News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by yholio on Saturday November 24, 2018 @09:04AM (#18522047)
The price of houses is driven by market rents compounded with access to financing. If lenders are willing to finance an investment with 3% yield, then house prices will jump to 33x their annual rent value - it goes without saying that's only possible in low interest markets.

The rent itself however is controlled by supply and demand - there needs to be a real person there earning a paycheck and he must have no other options before going for a high rent house. Therefore, the options for keeping rents down are either keeping people out of the city through administrative means, or, realistically, building higher and denser. Good public transport infrastructure is an essential component because it opens for development distant areas that otherwise would not be desirable to people working in the city.

On the other hand, as the city grows, economies of scale bring in more businesses, create more high paying jobs and opportunities, therefore attracting more people - up to the point where rents and commute times increase again and restore equilibrium. A Malthusian catastrophe of sorts, that requires radical new transport solutions and workplace transformations, as opposed to building regulation and financial innovation.

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by usaar333 on Saturday November 24, 2018 @11:10AM (#18522640)
> If lenders are willing to finance an investment with 3% yield, then house prices will jump to 33x their annual rent value - it goes without saying that's only possible in low interest markets.

There's truth to this, but I don't think house prices should simply be (annual rent) / interest_rate. There's a variety of other homeowner costs to consider (property taxes, HOA, maintenance, etc.) and buyers are taking an opportunity cost not being able to invest their paid-down principal (including down payment) in riskier assets.

I have a calculator at https://medium.com/@usaar33/an-up-to-date-buy-or-rent-calcul... to find indifference point on the buyer side. Other huge inputs are future appreciation rates of investment and property. At default values, price moves at about half that of mortgage rate changes: e.g. halving the mortgage rate only raises the house price willing to pay by ~16%; doubling it, cuts price by ~25%.

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by thaumaturgy on Saturday November 24, 2018 @02:02PM (#18523458)
> The rent itself however is controlled by supply and demand

No, it's not. Folks have got to stop using simplistic remedial high school economics classes to explain complex social problems. They just aren't that simple.

During the 2008 financial implosion, a single investment company called Blackstone Group went on a buying spree around the US. As of this time last year, they owned, through a subsidiary company, fully 1.5% of the entire Sacramento-area rental house market [1]. Blackstone in turn is flush with cash from foreign investors [2].

Foreign cash investment in real estate is a major cause of high rental prices. But the data on this and investment companies like Blackstone Group is spotty and difficult to follow [3], on purpose.

These groups don't set prices according to "the market". They are more than happy to let some percentage of their properties remain empty rather than decreasing rental prices, because they can claim the lost rents -- at the prices they set -- as taxable deductions. It's a net win for them: keep the price high for all their other properties, get a writeoff on their empty properties.

Building more housing is not going to fix this part of the housing problem. There is more than enough foreign capital available to continue to keep housing prices artificially inflated no matter how many new homes are built. These are long-term investments and small fluctuations in available housing are not going to shake them loose.

Much more comprehensive investigation is needed in the actual causes of high housing costs, including the effects of foreign investment and investment firms, and then reform is needed to address those causes.

[1]: https://www.kcra.com/article/this-is-the-largest-owner-of-re...

[2]: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-10-22/how-black...

[3]: https://calmatters.org/articles/data-dig-are-foreign-investo...

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by darawk on Saturday November 24, 2018 @06:28PM (#18524496)
Basically none of that makes any economic sense. The fact that Blackstone can own 1.5% of the property in Sacramento is a supply issue. I.e. we are back to supply and demand. The entire rest of your post hinges on there being no supply response to demand. So yes, once again, everything is still and always will be mediated primarily by 'remedial high school economics'.

> Building more housing is not going to fix this part of the housing problem. There is more than enough foreign capital available to continue to keep housing prices artificially inflated no matter how many new homes are built.

