News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Everyone is totally just winging it, all the time (2014) by antonvs on Sunday November 25, 2018 @01:24PM (#18528037)
This is projection by people who are untrained in what they do.

Competent people with good training in some discipline are able to apply that training to competently achieve goals. This allows them to apply knowledge that they didn't develop themselves by trial and error, and is much more efficient, with better outcomes than the alternatives.

Unfortunately, this often seems to be the exception rather than the rule. Although "seems" is the operative word: if it weren't for this effect, we'd see many more bridges and buildings collapsing, ships sinking, etc.

It's just that many areas of human endeavour tend to more commonly involve untrained people "winging it", and that's what the article focuses on.

Re:Everyone is totally just winging it, all the time (2014) by johnjohnsmith on Sunday November 25, 2018 @02:06PM (#18528316)
I'd like to offer a few decades of perspective on your claim.

I've been programming for 30+ years. When I sit down to code, most of the time I've thought through it before even typing and am ~99% confident I won't hit a roadblock. I've spent half my life mastering my programming skills.

BUT: I'm a high-level technical lead / product lead, so I only get to write code a few times a month and it is more for stress-release because I've mastered it (and because I am a mentor to / lead 30+ programmers and this gives me a chance to interact with them).

If I wrote code 100% of the time I'd being winging it 1% of the time. So in this regard you are correct.

However, because of how corporations work, once you've demonstrated proficiency at "junior level work" you move up to the next big challenge. Yes, that sounds pejorative, but coding is not hard compared to the next levels of competency: programming is junior level, software architecture is senior level, product roadmap is staff level, corporate direction is above that. Sorry if that hurts your butt, but knowing the latest JS framework or how to optimize your C++ is trench-work compared to convincing the CTO where your division should invest its R&D budget for the next 5 years.

Because there is no "school" for learning how to plan your company roadmap, you really do have to wing it and learn from experience. And since shit is changing so fast... well, sure there are basic principles studied is business (that sometimes are useless for strategy but are good for tactics)... but in tech, it very much is "wtf is going to happen next and is this the right choice." Sure there is an executive board, and vice presidents gunning for your role, but you REALLY are winging it at C-level unless you are in your 70's and have helmed multiple large companies.

So from a top's down view from higher-importance positions, winging it is simply part of the job.

Re:Everyone is totally just winging it, all the time (2014) by davidgay on Sunday November 25, 2018 @06:00PM (#18529649)
> However, because of how corporations work, once you've demonstrated proficiency at "junior level work" you move up to the next big challenge. Yes, that sounds pejorative, but coding is not hard compared to the next levels of competency: programming is junior level, software architecture is senior level, product roadmap is staff level, corporate direction is above that.

This viewpoint, that those jobs are harder, is just self-justification (either to themselves or to everyone else) for people higher up that list of their higher pay than those below.

I don't believe those skills are actually harder (nor easier, just different), or that you have to be good, e.g., at programming to be good at corporate direction.

What is, IMO, true, is that those skills do have larger impact (or at least, significantly more obvious impact), which is at least a reasonable justification for higher pay.

But don't pretend that being good at software architecture, corporate direction, etc, means that you're actually smarter than that person who's "just" a programmer.

Re:Everyone is totally just winging it, all the time (2014) by swelz on Sunday November 25, 2018 @11:02PM (#18530964)
I don't think they are implying that people on more junior levels are not at smart. I believe they are attempting to explain that as you go up higher people tend to be less competent due to a lack of experience and proper training tools.
Re:Everyone is totally just winging it, all the time (2014) by barberousse on Monday November 26, 2018 @11:46AM (#18534615)
> I believe they are attempting to explain that as you go up higher people tend to be less competent due to a lack of experience and proper training tools.

He's not saying higher-ups are less competent, he's saying winging it is inevitable and necessary at the C-level _because_ it is impossible to already have experience and proper training tools for the decisions one has to make.

Re:Everyone is totally just winging it, all the time (2014) by paganel on Sunday November 25, 2018 @03:26PM (#18528821)
Sites like this one (and especially the initial spirit behind them) are the result of programmers and programmer-like minds (“hackers”, if you will) just “winging” it and seeing what will happen if they’ll build them. The reddit’s founders’ decision to initially write it in Lisp or even Paul Graham’s decision to write this website in Arc is almost quintessentially “winging it”, no sane person should have picked the wingy Lisp or Lisp-like Arc over a non-wingy and easily “architecturable” platform like Struts (we’re talking about the years 2005-2006). The same goes for Zuckerberg using PHP to write Facebook as PHP is the most winging-like programming language ever.

What I’m trying to say it’s that winging it is good, it’s good to get lost in a bazaar, we don’t all need cathedrals.

