News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My dalliance with smart drugs - and the lesson I learned by silentbicycle on Saturday October 30, 2010 @10:52AM (#1850962)
Wow! Yet another article about "smart drugs" that's actually about stimulants! I give it one hour before people start mentioning Erdos and talking about amphetamines instead. (Edit: Yup, and now I'm getting downvoted.)

Here's a much better article about actual smart drugs (http://sites.google.com/site/thinkinginanutshell/nootropics), and its HN discussion (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1211959). Sorting them in terms of risk & body load is a good idea, I think. He's not kidding when he says vaso-/desmopressin messes with homeostasis.

The racetams (piracetam, aniracetam, oxiracetam, etc.) are probably the least risky, though I've had the best long-term effects from getting enough sleep and exercise, eating reasonably well, and not spiking and crashing on caffeine all the time. If you want to try nootropics, be informed and careful, and address the obvious factors that may be messing with your concentration first. (For me it was sleep debt and too much caffeine.)

Re:My dalliance with smart drugs - and the lesson I learned by hamilcarbarca on Saturday October 30, 2010 @02:54PM (#1851516)
This site is very informative, easily the best hub of nootropic information I have seen. There are links from each of the drugs to the medical studies, user surveys, etc.

http://www.imminst.org/forum/topic/43394-nootropics-thread-i...

Also read: Ten months of research condensed - A total newbies guide to nootropics: http://www.imminst.org/forum/topic/36691-ten-months-of-resea...

Choline + Piracetam + Melatonin are what I use. All are 100% legal, nonprescription, effective and safe (according to all scientific research so far).

Routine exercise has been shown repeatedly to provide tremendous gains to mental cognition. Get yourself to a baseline that includes daily cardiac exercise before jumping into the great chemical unknown.

I have tried both adrafinil (legal/unregulated in USA, metabolized in vivo to modafinil) and armodafinil. The best way I could describe them is that they provide the wakefulness provided by caffeine, without the attention deficit hyperactivity. While they are certainly both interesting and effective, cost is prohibitive.

Stay away from amphetamines. Regardless of the potential for physical dependence, you will rapidly develop a mental dependency on them. For a short while I had a prescription for ritalin and adderall (stopped taking them on my own accord)and can admit that they made me feel superhuman. However, they also provide a hellish overconfidence that can cripple you. I was not more creative and was ironically less focused upon the important aspects of my work. Information triage is far more difficult when everything in the world suddenly becomes worth of intense study.

Re:My dalliance with smart drugs - and the lesson I learned by fragmede on Saturday October 30, 2010 @03:11PM (#1851560)
Is there actually a medical definition of "smart drugs"? I know some seriously smart people with a serious caffeine addiction who have an IQ of about 85 before their morning coffee.
Re:My dalliance with smart drugs - and the lesson I learned by silentbicycle on Saturday October 30, 2010 @03:31PM (#1851598)
Medical journals usually use the term "nootropics". "smart drugs" is more of a catch-all, and makes me think of Mondo 2000 (cyberpunk! fractals! subvert the dominant paradigm!) rather than medical research.

And: Don't underestimate the short-term effects of caffeine withdrawl (and daily rituals). They're probably waking up mentally at -2 cups of coffee. Caffeine use seems to be more beneficial when used in small quantities over the day (a thermos of green tea* , slightly-caffeinated candy every hour or two, etc.) rather than spiking levels first thing in the morning.

* And there's an amino acid in green tea, l-theanine, that seems to cancel out some of the jitteriness.

Re:My dalliance with smart drugs - and the lesson I learned by dejb on Saturday October 30, 2010 @07:55PM (#1852086)
>>> Yet another article about "smart drugs" that's actually about stimulants!

> "smart drugs" is more of a catch-all

So which is it? It seems to me (and you apparently) that the term "smart drugs" is rightly a catch-all for anything that can enhance mental performance, including stimulants. So the original article used the term correctly and this part of your earlier criticism doesn't make sense.

