confining the plasma is easier in a larger reactor, so you might be better off building one big reactor instead of 20 small ones.
Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by nine_k on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:05PM (#18534782)
If confinement is easier in a large machine, why are not very large machines being built?

If this is economically infeasible, then again, building piecemeal may be better, in the same way as taking a credit and paying interest on it might be better if you can't secure the upfront sum anyway.

Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by cygx on Monday November 26, 2018 @02:36PM (#18536151)
If confinement is easier in a large machine, why are not very large machines being built?

Money and politics. You might want to take a look at the original logo of the ITER project: https://www.iter.org/img/resize-900-90/www/content/com/Lists...

The Soviet Union collapsed, and the US pulled out of the project in 2000, rejoining only in 2006. This necessitated a down-sizing of the original design.

Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by Obi_Juan_Kenobi on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:28PM (#18535618)
Cost. Building huge magnets and a huge vacuum vessel is simply expensive.

Fusion scales very well with two parameters: size and magnetic field strength.

Size works great, but it's just too expensive. Even if you could justify the costs in theory, ITER is demonstration that the political will to invest that much capital with such a long payoff time just isn't there.

Magnetic field strength is the new hope of the fusion industry: 'Cheap' high temperature superconductors have been commercialized and could make smaller fusion designs practical and economical.

Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by philwelch on Monday November 26, 2018 @07:23PM (#18538129)
This is kind of similar to how we use rockets instead of Lofstrom loops. The cost per kilowatt-hour of One Giant Fusion Reactor may be infinitestimal, but if you don't actually realize lower unit costs without a huge upfront investment, and there's no way to incrementally get some of the benefit for only some of the cost, it's a very hard sell.

Rockets are an easy sell because you can design a rocket that launches from Holland and lands on London and you can find someone to fund that. Later, based on that track record, you can design a rocket that launches from Florida and reaches low earth orbit, and you can find someone to fund that. After you pull that off, you can make a rocket that launches from Florida and reaches the moon, and you can find someone to find that based on your track record.

Conversely, if you wanted to build a Lofstrom loop, you would have to tell someone, "hey, there's no track record of something like this working, but give me tens of billions of dollars and you'll make it back by not blowing as much money on rockets". Nobody's gonna pay for that. And if you start building it piecemeal, you're still not going to get anything to space, and then people will point and laugh and talk about how Lofstrom loops are a stupid technology that will never work out because they're always another 20 years away, so you never get the necessary funding to actually finish the thing, which means people will just continue to point and laugh, and in allegorical form, this is the history of fusion power.

Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by gmueckl on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:36PM (#18535112)
Please have a look how frigging huge ITER is. There is no other way to put it. This thing has its own campus. It is also delayed because it is the first of its kind and also underfunded with some mismanagement on top. But
Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by bsder on Monday November 26, 2018 @02:01PM (#18535860)
> If confinement is easier in a large machine, why are not very large machines being built?

They are. ITER was designed to be as large as the engineering allows. But that is Expensive.

The groups at MIT are trying to take advantage of the fact that newer superconductors allow you to get to ITER levels with smaller designs. However, those are Not Cheap either.

Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by DennisP on Monday November 26, 2018 @02:17PM (#18536000)
Not cheap, but about an order of magnitude cheaper than ITER.
Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by maxxxxx on Monday November 26, 2018 @04:06PM (#18536800)
"If confinement is easier in a large machine, why are not very large machines being built? "

That's the plan. But first you have to figure out a lot of details in smaller machines.

Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by bicubic on Monday November 26, 2018 @11:19AM (#18534379)
This doesn’t solve the fact that a single fusion pulse (all existing reactors are pulsed) currently consumes more energy than it produces.
Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by nine_k on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:01PM (#18534739)
I remember hearing about break-even events for a few years. E.g. from 2014: https://www.nature.com/news/laser-fusion-experiment-extracts...

A design that produces e.g. 2x the energy it consumes for the startup could be viable, even if pulsed (running minutes, not months).

Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by Chemiseblanc on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:45PM (#18535225)
IIRC They were able to get net energy from the fuel versus the energy of the x-rays used to ignite it. But not in terms of the energy of the lasers used to create the x-rays by vaporizing the fuel pellet.
Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by pastullo on Monday November 26, 2018 @11:43AM (#18534584)
The idea of having many small fusion reactors is quite interesting. I never thought about it and i would normally dismiss it since building a big one is cheaper than building many little ones. However, SpaceX and their 9-engine Falcon rocket teach us a different story. Sometimes building smaller yet complicated power plants is cheaper than building fewer ones but bigger.

Would be great to know more about the economics behind a multi reactor power plant.

Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by gmueckl on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:30PM (#18535055)
The real issue is surface to volune ratio of the contained plasma. This needs to be as small as possible for the containment to be effective (reduced energy losses through the surface area). So you want your reactors to be as big as possible.
Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by pfdietz on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:57PM (#18535333)
From an engineering point of view, though, you want the reactor to be as small as possible. That's because output is limited by the power/area that the first wall can withstand. So, the volumetric power density will be inversely proportional to the linear dimensions of the reactor.
Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by emilfihlman on Monday November 26, 2018 @11:20AM (#18534387)
>BTW the waste heat could be directly reused

Yes, for district heating.

Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by semi-extrinsic on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:00PM (#18534732)
Not really. For power generation as in a coal or nuclear fusion or fission powerplant, you run a multi-stage steam turbine cycle to get down to as low a temperature as possible after the final LP turbine. Because that maximizes the Carnot efficiency of the (idealised) Rankine cycle, it also maximizes real world efficiency.

In practice, coing down to ~40 C (~100F) is not uncommon. And then the waste heat is basically unusable, even for district heating.

OTOH, if you need lots of heat (maybe you have a chemical plant or something nearby), you can design you powerplant for cogeneration of heat and power, yielding higher total system efficiency. But you don't do that "just" for district heating.

Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by twic on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:39PM (#18535152)
You can (and at least one nuclear plant does!) run greenhouses off 40-celsius air. Maybe some tropical fish aquaculture.

But no, nothing at infrastructure scale.

Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by antocv on Monday November 26, 2018 @11:43AM (#18534583)
What is it with physicists and molten salt?

Every battery-tech, pro-nuclear, fusion related news have to have somebody chiming in "molten salt".

Just an observation.

Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by 08-15 on Monday November 26, 2018 @02:45PM (#18536201)
Molten salts are hot!

SCNR. Seriously though, molten salts are great heat transfer media, a bit like water, just at higher temperature and still low pressure. They are also completely immune to radiation damage, which is a big deal if you have 14MeV neutrons flying around and something has to stop them. Chemistry in molten salts is also interesting. Things can be extracted (say, into a molten metal phase) or precipitated, and some reactions just happen at 600 degrees while they need platinum and palladium catalysts at room temperature. What's not to love?

Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by antocv on Wednesday November 28, 2018 @03:32AM (#18550063)
Can you teach me more about the radiation properties of molten salts? Didnt know molten salt is immune to radiation, why would that be? Thats cool, though.
Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by pfdietz on Thursday November 29, 2018 @05:30AM (#18559268)
Because they (or, at least, the ones being discussed) have no covalent chemical bonds or other static arrangements of atoms that can be disrupted. The ions are all just single atoms with more or fewer electrons than the neutral versions of those elements. The atoms can be ionized by radiation, but the resulting weird oxidation states just fall back to chemical equilibrium as the electrons redistribute.
Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by ForHackernews on Monday November 26, 2018 @11:48AM (#18534628)
Molten salt has a high heat capacity and a higher boiling point than water, so you can get higher temperature without worrying about steam.
Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by HoochTHX on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:30PM (#18535059)
No pressure vessel required. Meaning no explosion possible. Intrinsic safety by design.
Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by pfdietz on Monday November 26, 2018 @09:17PM (#18538766)
The confinement building of a light water reactor is large because it has to contain large volumes of steam in an accident.

In a molten salt reactor, there is very little volatile material inside the containment building. The salt itself does not have high vapor pressure, even in accident conditions. As a result, the size (and cost) of the containment building can be radically reduced. Moltex's design, for example, reduces the cost (per unit of power output) of the containment building by a factor of 5 vs. LWRs.

Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by maxxxxx on Monday November 26, 2018 @04:03PM (#18536778)
With fusion bigger is better.
Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by whyisthis122 on Monday November 26, 2018 @09:37PM (#18538864)
Why is this upvoted? It shows a severe lack of physics knowledge.

The whole goal of fusion is to get the energy amplification, Q, to be > 1, which requires the triple product n T t to be above some threshold. n is density, T is temperature, t is confinement duration. This is Lawson's criteria, you should look it up to educate yourself.

Your proposal doesn't help n, T, or t, hence doesn't help Q.

Also, there are economic and physical gains from concentrating your efforts into making your fusion reactor larger, rather than trying to make it 1/10 the size and have 10x of them.

The economies of scale will happen once fusion ignition (Q>1) is achieved and we start mass producing dozens of fusion plants around the world. But at this point we're likely 10+ years away from achieving ignition.

Re:Successful second round of fusion experiments with Wendel... by pfdietz on Tuesday November 27, 2018 @07:40AM (#18541827)
DT fusion reactors have inherent diseconomies of scale. That's because their power output is limited by what the first wall can withstand. By the square-cube law, the volumetric power density of a DT reactor must go down as its linear dimensions increase.

This is not just quibbling, since bad power density is a huge problem with fusion.

Look at ITER. The volumetric power density (gross fusion power/volume of reactor proper, not including the building or auxiliary equipment) is 0.05 MW/m^3. Compare that to a PWR primary reactor vessel, which have a power density around 20 MW/m^3. The smaller designs like ARC or Lockheed's concept have power density around 0.5 MW/m^3.