Re:Everyone is totally just winging it, all the time (2014) by pinusc on Sunday November 25, 2018 @02:16PM (#18528368)
I believe the phenomenon you're talking about is called "Peter principle" [1], which states that "people in a hierarchy tend to rise to their level of incompetence. In other words, an employee is promoted based on their success in previous jobs until they reach a level at which they are no longer competent".

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_principle

edit: punctuation and wording

Re:Everyone is totally just winging it, all the time (2014) by strken on Sunday November 25, 2018 @02:41PM (#18528560)
No, he's talking about something different. The Peter Principle makes the process sound totally dysfunctional because it assumes the employee will remain incompetent, while he suggests that a period of incompetence is necessary to learn how to do your job.
Re:Everyone is totally just winging it, all the time (2014) by yesenadam on Sunday November 25, 2018 @02:36PM (#18528532)
He didn't mention people being incompetent. Why do you say he's talking about the Peter principle? I can't see it.
Re:Everyone is totally just winging it, all the time (2014) by Novashi on Sunday November 25, 2018 @02:42PM (#18528568)
The CTO you're convincing is winging it as well, so how much convincing do you actually need to do? How many C-levels have been convinced to blindly adopt ML/AI/Blockchain/TrendyThings?

If these folks really are winging it, that's code for "hey, we're dumb, come exploit us". It's where pomp and circumstance close deals rather than actually delivering something technically good. It's where things start turning into a social club but the salaries continue to climb.

Re:Everyone is totally just winging it, all the time (2014) by KaoruAoiShiho on Sunday November 25, 2018 @02:19PM (#18528394)
Great perspective. My takeaway is that people today are still overall undereducated. Business skills and corporate strategy should be taught earlier, at the highschool levels, instead of requiring a dedicated MBA.
Re:Everyone is totally just winging it, all the time (2014) by wallacoloo on Sunday November 25, 2018 @02:46PM (#18528596)
> Business skills and corporate strategy should be taught earlier, at the highschool levels, instead of requiring a dedicated MBA.

How would you teach corporate strategy in a way that’s simultaneously honest (and useful to the individual) and palatable?

Maybe if you limited yourself to strategy within coops, where the individual’s incentives really are aligned with the incentives of everyone else in the organization, or mid-level management, where you only have a certain category of power - but that’s less useful because coops aren’t so common and mid-level management is ultimately subjected to what the upper levels decide.

In the end, individuals with positions where they have to worry about “business skills” or “corporate strategy” don’t usually have incentives which are aligned with the people at other rungs on the ladder. If you teach corporate strategy in an honest fashion, a not-insignificant portion of your material will be how to effectively redirect money from other areas in the organization to yourself. Most of your students will see that at stealing.

Or maybe you don’t teach how to leverage these strategies, but just how to spot them in action?

Either way, K-12 is traditionally focused on skills that are more foundational and generally useful. Admittedly, that’s changing as some schools introduce things like CS courses, but usually these are electives and not part of the core curriculum.

Re:Everyone is totally just winging it, all the time (2014) by mrhappyunhappy on Sunday November 25, 2018 @06:35PM (#18529794)
If I were exposed to corporate strategy without having any business experience whatsoever that usually accompanies an MBA, the subject would go in one ear and out the other without registering one bit.

What really ought to be taught is personal finance and basic investing - those subjects can be molded into information for any age group.

Re:Everyone is totally just winging it, all the time (2014) by dwaltrip on Monday November 26, 2018 @01:12AM (#18531485)
It seems to me those domains lack a well-defined paradigm that can be taught in a easily digestible way in a classroom environment.

I imagine some of the known valuable skills can be taught to a certain degree. Problem-solving, learning how to learn, assessing opportunities, looking for inefficiencies, communication, telling a compelling narrative, and so on. But I don't think it is easy to teach those things in a highly effective manner, at least not in a short amount of time.

Re:Everyone is totally just winging it, all the time (2014) by jamesrcole on Sunday November 25, 2018 @01:31PM (#18528087)
> Unfortunately, this often seems to be the exception rather than the rule. ... many areas of human endeavour tend to more commonly involve untrained people

This seems to imply "if only everyone got adequate training". It's not like that, though. There's a lot of important, worthwhile endeavours that inherently involve having to figure things out as you go.

Re:Everyone is totally just winging it, all the time (2014) by B0btheBuilder on Sunday November 25, 2018 @01:37PM (#18528114)
Even competent people with good training aren't perfect. Competent people make mistakes. You mention bridges, buildings, and ships, all projects built by massive teams of people and stringent processes. These massive teams of people and stringent processes are necessary exactly because people aren't perfect. I'm unclear what you mean by the article focusing on "untrained people", unless you're trying to claim that politicians and newspaper executives are untrained.
Re:Everyone is totally just winging it, all the time (2014) by Sharlin on Sunday November 25, 2018 @02:52PM (#18528626)
Making occasional mistakes while applying formal knowledge seems to be qualitatively quite different from making suboptimal decisions because you’re improvising due to lack of such formal knowledge.