No...that's not how anything works. Foreign capital is not infinite. And foreign capital invests in the US real estate market because it expects a return. If you change the expectation of supply, guess what happens? People don't want to invest in that asset anymore, and the capital dries up.

This is all a lot easier to see if you actually put yourself in the shoes of one of these 'foreign investors'. Don't think about them as an abstraction - think about yourself. If you were a rich Chinese businessman, ya, the SF property market is a great place to park your cash. Because it's supply constrained. But you better believe the moment that supply situation changes you're going to be running for the exit.

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by thaumaturgy on Saturday November 24, 2018 @07:47PM (#18524754)
These replies to my comment are super weird. I'm reading them collectively as, "I don't see how the influx of millions and millions of dollars of investment capital would have an effect on housing prices."

Well, okay, I guess. How many houses do you think need to be built to satisfy the investment needs of everyone looking to outperform the S&P 500? For extra credit, realize that this means that every metropolitan market is now an international investment vehicle.

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by darawk on Saturday November 24, 2018 @07:59PM (#18524793)
> These replies to my comment are super weird. I'm reading them collectively as, "I don't see how the influx of millions and millions of dollars of investment capital would have an effect on housing prices."

Huh? Let's talk about the rice market, rather than housing. Let's say you dump 1 trillion dollars into rice. What's going to happen? The price of rice rises, dramatically. However, rice farmers the world over see that price rise, and they start growing more rice. If you keep buying 1 trillion dollars worth of rice every year, the rice farmers will grow more rice in response, and the price will start to fall.

You, being a rational rice investor, will see that happening. And unless you're an idiot, will stop dumping your money into the rice market.

The only reason that houses are any different from rice is that housing is supply constrained, whereas rice is not.

> Well, okay, I guess. How many houses do you think need to be built to satisfy the investment needs of everyone looking to outperform the S&P 500? For extra credit, realize that this means that every metropolitan market is now an international investment vehicle.

This question doesn't make any sense. You don't create homes so everyone can outperform the S&P. That's like asking "how many stocks do we need to create for everyone to be an early investor in a decacorn?".

The question you're trying to ask is: How many houses do we need to build until the rate of return on buying property equals the rate of return of the stock market, adjusted by risk. To be precise, you want the number of homes that need to be built for the Sharpe ratio of the residential real estate market to equal the Sharpe ratio of the stock market.

That question is going to vary by geography. Many housing markets already dramatically underperform the S&P. It's only a very small number of them that perform better. In aggregate, housing already does underperform the S&P.

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by thaumaturgy on Saturday November 24, 2018 @09:11PM (#18525032)
I think I'm getting your comments. I don't think you're getting mine.

> What's going to happen? The price of rice rises, dramatically.

Yes, which is what has been happening in housing.

> However, rice farmers the world over see that price rise, and they start growing more rice.

And here's where your analogy falls over, because (a) the availability of land for residential real estate is not infinite; (b) it requires a far, far greater capital outlay (and time-to-market) to build housing than to farm rice; (c) developers are incentivized to build expensive housing because that's where they make more money.

That's where my earlier comment came from: the amount of new housing required to satisfy this equation from the supply side would be enormous, as would be the environmental destruction it would cause.

> And unless you're an idiot, will stop dumping your money into the rice market.

Only if there's a better place to park my wealth. That's where all this money is coming from: people with money, who want to make more money, and are dissatisfied with the returns available in a lot of other investment vehicles.

> It's only a very small number of them that perform better. In aggregate, housing already does underperform the S&P.

Oh, c'mon. Deal with me honestly here. We're not talking about BFE, Iowa, yeah? We're talking about housing in metropolitan areas, and I'm pretty sure I've been specific about that in my comments on the subject so far. Y'know, the areas where there is a lot of investment money -- demonstrably -- and where there are ridiculously high housing prices to go along with it.

