Re:Controlling the Spice, Part 1: Dune on Page and Screen
by duskwuff on Saturday November 24, 2018 @02:25PM
(#18523560)
The best Dune novel, IMO, is God Emperor of Dune. And it's completely unfilmable. The primary character is conspicuously nonhuman. Much of the exposition, as well as a number of important plot developments, are only delivered through his internal narrative. An attempted film adaptation would probably try to focus on one of the human secondary characters, and would, by so doing, completely miss the point of the book.
Re:Controlling the Spice, Part 1: Dune on Page and Screen
by ianai on Saturday November 24, 2018 @02:31PM
(#18523592)
I think they could focus on the worm/human internal struggle through actions made over the course of millennia. First movie being the plot that turns him toward the worm. Second movie being the gradual steps towards the worm and inhuman choices. Third movie being his death. (Forgive me if this is wrong somehow importantly. It’s been a while.). But you’re right on it being a big challenge.
Re:Controlling the Spice, Part 1: Dune on Page and Screen
by duskwuff on Saturday November 24, 2018 @02:41PM
(#18523640)
Much of what you're describing as the first and second movie is covered in Children of Dune. God Emperor is set several thousand years later, and would correspond to your third movie. The interim period is incredibly dull -- the boredom and stagnation of total societal stability is, in fact, an important theme of the book.
Re:Controlling the Spice, Part 1: Dune on Page and Screen
by bluejekyll on Saturday November 24, 2018 @02:26PM
(#18523568)
Yeah. It needs a Jackson like person and the entire crew from LOTR to really pull off. People with the same depth of understanding of the books.
LOTR’s art director had done amazing works before those movies, and it was neat to see that transposed to the screen.
I bet the studios look at it and don’t want to touch it based on the past performance of the movie.
My guess is that dune suffers from a dead author and it’s long passages on how societies work. Someone would need to translate the plots and central themes and ideas to the screen.