Re:My dalliance with smart drugs - and the lesson I learned by silentbicycle on Saturday October 30, 2010 @08:20PM (#1852129)
I'm using the term "smart drugs" to match the original post, but left it in quotes - I'd be more inclined to say "nootropics", which (intentionally) narrows the scope a bit.

Every couple months a post comes up on HN about nootropics, and within a few hours it typically gets derailed by comments about how taking speed is totally awesome. I try to remind people that 1) amphetamines are not "smart drugs", they have pretty nasty side effects and are generally unsustainable, 2) if taking nootropics (or any other drugs) it's a good idea to do research first, and HN doesn't count, 3) some are much less risky than others, and 4) they'll probably get more benefits from getting enough sleep and exercise, if they aren't already.

Re:My dalliance with smart drugs - and the lesson I learned by roel_v on Sunday October 31, 2010 @11:08AM (#1853357)
It's disingenuous to throw 'ritalin' in the same basket as 'speed', even if they're in the same pharmaceutical family. 'Speed' as sold on the street is ingested orally or nasally in an attempt to concentrate its effects in a short time period, Ritalin (and similar) is prescribed in much smaller amounts (20-80 mg a day, for speed it's not uncommon to consume 250 mg at once); plus slow-release versions of Ritalin (Ritalin MR, Concerta etc.) make this effect even stronger. Some experimentation with Ritalin is necessary to find out a person's correct dosage, when you really get a 'hit' like you do with speed, it's not used properly. Plus, people who actually have ADHD react differently to Ritalin that people who don't. Please don't just throw out blanket statements about how 'Ritalin is bad' - for some people it makes the difference between being able to function normally and not being able to plan their daily lives.
Re:My dalliance with smart drugs - and the lesson I learned by silentbicycle on Sunday October 31, 2010 @01:05PM (#1853637)
I never mentioned Ritalin. I meant Adderall and particularly amphetamines.

I know Ritalin is helpful for some people.

Re:My dalliance with smart drugs - and the lesson I learned by dejb on Sunday October 31, 2010 @06:56AM (#1853044)
Oh I see. You're using the term "smart drugs" in 2 different ways. One to mean 'intelligence enhancing' and the other 'a smart idea to take'. Kind of like a pun or some really corny anti-drugs commercial.
Re:My dalliance with smart drugs - and the lesson I learned by joshu on Saturday October 30, 2010 @11:53AM (#1851083)
Modafinil isn't a stimulant.
Re:My dalliance with smart drugs - and the lesson I learned by Construct on Saturday October 30, 2010 @12:38PM (#1851203)
Modafinil is most certainly a stimulant.

Its mode of action isn't identical to that of Adderall (amphetamine) and Ritalin (methylphenidate) but then again neither is that of caffeine, but it is still a stimulant. Adderall and Ritalin increase extra-cellular concentrations of dopamine and norepinephrine. Modafinil has been shown in many studies to elevate dopamine and norepinephrine concentrations in certain regions of the brain. It may not accomplish this as directly as Ritalin or Adderall, but the effect is there. There are additional glutamate-enhancing and GABA-reducing effects to Modafinil as well, which is perhaps where the "Modafinil is not a stimulant" misconception comes from. Still, administering a dopamine antagonist diminishes some of Modafinil's effects, much in the same way it diminishes the effects of Adderall or Ritalin.

But even without delving into the pharmacology of Modafinil, how you can you possibly not call Modafinil a stimulant? It promotes wakefulness, increases concentration, and substitutes for Adderall and Ritalin in narcolepsy treatment. It is also a Schedule IV controlled substance (FYI, do not attempt to import a controlled substance, but Adrafanil is a Modafinil precursor and is not scheduled.) indicating there is even a risk of abuse.