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by darawk on Sunday November 25, 2018 @03:21AM (#18525962)
> And here's where your analogy falls over, because (a) the availability of land for residential real estate is not infinite; (b) it requires a far, far greater capital outlay (and time-to-market) to build housing than to farm rice; (c) developers are incentivized to build expensive housing because that's where they make more money.

Well, you're using the word 'availability', but that sounds a lot like 'supply' to me. So, i'm not sure we really disagree here. Though I would add that for the most part, land supply is not the constraining variable in almost all major metropolitan areas (exception for places like Hong Kong).

> Only if there's a better place to park my wealth. That's where all this money is coming from: people with money, who want to make more money, and are dissatisfied with the returns available in a lot of other investment vehicles.

Sure, so they bid it up until its risk-adjusted net-present-value equalizes with other assets. But all that is is restating the fact that these particular plots of land are worth a lot. It doesn't answer the question of why they are worth a lot. For that, you must look to supply constraints and network effects.

> Oh, c'mon. Deal with me honestly here. We're not talking about BFE, Iowa, yeah? We're talking about housing in metropolitan areas, and I'm pretty sure I've been specific about that in my comments on the subject so far. Y'know, the areas where there is a lot of investment money -- demonstrably -- and where there are ridiculously high housing prices to go along with it.

I'm not trying to deal with you dishonestly. I know you are talking about major metro areas. My point in pointing out the heterogeneity was to point out that we only know ex post that the particular areas you're thinking of have done well. If you were an investor in say, 2003, it may not have been such an easy call, and similarly, it may not be such an easy call now.

Let's say you had $10 million to invest. Where would you put it? Would you chuck it into SF real estate in the current market? I'm not sure I would. I think the market is quite high, especially given the rising interest rates, and I think the anti-nimby movement has gained a lot of steam, and the bay area has a lot to lose from that, in terms of property values. If I were trying to park $10 million, I think i'd actually shy away from areas with sky high valuations that are built on such monocultural foundations (tech).

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by jseliger on Saturday November 24, 2018 @02:42PM (#18523645)
Foreign cash investment in real estate is a major cause of high rental prices. But the data on this and investment companies like Blackstone Group is spotty and difficult to follow [3], on purpose.

That's not true. Zoning is the big problem: https://www.amazon.com/Rent-Too-Damn-High-Matters-ebook/dp/B... or see Zoning Rules! by Fischel.

Blackstone's investments only make sense because of artificial supply limits. Remove those, and their whole strategy is destroyed. The situation really is primarily about supply and demand.

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by wwweston on Saturday November 24, 2018 @02:25PM (#18523561)
> They are more than happy to let some percentage of their properties remain empty rather than decreasing rental prices, because they can claim the lost rents -- at the prices they set -- as taxable deductions.

How is it that a tax deduction can offset the opportunity cost of leaving a property vacant?

Or does it only offset the cost of what the unit would actually rent for at rates that naturally clear the supply/demand curve?

Could a vacancy tax fix this?

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by thaumaturgy on Saturday November 24, 2018 @02:52PM (#18523686)
> How is it that a tax deduction can offset the cost of leaving a property vacant?

I can't comprehensively answer this, because I'm not in the business and those that are, are tight-lipped about it. But it's definitely a contributing factor to high rates of empty storefronts [1]:

“If these landlords have deep pockets and large property portfolios, it may make more financial sense to claim a tax loss on vacant property than to rent at a non-optimal value.”

I'm assuming here that if this is a model that works in the commercial property investment market, it probably works in the residential property investment market too, as long as the investor has deep enough pockets and a long-enough financial strategy. Smaller, short-term residential property owners -- the individual landlord or small-time property management company -- probably wouldn't get as much of an advantage out of this.

> Or does it only offset the cost of what the unit would actually rent for at rates that naturally clear the supply/demand curve?

I dunno. I think we can make some educated guesses here.

If you own 1,000 single-family dwellings in a high-demand metropolitan area, like Sacramento, you've probably paid for those properties with cash or with foreign investment capital. There's no mortgage payment on it, so your costs for letting it sit empty are relatively low.