In some domains you don’t have a choice; there are too many moving parts, decision making is of necessity based on noisy and incomplete information, the domain is too messy for formal models to be useful. You just have to intuit and improvise. This is more often than not the case when human interactions are involved. Trying to impose engineering solutions to social problems usually ends in disaster.

Re:Everyone is totally just winging it, all the time (2014) by zmmmmm on Sunday November 25, 2018 @06:25PM (#18529751)
I agree a little bit, but I think you're swinging the pendulum a little far the other way. I work in a highly regulated area with consequences similar to "bridges falling down", and guess what? At an individual level, everyone is still winging it. What we do have though is a lot of processes: mandated things like checklists, written down procedures, standards that we work to and second-checking by peer or senior colleagues. It's those that stop the "bridges falling down", but at a personal / career level - people are all still exhibiting those people-like behaviors - rushing their work, making all kinds of mistakes, big-noting themselves, saying stupid things, etc. We design processes that kind of concede that "everyone is winging it all the time", so that things still be ok anyway.
Re:Everyone is totally just winging it, all the time (2014) by kthejoker2 on Monday November 26, 2018 @07:29AM (#18532818)
This is what I came here to post. We have checklists and processes specifically to thwart "winging it" and

1. It's amazing how many people ignore those checklists and processes in the name of winging it, and

2. It's amazing how despite dozens, hundreds, and sometimes thousands of people-years in an organization, sometimes there's still no checklist or process and winging it is all they've got.

Re:Everyone is totally just winging it, all the time (2014) by lapnitnelav on Monday November 26, 2018 @09:39AM (#18533610)
I relate to this so much. I work in one of those regulated areas (finance).

Your comment has given me a new perspective on what I consider a developer hostile environment.

Re:Everyone is totally just winging it, all the time (2014) by xapata on Sunday November 25, 2018 @02:08PM (#18528332)
Paraphrasing Plato (quoting Socrates): The more I learn, the less I know.

Highly trained, competent people often encounter situations they're unfamiliar with. That's what keeps the job exciting.

To believe otherwise suggests either lack of training, or ...

Re:Everyone is totally just winging it, all the time (2014) by seem_2211 on Sunday November 25, 2018 @02:24PM (#18528429)
Agreed. I think there's a combination of things here - STEM type subjects for example seem to lend themselves to well defined processes and training, whereas things that are a bit more ambiguous (law, journalism, management, politics) leave a lot more space to make things up as you go along.

I think there are benefits to both, but whenever I see someone complain about everyone winging it, I think they show their incompetence and lack of professional development.

I work in a very fluid field (I recruit salespeople), so the rules are much less defined than if I were building rocketships or bridges or whatever, but there's still an abundance of work out there giving guidance on how things can be done.

You see the same things in startups. The successful ones are emulating a lot of the lessons learnt by people who came before them, and then innovate in a small area. The unsuccessful ones are "innovating" on everything.

Re:Everyone is totally just winging it, all the time (2014) by CM30 on Sunday November 25, 2018 @06:40PM (#18529817)
This is true, though I suspect success also comes from knowing which lessons to take from other companies and when to apply them to your project/business. A lot of design decisions that work for Amazon won't work for a company with about 1000 times less customers, resources and manpower. An awful lot of startups also fail because they copy the big guys without realising that they're nowhere near as successful just yet and that what works for a large site/business and what works for a small one aren't necessarily the same thing.

It's certainly the cause for a lot of overengineering and early complexity.

Re:Everyone is totally just winging it, all the time (2014) by bksenior on Sunday November 25, 2018 @01:56PM (#18528256)
Leeches used to be common medical training, Penicillin was literally created by a pro who went against his training. Training is often helpful for pattern mataching, but make no mistakes, your doctor can kill you and your teachers can mislead. Everyone is faking it.
Re:Everyone is totally just winging it, all the time (2014) by nharada on Sunday November 25, 2018 @01:59PM (#18528275)
There's a difference between "faking it" and "trying your best but making mistakes". Trained pilots still crash airplanes, but I'm not getting on a plane flown by some random passenger.
Re:Everyone is totally just winging it, all the time (2014) by bksenior on Sunday November 25, 2018 @07:38PM (#18530083)
You're confused. Faking it is still doing your best to meet your own knowledge and standards. No one is going and just trying to fuck it up.