Re:Why Facebook Will Never Fix Facebook
by bobbygoodlatte on Friday November 23, 2018 @06:08PM
(#18519425)
There's something ironic about Buzzfeed advocating for content distribution reforms on Facebook. Buzzfeed owes its entire existence to gaming Facebook's engagement algorithm via clickbait.
What if the fix Buzzfeed is asking for involves less distribution for outlets like Buzzfeed? I'd support that.
Re:Why Facebook Will Never Fix Facebook
by adt2bt on Friday November 23, 2018 @06:45PM
(#18519544)
The irony isn’t lost on me, but it does not mean the article is wrong in some way because it is published by Buzzfeed News.
If anything, I would be inclined to trust Buzzfeed’s expertise in garnering views, clicks and ad revenue from Facebook when it comes to them criticizing the system they thrive in.
Additionally, if those changes drive less traffic to Buzzfeed, it will likely hurt publishers across the board and they will all have to change to survive. Perhaps that could be in the general best interest.
Re:Why Facebook Will Never Fix Facebook
by majani on Friday November 23, 2018 @10:25PM
(#18520294)
Less distribution for outlets like Buzzfeed already happened. Facebook has cut reach to pages so badly of late that even boosting posts hardly gets any of the virality of yesteryear. Nowadays if your post doesn't get people clicking the share button found on the Facebook post, it's not gonna get very far.
Re:Why Facebook Will Never Fix Facebook
by jseliger on Friday November 23, 2018 @05:51PM
(#18519352)
Perhaps this shouldn’t come as a surprise. Facebook, after all, is a platform historically powered by prioritizing and rewarding a very simplistic idea of user engagement. You react to something, or you don’t. And if you do, you’ll see more of the same.
This again. It's another variant on the themes I discuss in "Is there an actual Facebook crisis, or media narrative about Facebook crisis?" https://jakeseliger.com/2018/11/14/is-there-an-actual-facebo.... Facebook will change when users quit or dramatically cut back using it. Until then, actual users are telling Facebook, "Full steam ahead."
Re:Why Facebook Will Never Fix Facebook
by nemild on Friday November 23, 2018 @06:01PM
(#18519400)
I don't agree. Facebook has to make changes given the risk of regulation, reputational risk, recruiting challenges, and the mismatch in their own self-professed mission.
We can debate if the change will be substantial enough to truly change things (I'm doubtful), but they have already made changes due to this media coverage (hiring more content moderators as just one example).
Throughout history, media has always had to weigh the tradeoffs of informing people vs engaging people. Yellow journalism in the US was an example of when the engagement imperative overwhelmed the informing imperative, and the issues did lead to changes in media. Facebook is going through this same journey (though painfully and slowly).
Re:Why Facebook Will Never Fix Facebook
by slavik81 on Friday November 23, 2018 @08:56PM
(#18519986)
One of the things that protects a business from political action is a large group of stakeholders who care. Facebook's problem is not that their users are entirely abandoning the platform, but that their users no longer care enough to defend them.
Re:Why Facebook Will Never Fix Facebook
by jrauser on Friday November 23, 2018 @11:05PM
(#18520387)
What if Facebook is exploiting the same weaknesses that cigarette companies or drug dealers or casinos do? Have you ever walked into a casino and seen truly sad people whiling away their time and money? Have you ever walked past a homeless heroin addict on the street? You might argue that those people have revealed their preferences, but to me it appears that they are trapped in addictive cycle reinforced by unscrupulous predators. That billions of people might be trapped in such an addictive cycle that feeds them intellectual poison is at least cause for alarm if not a full-on crisis.
Re:Why Facebook Will Never Fix Facebook
by wildmusings on Friday November 23, 2018 @07:00PM
(#18519594)
Content regulation is very unlikely in the US given the Court’s near-absolutist First Amendment jurisprudence. Regulation of advertising and privacy is more plausible, but something like the GDPR is a constitutional and political non-starter in America.
Re:Why Facebook Will Never Fix Facebook
by threeseed on Friday November 23, 2018 @07:38PM
(#18519728)
GDPR comprises many facets many of which are completely constitutional.
And it maybe a political non-starter federally but all it takes is a few states in particular New York and California to impose restrictions and you will have the same effect.
Re:Why Facebook Will Never Fix Facebook
by twblalock on Friday November 23, 2018 @08:43PM
(#18519950)
Especially considering Facebook is based in California, which is controlled by the Democratic party. Many people in that party blame Facebook for helping Trump win the 2016 election.
Re:Why Facebook Will Never Fix Facebook
by threeseed on Friday November 23, 2018 @07:35PM
(#18519719)
I don't understand why Facebook is being singled out here.
Because the underlying issue is time spent on the internet as a whole. Each of the negatives that can be attributed to Facebook apply equally to sites like Youtube, Instagram, Snapchat, Twitter etc. And ultimately Facebook is just a website that exposes humanities's neuroses and problems to itself.
And I still love the hypocrisy of this coming from Buzzfeed whose entire existence centres around driving traffic through jealousy, fake news, clickbait etc.
Re:Why Facebook Will Never Fix Facebook
by CharlesW on Friday November 23, 2018 @07:50PM
(#18519766)
> I don't understand why Facebook is being singled out here.