So let's say you maintain a 90% occupancy rate at rents that are significantly higher than they would be if you were forced by some regulation to maintain closer to 100%. Instead of rents varying from $2000/mo to $2700/mo for 100% of your properties, you ask for $2800/mo for 90% of your properties, and then your well-heeled mustache-twirling tax advisers find ways to write down the remaining 10% at as close to a $2800/mo loss each as possible. Hey, if anybody complains, you can just blame "the market".

> Could a vacancy tax fix this?

Some people think so, but I haven't seen a deep enough investigative piece to be certain. That's mostly what I wish for: a thorough investigation into this aspect of the housing problem that leads to some smart strategies for fixing it.

Population growth alone just doesn't explain the massive increase in cost of housing.

[1]: https://nypost.com/2018/03/30/de-blasio-eyes-vacancy-tax-for...

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by closeparen on Saturday November 24, 2018 @04:26PM (#18524056)
Foreign-ness of the investment capital may be important to the perceived moral valence if the transaction, but money is money.

The strategy of squatting on vacant property is essentially patience. For it to pay off, you do have to eventually rent it out (or sell it) when you think prices are high enough. For example, if you have deep enough pockets you might move during a recession, but wait until the recession is over to sell your old house, because you get a better price. If you never sell it, you’re tying up capital for no reason. The higher interest rates are, the more you’re losing in opportunity cost by owning a vacant building. Patience has probably been especially abundant in this decade of historically low interest rates.

Since no tax rate is 100%, a writeoff is never as good as a profit. It only softens the blow, which might extend the landlord’s patience in waiting for rents to cycle back up to $2800.

Another thing that happens is the project’s financing is contingent on a certain average rent, but the contract doesn’t factor in $0 rent empty units, just leaves them out of the calculation. This is essentially a bug. It’s one reason landlords give signing bonus concessions instead of just lowering the rent.

In markets seeing runaway costs, vacancy is at historic lows. No one is investigating this too thoroughly because fixing it wouldn’t be very fruitful.

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by dlubarov on Saturday November 24, 2018 @04:08PM (#18523994)
> they can claim the lost rents -- at the prices they set -- as taxable deductions

Can you provide a source? This doesn't seem right. A vacant unit produces no revenue, but the "lost rent" doesn't constitute an expense.

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by Apes on Saturday November 24, 2018 @02:31PM (#18523598)
So let me make sure I'm understanding you correctly.

You're positing that the proof supply and demand is not applicable to the housing market is that a private investment company has greatly increased demand beyond what the housing supply can support, which is driving up prices.

And the fact that demand exceeding supply is driving up prices is proof that supply and demand does not apply to the housing market?

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by closeparen on Saturday November 24, 2018 @04:10PM (#18524001)
Investors invest because they believe there will be a good return. A drastically increasing ratio of people to homes can’t not drive up prices in a way that will deliver that return.

Sure there are many factors at play, interacting with each other in strange ways. But there is no amount of complexity that will let you settle 100 families in 10 houses.

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by yardie on Saturday November 24, 2018 @03:02PM (#18523731)
As an aside the rental market in my area (So. Fla.) has started to drop. Property managers are doing everything in their power except lowering the rent, including $0 deposits, waived application fees, waived first and last months, and free parking. The rent hasn't changed and if you speak to a property manager or investor it's still a solid investment. But to renter's all these waived items definitely points to lowered rent.
Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by pizzazzaro on Saturday November 24, 2018 @03:21PM (#18523800)
You are neglecting the hidden sources of consumer-side competition, and their effect of driving up prices:

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-11-19/foreign-i...

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by esotericn on Saturday November 24, 2018 @09:25AM (#18522120)
What influences the willingness of a lender?

Availability of money in the general lending environment, sure, but surely there's a risk component there.

