News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by 013a on Saturday November 24, 2018 @04:18PM (#18524028)
One of my "wake up" moments was when I searched for the phone number of a local physical therapy office on Google. Within the day, I started getting Youtube video recommendations for massage techniques to relieve shoulder pain.

Google and all of its employees who make products like this are on the absolute wrong side of history. Society will only take so much before breaking; they need to figure out their business model, and fast.

Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by tw1010 on Saturday November 24, 2018 @04:27PM (#18524063)
This seems like a fairly easy thing to test rigorously (in a statistically significant way). Just create a fake account and do a search and see what the effect is on other places on the web. Are there services that does this automatically, so we don't have to rely on anecdotal "I searched for X here and now I see recommendations for that on Y, and I think it was because of X, but maybe it's just coincidence"? A site that rigorously confirms secret data links between e.g. google search or gmail plain text and other places (e.g. youtube or even amazon recommendations). If it doesn't exist, it seems like a cool thing to create, as a sort of service to the world.

It'd probably reveal a lot of hidden data links that aren't obvious (or which companies promise doesn't exist).

Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by Cyphase on Saturday November 24, 2018 @05:18PM (#18524253)
That could turn into an arms race of the target companies trying to detect when it's a fake account versus a real one, and the analysis service trying to make the accounts seem more real. Of course, if it became public that the target companies were trying to dodge the analysis, that could be damaging to them. Then again, automated accounts would likely be against the TOS.

The analysis service could work by watching the traffic of real people who download a browser extension, but then privacy from _them_ becomes an issue.

Perhaps some kind of distributed data-collection system could be created, where an extension will analyze your own traffic, strip out as much personally identifiable information (PII) as possible / as you'd like, and then submit that to a central repository for aggregation or further collective analysis.

Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by FloatingVertex on Saturday November 24, 2018 @06:08PM (#18524427)
An arms race like that would be a help for privacy, there is no way of filtering out enough bots without a relatively high false positive rate.
Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by Cyphase on Sunday November 25, 2018 @05:04AM (#18526237)
But "filtering out" would just need to be reducing ad targeting, not suspending the accounts, so some level of false positives might be fine if you can get a low enough false negative rate. The goal of the companies in this hypothetical is to limit systematic statistical detection of ad targeting, not to suspend automated accounts. If a small enough percentage of human users' ads are less/not targeted, no big deal.
Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by jhall1468 on Saturday November 24, 2018 @04:49PM (#18524161)
> Google and all of its employees who make products like this are on the absolute wrong side of history.

A few things:

1. It takes a fairly high throne to look down on people for their employers issues.

2. You assume a great deal about what people are willing to put up with for free services.

I think you're probably going to be wrong. Most people will whore themselves out for convenience because they don't care if they get targeted ads in order to get those free services.

Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by denerio-a on Saturday November 24, 2018 @05:38PM (#18524316)
WRT point 1 - Wait what? You can work for not-not-evil employers now and all the ethical blame is on the CEO?

> Corporation: an ingenious device for obtaining profit without individual responsibility - Bierce

Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by jhall1468 on Saturday November 24, 2018 @08:44PM (#18524947)
Bad or good companies are subjective. My family > your ideals. Sorry man, I'm not going to take a pay cut because of your list of companies that are subjectively bad.
Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by denerio-a on Saturday November 24, 2018 @09:12PM (#18525036)
I’m struggling to read your comment as anything but a direct and unapologetic “Fuck you I got mine”.

Are my rights as beneath your family as my ideals? And how does the fact that you’re not self employed absolve you of this, exactly?

Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by jhall1468 on Saturday November 24, 2018 @09:18PM (#18525059)
You don't have "the right" to no targeted advertising. You have every right to do whatever you legally can to prevent it from happening. Your rights aren't being violated. If I'm knowingly participating in a violation of your rights, I'm culpable. If I participate, knowingly or otherwise, in something that bothers you, you are exactly right fuck you I got mine. I'm not subject to other peoples belief systems.
Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by denerio-a on Saturday November 24, 2018 @09:36PM (#18525109)
>I’m not subject to other people’s belief systems

You live in a society. Your actions have consequences, and if you can ignore that to get your fat paycheck then I can certainly judge the shit out of you, without a very high chair.

The fact that you claim rational discourse has ended when people invoke the lessons of Nuremberg - “because Godwin’s law” - is a stain on, and reflection of your own character.

Godwin compares people to Nazis sometime himself you know, when there’s a call for it. When this many people are calling you on it, maybe you should be listening a little better..

Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by jhall1468 on Saturday November 24, 2018 @09:53PM (#18525171)
> You live in a society. Your actions have consequences, and if you can ignore that to get your fat paycheck then I can certainly judge the shit out of you, without a very high chair.

My actions don't involve the harm of others, outside of their fragile egos and obsession with what they think should be their rights. I couldn't possibly care less about your judgement.

> The fact that you claim rational discourse has ended when people invoke the lessons of Nuremberg - “because Godwin’s law” - is a stain on, and reflection of your own character.

The fact that you think an argument about a subject with a variety of opinions deserves comparison to one of the most horrible events in human history is a reflection on your character.

> Godwin compares people to Nazis sometime himself you know, when there’s a call for it. When this many people are calling you on it, maybe you should be listening a little better..

It's valid when their behavior is something akin to Nazism. Not very many people are calling me on it... on the contrary, my post is getting upvoted. Because the reality of the situation is, targeted advertising is a topic that needs discussion but it has no place in a comparison with the death of millions of people because of their heritage/religion.

It's pathetic hyperbole people use when they can't win an argument on its merits.

Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by hyperman1 on Sunday November 25, 2018 @04:37PM (#18529214)
Unfortunately, you are very very wrong, and World war 2 is a great example why:

Some countries had census data containing the religion of every family. People proudly declared themselves Jewish. When the Nazis invaded the countries, they grabbed the available data and instantly knew who to send to the camps. One reason why so many Jews died was the speed with which the situation evolved. Sometimes there were 2 weeks between 'nothing to wory' and the deportation.

The same principle holds for every big list of intrusive data. Yes, you are grabbing all the data you can only to target ads. Today. But that same data in other hands can block people's access to loan, deny them healthcare or make them look like terrorists.

The US democracy is eroding, fast. It is not that far fetched to see the data ending up with the government: 1) How many data has ended up in a FOIA request? You don't know, as you don't see them. 2) Snowden proved that Google already leaked data to the government without even realizing it 3) An executive order from the US president will give him any access to the data.

And that's just the US government. Businesses sell data to each other whenever they want. Today Google seems not to do it, but one CxO change or bad financial quarter can change a lot here, fast.

Basically, Google is playing with fire, in a political situation equivalent to a big gas leak. Be very carefull.

Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by codyb on Saturday November 24, 2018 @09:03PM (#18525008)
I hate to godwin this thread, but wasn't half the issue people claimed to have with ex nazis was that they never stood up and stopped following orders?

Obviously Googlers are not Nazis. I guess the subjective part ends up being where you draw the line.

Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by jhall1468 on Saturday November 24, 2018 @09:12PM (#18525037)
You aren't the first to do so. That line is an easy one to draw, and the moment you have to bring up Nazi's you're argument doesn't hold water. There's a huge swath of subjectivity between targeted advertising and murdering hundreds of millions of people.
Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by ionised on Monday November 26, 2018 @06:25AM (#18532548)
> and the moment you have to bring up Nazi's you're argument doesn't hold water

Not really.

You are thoroughly misusing Godwin's law, and Godwin himself stated that he never intended people like yourself to stifle conversation on a subject by chanting his name.

Godwin stated that references and comparisons to Hitler or the Nazis are perfectly reasonable in a conversation, as long as the person shows sufficient understanding of history, which the posters you are arguing with seem to have.

Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by 013a on Saturday November 24, 2018 @05:00PM (#18524201)
I view it as something governments will eventually step in to fix. It's very convenient to dump toxic waste into rivers. If it weren't for regulation companies would probably still do this. That doesn't make it ok, and it doesn't mean that behaviors like that will always be allowed.
Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by p2t2p on Saturday November 24, 2018 @06:34PM (#18524516)
You clearly didn’t read the article. It’s the government website that sent those searches to two advertising and data collecting systems.
Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by ErikAugust on Saturday November 24, 2018 @05:34PM (#18524301)
Familiar with the “banality of evil”? Give it a good thought before you give employees a free pass for the behavior of their employers.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eichmann_in_Jerusalem

Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by jhall1468 on Saturday November 24, 2018 @09:11PM (#18525031)
Yes, because targeted advertising is just like playing along with killing hundreds of millions of people. It's almost like a grey area exists here.
Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by ErikAugust on Sunday November 25, 2018 @12:39AM (#18525611)
More like there is a wide spectrum of severity. There is no equivalence being inferred here.
Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by paulddraper on Saturday November 24, 2018 @04:50PM (#18524165)
The strongest lesson life has taught me:

Never underestimate the power of convenience.

Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by JacobJans on Saturday November 24, 2018 @07:17PM (#18524649)
I don't necessarily disagree with you.

However, you are stating that ads for massage techniques could "break society."

That just doesn't add up to me.

What is not being stated here? How does this connect? (These are not rhetorical questions!)

Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by 013a on Saturday November 24, 2018 @09:29PM (#18525092)
When I say "society could break" I mean that there is a general acceptance, or stability, in society whereby we accept that these practices are alright. And that stability will break.

Google, and companies like them, are built on practices which only exist because their users don't fully comprehend the depth of discovery, correlation, and export Google is making on their data. Maybe deeper, users don't fully realize the value of their data.

If you build a business on the ignorance of your customers, you will fail. Period. Society always gets smarter. Google has so much amazing technology and legitimate value (G-Suite, Cloud, etc) to fall back on that they'll be alright, but companies like Facebook don't have that same level of breadth.

Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by codyb on Saturday November 24, 2018 @09:00PM (#18524997)
I suppose one relatively easy scenario for me to imagine would be these massive databases of information on billions of individuals being either hacked, leaked, or taken by groups with idealogies which could use such data to discriminate or worse.

A slower moving but potentially more insiduous effect on society might be the slow cracking down of any semblance of privacy and the use of all this data to discriminate whether intentional or not.

And indeed there have already been studies showing that a lot of these AI programs trained over large data sets are discriminating against minorities and the poor. I doubt it's intentionally built into the system but it appears to be a side effect of some systems.

Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by mrfusion on Saturday November 24, 2018 @06:08PM (#18524426)
I searched for a car model and my bank called me an hour later to talk about car loans!

That was my wake up moment.

Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by eh78ssxv2f on Saturday November 24, 2018 @07:57PM (#18524787)
Honestly, that just seems like a coincidence. Do you have thoughts on how that information got transferred?
Re:How my sexual health searches ended up in the hands of bi... by mrfusion on Saturday November 24, 2018 @08:36PM (#18524918)
I was logged into search under my gmail address. The bank has that same address on file. They’re probably buying a data feed from the search company.

If not, maybe one of the pages I landed on was able to see my info and has a marketing deal with the bank.