Re:Everyone is totally just winging it, all the time (2014)
by e17a on Sunday November 25, 2018 @08:37PM
(#18530361)
N. N. Taleb has been harping away at this for ages now. Here are some great quotes:
> Electricians, barbers, gardeners, surgeons, tango dancers, are experts. Not economists.
> The Black Swan explains the domain-dependence of expertise: why the electrician, dentist, are experts, while the journalist, State Department bureaucrat, and macroeconomist are not. Since then, there has been a global movement against the pseudo-expert, the serial incompetence of a certain class of babbling and pompous operatives across bureaucrato-academic professions. Which leads to the question: who is the real expert? Who decides on who is and who is not expert? Where is the metaexpert? Time it is. Or, rather, Lindy.
> Electricians, barbers, gardeners, surgeons, tango dancers, are experts. Not economists.
> The Black Swan explains the domain-dependence of expertise: why the electrician, dentist, are experts, while the journalist, State Department bureaucrat, and macroeconomist are not. Since then, there has been a global movement against the pseudo-expert, the serial incompetence of a certain class of babbling and pompous operatives across bureaucrato-academic professions. Which leads to the question: who is the real expert? Who decides on who is and who is not expert? Where is the metaexpert? Time it is. Or, rather, Lindy.