The low interest rates can only persist as long as a lender has a reasonable expectation that they'll be paid back (e.g. that rents remain high enough to sustain the mortgage over the term).

The real world factors like 'how desirable a place is'/'are good jobs there' and so forth seem to be further back in the causation chain to me.

This is probably why we see the sort of "non-linear growth" that we do. An environment with stable, increasing rents due to increased demand _directly_ increases the price of housing linearly, and then on top of that it's a less risky market as a result so you end up with lower interest rates which drive it even further.

A mortgage at 3% is basically a risk-free rate. Lenders are saying "you can't lose by buying here so go wild".

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by Spooky23 on Saturday November 24, 2018 @10:08AM (#18522305)
A: Closing the deal.

The only exposure your bank has in terms of losing money is losing the costs associated with starting up the loan when you apply — there is a strong incentive to approve. The government owns the risk on performance.

This was a policy choice, because banks making subjective decisions usually looked a lot like redlining. Nobody would write a loan on a luxury condo in a rehabbed factory in the inner city because it’s a measurably higher risk. Bad schools, high crime, pollution, and risk of the condo board doing dumb things makes that a risk for the bank.

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by commaone on Sunday November 25, 2018 @08:16AM (#18526745)
I think it's also worth mentioning that these local banks are still bundling and selling mortgages as securities,therefore removing the risk of long term price and payment instability. I find it odd that no one has even mentioned this, given we have just been through the largest financial crisis in generations because of it.
Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by bradleyjg on Saturday November 24, 2018 @09:37AM (#18522167)
The lender on a very percentage of loans made in the United States since 2008 is directly or indirectly the federal government. The federal government is not constrained by the reasonable expectation of being paid back or market discipline.
Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by Theodores on Saturday November 24, 2018 @10:58AM (#18522575)
Years ago in the UK there was a considerable quantity of council owned properties, these were nice places to live with nice rents to pay. There was no shame in living in a council house, but you wouldn't be buying it, so it was not yours. You wouldn't be evicted either or forced to pay through the nose.

This worked as a baseline, if you had more money or wanted to live in a posh area (or just the countryside) then you could rent elsewhere. Or buy.

Councils could extend their stock of housing and there could be benefits of scale, e.g. replace everyone's windows for double glazed at the same time on the whole street.

In this market there was an anchor on house price inflation as well as market rents. Why pay double to live in somewhere not looked after just to line the pockets of a rent-seeker?

Then Margaret Thatcher came along. Nowadays we don't have council housing. There is some but none is available. Councils aren't allowed to build/buy more. With 'right to buy' the council housing was sold on to rent-seekers, none of whom have any interest at all in the community and only have an interest in making money, not housing people. The rent-seekers have portfolios as bit as large as councils used to have in some instances.

Social mobility is lost now that we have rent-seeker owned properties, you can't just move as easily as was possible with council owned housing. This has been great for the rent seekers as well as their banks. For people wanting to be part of the community, bring up a family and do legit work this has not been so good. Either you are a serf or a rent seeker. There was a time when it was not like that.

The red carpet has been rolled out all the way for the rent seekers, the silly interest rates and notionally low inflation (which does not include rent) means that their capital accumulates, they can leverage and steal more homes from people who deserve to be 'on the ladder'.

Normal working people are forced to pay ever higher sums of money to the rent seekers as they have no choice. So you have two people working to pay for a single bedroom flat, with no money to spare or kids or even cars. You would be really shocked if you saw how some people live in London, people that do service sector stuff have nothing. Pigeons fare better.

People nowadays have no knowledge of how well a stock of council houses serves the community, all they know is the world of the rent seeker. Politicians 'demand' more affordable housing but that doesn't fix the problem, you need capital to deteriorate if invested in property, an anchor in rent prices and for people to be able to live not speculate. It is not hard to get right and not mankind's hardest problem. Apart from anything else having property as the only asset that accumulates is wrong, people should be investing capital in business, old and startup, not forcing the next generation out of their homes.