Re:My dalliance with smart drugs - and the lesson I learned by digitailor on Saturday October 30, 2010 @02:45PM (#1851502)
The PDR describes its action as "unknown," and says it is not a stimulant. This is a common error.
Re:My dalliance with smart drugs - and the lesson I learned by _delirium on Saturday October 30, 2010 @05:31PM (#1851857)
The manufacturer and FDA seem to consider it at least similar to a stimulant, with stimulant-like effects and possible dependence problems typical of stimulants.

From the prescribing information:

In addition to its wake-promoting effects and ability to increase locomotor activity in animals, modafinil produces psychoactive and euphoric effects, alterations in mood, perception, thinking, and feelings typical of other CNS stimulants in humans. Modafinil has reinforcing properties, as evidenced by its self-administration in monkeys previously trained to self-administer cocaine. Modafinil was also partially discriminated as stimulant-like.

And from the safety information label:

PROVIGIL is a Schedule IV drug. PROVIGIL produces psychoactive and euphoric effects, alterations in mood, perception, thinking and feelings typical of other CNS stimulants. Physicians should follow patients closely, especially those with a history of drug and/or stimulant abuse.

Re:My dalliance with smart drugs - and the lesson I learned by digitailor on Saturday October 30, 2010 @06:26PM (#1851934)
I don't like the legal speeds. I would not accept a prescription for one.

Modafinil feels very different from the legal speeds, crank, coke, or other heavy stimulants... not that I know that from experience or anything. Just from reading posts on HN and Slashdot and shit. And movies. And ex-girlfriends. And doing drugs. Oh wait.

So I don't sound like I'm in love with modafinil: I have seen a person react unfavorably on it, although I can't be certain it was the modafinil that caused the unfavorable reaction. I have not had any side effects I can tell. Besides the new hairs on the tip of my nose and severe tooth vibrations. [Just kidding, obv.]

It has its place, and it just helped me on a trip to China considerably.

Re:My dalliance with smart drugs - and the lesson I learned by silentbicycle on Saturday October 30, 2010 @12:36PM (#1851190)
Then what is it? I don't have a PDR on hand, but Wikipedia says it's an "analeptic", a central nervous system stimulant used specifically to control sleepiness.
Re:My dalliance with smart drugs - and the lesson I learned by mmt on Sunday October 31, 2010 @09:49AM (#1853230)
I find rxlist.com contains essentially the same (straight from the manufacturer) information as a PDR, without the bulk, expense, and latency of paper distribution.
Re:My dalliance with smart drugs - and the lesson I learned by digitailor on Saturday October 30, 2010 @02:45PM (#1851501)
The PDR describes its action as "unknown."
Re:My dalliance with smart drugs - and the lesson I learned by silentbicycle on Saturday October 30, 2010 @03:36PM (#1851607)
Does that mean something like, "it has stimulant-like effects, but its actual mechanism is more complex and not fully understood"?

Serious question, not trying to sound flippant.

Re:My dalliance with smart drugs - and the lesson I learned by digitailor on Saturday October 30, 2010 @03:57PM (#1851663)
The PDR is very vague on this for a reason- they have no idea. The doctors I have spoken to about it seem to think it is not a stimulant, it is something "better." They are calling it a wakefulness promoting agent. This isn't just PR boobspeak- the docs don't equate it with speed or coke, and with good reason. It has NOT been shown to have the long term damaging effects on dopamine and serotonin receptors those drugs do.
Re:My dalliance with smart drugs - and the lesson I learned by silentbicycle on Saturday October 30, 2010 @04:14PM (#1851702)
Ok, thanks.

IIRC, the exact mechanism for piracetam isn't fully understood either (something involving acetylcholine) - they decided to create the "nootropic" designation for it rather than classify it as a stimulant. The general consensus is that it's safe (no known LD-50, relatively mild side-effects) and makes orange juice taste horrible.

Re:My dalliance with smart drugs - and the lesson I learned by digitailor on Saturday October 30, 2010 @02:47PM (#1851506)
Please discontinue downvoting the parent comment, it is correct. Provigil is not classed a stimulant in the PDR.
Re:My dalliance with smart drugs - and the lesson I learned by Construct on Saturday October 30, 2010 @03:30PM (#1851597)
Arguing that Modafinil is not a stimulant is like arguing that alcohol is not a drug. Sure, you can twist words and definitions, but all you're doing is re-drawing the cutoff line between what is and what is not a stimulant.