From where I sit, they're not. Facebook is the canary in the coal mine because of its current outsized influence, but you can find similar pieces about all of the services you mentioned.
Re:Why Facebook Will Never Fix Facebook
by WheelsAtLarge on Friday November 23, 2018 @08:04PM
(#18519826)
The real question is: What is the fix? People want social networks but they are opposed to giving their data away or paying for the service. How does a company survive without revenue?
The least path of resistance is giving the service free to users and selling their data. The only fix comes from the users, not Facebook, and that's to stop using the service. Facebook will continue to monetize the user's data as part of their business model. There is no fix from their side.
Re:Why Facebook Will Never Fix Facebook
by makecheck on Friday November 23, 2018 @09:54PM
(#18520191)
Do we know people wouldn’t want to pay? I know Facebook never asked me if I would. People have a track record of paying for services like television. They might pay for social networks if given a chance. Charge me two dollars a month, make all the creepy spying illegal, and the remnants of Facebook are useful (staying connected to friends, etc.).
Re:Why Facebook Will Never Fix Facebook
by jiveturkey on Friday November 23, 2018 @10:11PM
(#18520252)
huh? facebook isn’t broken. it’s a monetization platform, not a force for good. they will DTRT to keep money rolling in. this talk about addictive patterns is a sideshow.
Re:Why Facebook Will Never Fix Facebook
by ams6110 on Friday November 23, 2018 @05:47PM
(#18519338)
Tldr: the incentives that govern the platform (gamifying and monetizing attention, as well as prioritizing clicks, shares, ads, and money over quality of information) will largely remain the same.
Re:Why Facebook Will Never Fix Facebook
by dane-pgp on Friday November 23, 2018 @06:28PM
(#18519490)
Thank you for the tl;dr. It makes sense that the forces applying to Facebook are largely economic ones.
I wonder if someone has attempted a first-principles estimate of the cost per user of running a site with similar levels of interaction as Facebook.
Ignoring costs for software development, media hosting, and moderation (none of which are trivial), would it be possible to support just basic text-based social networking with an income stream based solely on displaying unpersonalised ads (and without manipulating which content gets shown to users)?
I'm imagining a federated social network, but maybe there are cost savings if you have effectively a monopoly and don't have to interoperate with other sites.
What if the fix Buzzfeed is asking for involves less distribution for outlets like Buzzfeed? I'd support that.
If anything, I would be inclined to trust Buzzfeed’s expertise in garnering views, clicks and ad revenue from Facebook when it comes to them criticizing the system they thrive in.
Additionally, if those changes drive less traffic to Buzzfeed, it will likely hurt publishers across the board and they will all have to change to survive. Perhaps that could be in the general best interest.
But if those reforms actually happen, I bet the executive team at Buzzfeed won't be happy
This again. It's another variant on the themes I discuss in "Is there an actual Facebook crisis, or media narrative about Facebook crisis?" https://jakeseliger.com/2018/11/14/is-there-an-actual-facebo.... Facebook will change when users quit or dramatically cut back using it. Until then, actual users are telling Facebook, "Full steam ahead."
We can debate if the change will be substantial enough to truly change things (I'm doubtful), but they have already made changes due to this media coverage (hiring more content moderators as just one example).
Throughout history, media has always had to weigh the tradeoffs of informing people vs engaging people. Yellow journalism in the US was an example of when the engagement imperative overwhelmed the informing imperative, and the issues did lead to changes in media. Facebook is going through this same journey (though painfully and slowly).
And it maybe a political non-starter federally but all it takes is a few states in particular New York and California to impose restrictions and you will have the same effect.
Are they? U.S. Facebook traffic fell nearly 50% over the last two years.[1]
Yes, they've got other properties cushioning the fall. But Yahoo! had lots of other properties, too.
[1] https://market-intelligence.io/analysis/shakeup-in-top-five-...
Because the underlying issue is time spent on the internet as a whole. Each of the negatives that can be attributed to Facebook apply equally to sites like Youtube, Instagram, Snapchat, Twitter etc. And ultimately Facebook is just a website that exposes humanities's neuroses and problems to itself.
And I still love the hypocrisy of this coming from Buzzfeed whose entire existence centres around driving traffic through jealousy, fake news, clickbait etc.
From where I sit, they're not. Facebook is the canary in the coal mine because of its current outsized influence, but you can find similar pieces about all of the services you mentioned.
Here's an example, but I ran across a bunch more just looking for this one: https://www.wired.co.uk/article/youtube-for-kids-videos-prob...
The least path of resistance is giving the service free to users and selling their data. The only fix comes from the users, not Facebook, and that's to stop using the service. Facebook will continue to monetize the user's data as part of their business model. There is no fix from their side.
Not to say they haven't also been corrupt to increase engagement because they have...
Facebook recently changed their algorithm to deliberately focus on the quality of engagement.
It had a material effect on marketers and news organisations so it was pretty significant.
I wonder if someone has attempted a first-principles estimate of the cost per user of running a site with similar levels of interaction as Facebook.
Ignoring costs for software development, media hosting, and moderation (none of which are trivial), would it be possible to support just basic text-based social networking with an income stream based solely on displaying unpersonalised ads (and without manipulating which content gets shown to users)?
I'm imagining a federated social network, but maybe there are cost savings if you have effectively a monopoly and don't have to interoperate with other sites.