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by esotericn on Saturday November 24, 2018 @11:31AM (#18522721)
Right.

In the UK, societally, we've decided that we don't value everyone having a decent place to live.

We don't seem to really have a "goal" for our society, I think. Maybe "everyone should have a job". But that's indirect; people want jobs because they (ideally) result in outcomes like feeling like you're contributing and receiving a stable life in response.

"Everyone gets a house if they want" is a really solid goal to aim for that we've just sort of given up on. It's not unviable at all, it's just politically been brushed aside.

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by __blockcipher__ on Saturday November 24, 2018 @12:11PM (#18522915)
Tread carefully. Implement such a policy naively and you end up with the American dream: everyone tied to mortgages they can’t afford.

Of course the core problem is treating affordability as merely a function of access to loans, without accounting for second / higher order effects.

You’re clearly not proposing that, but it is of course an easy trap for a society to fall into

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by EliRivers on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:14PM (#18534883)
Maybe "everyone should have a job".

I think that's just a spin on the real "goal", or at least the feeling behind it; people don't deserve any help when they're down because they could have a job.

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by tonyedgecombe on Saturday November 24, 2018 @12:33PM (#18523021)
Not only this but there have been other problems caused by making social housing just for the needy rather than ordinary working people. You end up with a concentration of poverty that is hard to escape from, people with no role models and hence gangs and violence.
Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by jackkinsella on Saturday November 24, 2018 @05:11PM (#18524236)
The plentiful council housing, while certainly wonderful for the reasons you gave, did come at a cost. I was surprised to learn that the upper tax rate on income over 20k pounds in 1974 was 83%, rising to 98% for investment income. [1] I believe this trend was what the Beetles sang about in Taxman.

1 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_taxation_in_the_U...

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by s4vi0r on Saturday November 24, 2018 @10:46AM (#18522502)
Or just destroying the entire cancerous concept of landlordism and housing as a commodity.

No need to get all complicated, the solution is pretty simple.

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by mmirate on Saturday November 24, 2018 @10:57AM (#18522568)
What exactly would remain after this "destruction" of yours?
Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by s4vi0r on Saturday November 24, 2018 @08:37PM (#18524923)
Not sure why, but I couldn't respond to your comment for quite some time.

I'm not sure what you're asking re: what would remain. Housing as a human right, I guess? There's no good reason for landlords to exist, nor do I understand why you would want housing to be a commodity especially considering we live in a post-2008 world.

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by conanbatt on Saturday November 24, 2018 @11:54PM (#18525528)
There can't be "no landlords". Someone owns the land, even if its the State.

Beware of that solution: you have a chance to fight a landlord, you have no chance to fight the state-landlord.

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by s4vi0r on Sunday November 25, 2018 @02:44AM (#18525853)
Yes, but the state isn't leeching off of the people. My point is wrt landlords in the sense of people who do nothing, provide no value, and make money solely by virtue of "I/my ancestor was here first I/they bought this when there was less people so gimme money".

I don't see where you get your conclusion from. For many (most?) people, they really don't have a chance to fight their landlord. Legal expenses, time, energy, etc. are pretty huge deterrents. Not sure why you can't fight a "state-landlord", also.

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by conanbatt on Sunday November 25, 2018 @02:58PM (#18528673)
> Yes, but the state isn't leeching off of the people

Are you sure about that. US government spending is 1/3 of GDP, while rents are around 1/10.

> Not sure why you can't fight a "state-landlord"

Because the state has the power to make it illegal to sue the state. You need to win a supreme court case to beat the state into something, and you will be paying taxes to fund your opposition all the way up to the supreme court.

Re:There is more to high house prices than constrained supply by tonyedgecombe on Saturday November 24, 2018 @12:57PM (#18523153)
Presumably what the government in the UK is already doing, gradually adjusting taxes to make the rentier economy less viable over time.