Modafinil is not a typical stimulant, but it provides stimulation, increases brain activity, increases self-reported measures of aggression, restlessness, and anxiety in double-blind testing, is a controlled substance with recognized abuse potential, and many of the stimulating effects are blocked by the same drugs that block the effects of stimulants.

Cephalon marketing is probably eager to get away and "stimulant" moniker, but this is an argument over semantics rather than pharmacology.

Modafinil is, by all measures and effects, a stimulant.

Re:My dalliance with smart drugs - and the lesson I learned by digitailor on Saturday October 30, 2010 @03:51PM (#1851648)
We are talking about medical and pharmaceutical classification here. "Stimulant" has a medical meaning. Provigil has NOT been classed a stimulant, which has a specific meaning.

The Physician's Drug Reference (PDR) is the last word on this, legally. That is why I keep saying it is not a stimulant. It isn't until the PDR says it is, to any medical professional.

I have taken a lot of Provigil, and I understand why it has not been classified a stimulant. It does not have the physical effects of other stimulants.

With the education and intelligence level being so high here on HN, I'm surprised to see inaccurate information being posited so confidently. It is NOT medically correct, and I'm not sure what the value of the non-medically correct "definition" of stimulant you are giving is supposed to be.

Re:My dalliance with smart drugs - and the lesson I learned by Construct on Saturday October 30, 2010 @06:27PM (#1851936)
The Physician's Drug Reference (PDR) is not the last word on this. It is literally just a desk reference, as the name implies. It isn't meant to be a definitive guide to medications. It is meant to be a quick and easy way for physicians to get an overview of a medication.

The following is taken directly from the FDA's website for Modafinil ( http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/drugsatfda_docs/label/2007/020... ). This information is also included in the product information sheet you receive with your prescription, and on the Provigil website. To say that Modafinil does not have the physical effects of other stimulants is not true. They are present to a lesser degree, but still exist.

  In addition to its wake-promoting effects and ability to
 increase locomotor activity in animals, modafinil produces 
 psychoactive and euphoric effects, alterations in mood, 
 perception, thinking, and feelings typical of other CNS 
 stimulants in humans. Modafinil has reinforcing properties,
 as evidenced by its self-administration in monkeys previously
 trained to self-administer cocaine. Modafinil was also
 partially discriminated as stimulant-like.
Re:My dalliance with smart drugs - and the lesson I learned by digitailor on Saturday October 30, 2010 @06:41PM (#1851972)
I am prescribed Provigil for a sleep disorder called Delayed Sleep Phase Syndrome.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delayed_sleep_phase_syndrome

Modafinil has been a help to me while stimulants have NOT been. I have a lot of experience with both, as I have talked about in various posts on this thread.

The difference between "stimulant" and "stimulant-like" is both small and vast. Think Uncanny Valley. "Human" and "human-like..."

Also, I am unsure what point you are trying to argue. I will give you stimulant-like, sure, although it does not make your heart race, a MAJOR PROBLEM with stimulants.

The FDA info you quote DOES NOT CALL MODAFINIL A STIMULANT!

Re:My dalliance with smart drugs - and the lesson I learned by Construct on Saturday October 30, 2010 @07:07PM (#1852011)
Nor does the FDA info I quoted say that Modafinil is not a stimulant. Either way, you're arguing semantics and using personal anecdotes as your sources. We've already established that the effects of Modafinil are similar to that of other stimulants, and I've linked multiple studies showing that its mode of action overlaps with that of stimulants, and that the side effects of traditional stimulants show up in Modafinil (albeit with reduced frequency and magnitude). You can call it what you want, but none of that changes what I've posted here.

I'm going to step out of this debate, as arguing semantics only detracts from the topic at hand at this point.