News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The quest for freedom and safety: Why I donated $100,000 ... by InclinedPlane on Friday October 29, 2010 @07:13PM (#1849441)
The idea that anyone has the right to regulate someone else's life based on morality is deeply puritanical. It may seem like a different problem when posed in the form of a highly addictive and often destructive behavior such as meth use but it's still the same fundamental issue.

How much harm does being homeless do to society? How much harm does having a bad credit score do to society? Smoking cigarettes? Listening to thrash metal? Rock climbing? Eating a cheeseburger? Being HIV positive? What's the proper response to these sorts of things?

History has shown us in no uncertain terms that it is impossible to protect people from themselves. And every attempt to do so will fail utterly. Will result in more harm to the individual and more harm to society than the problem attempted to be addressed. There are good ways and bad ways to deal with the problems that, say, meth addiction creates. The wrong way is to try to regulate what people can put into their own bodies, that road leads to addicts who can't seek help because of fear of jail, it leads to no-knock militarized police raids, it leads to a criminal justice system increasingly cut-off from the populace. It leads to corruption, to gang violence, and to tragedy of epic proportions. There are too many examples from history to pretend otherwise.

P.S. http://www.imdb.com/video/screenplay/vi3582329113/

Re:The quest for freedom and safety: Why I donated $100,000 ... by lukifer on Friday October 29, 2010 @08:05PM (#1849582)
> The idea that anyone has the right to regulate someone else's life based on morality is deeply puritanical

I'm saying nothing of morality, and speaking only of practicality. Absolute personal freedom is a beautiful ideal, in the same sense as world peace or the eradication of hunger; we should strive to achieve those ideals using every tool at our disposal.

But people (and societies) are extremely complicated, and in practice, one person's freedom can mean that another's is taken away. My freedom to play loud music at 3am removes your freedom to sleep soundly through the night. The premise of a social contract exists to seek a balance that maximizes freedom for everyone. Just because it doesn't always work isn't a reason to abandon the idea outright.

On the issue of drugs specifically, I think it's simply naive to pretend that easy and legal access to hard drugs won't have profound unintended negative effects on those besides the users themselves. I think we need custom-tailored policies for each drug that seek to strike a balance between personal freedom and the good of society (which is code for "the freedom of everybody else to not be fucked with by drug addicts").

Re:The quest for freedom and safety: Why I donated $100,000 ... by rick888 on Saturday October 30, 2010 @01:56AM (#1850226)
"Smoking cigarettes?"

If it means you will be blowing smoke around and potentially having a negative effect on me or my family, lots.

"Being HIV positive"

If you don't tell your partners and spread it around, it could have devastating effects on many peoples' lives.

"The wrong way is to try to regulate what people can put into their own bodies, that road leads to addicts who can't seek help because of fear of jail, it leads to no-knock militarized police raids, it leads to a criminal justice system increasingly cut-off from the populace."

I seriously doubt addicts have to worry about jail. Have you ever seen the show "Intervention"? If the laws were as bad as you say in the US, the police would be waiting outside the homes of those people. Many of them are illegal drug addicts (and the show explains exactly which drugs they are taking).

The pro-marijuana movement is less about freedom and is more about trying to legitimize a mind-altering substance.

"It leads to corruption, to gang violence, and to tragedy of epic proportions."

Correlation != Causation. This seems to come up in every article except when it comes to drug related stats. It doesn't lead to corruption and gang violence. Those people would be just as corrupt and in gangs without drugs.

Also, it's your freedom and choice to put substances into your body..with or without laws. The tragedy is only brought on by the user and is most likely a symptom (the reason they got into drugs in the first place) of other problems. Most of the drug users I know had messed up childhoods/family life.

I also don't think we should make it any easier for an addict..because we will just end up with more people who won't really care about becoming addicted because there will be no consequences (IE: the government pays for your rehabilitation).

Re:The quest for freedom and safety: Why I donated $100,000 ... by InclinedPlane on Saturday October 30, 2010 @05:26AM (#1850512)
Could you explain to me in what ways your argument differs from that of prohibition of alcohol? If you can't, do you support a return to the prohibition of alcohol?

P.S. My comment about corruption was not meant to address the "corruption" of individuals who join gangs, rather it was meant to describe the corruption of the criminal justice system, society, and the political process that prohibitions causes.

Re:The quest for freedom and safety: Why I donated $100,000 ... by rick888 on Saturday October 30, 2010 @10:17AM (#1850890)
"P.S. My comment about corruption was not meant to address the "corruption" of individuals who join gangs, rather it was meant to describe the corruption of the criminal justice system, society, and the political process that prohibitions causes."

Ahh, because if drugs were allowed, we would see virtually no gang activity in the US. We should check out Portugal and Amsterdam to see if all of the gangs just decided to disban because drugs are legalized.

Re:The quest for freedom and safety: Why I donated $100,000 ... by chc on Saturday October 30, 2010 @02:29AM (#1850275)
>If the laws were as bad as you say in the US, the police would be waiting outside the homes of those people.

Nope. There are many other possibilities. The law could be that bad, but enforcement could be inconsistent. The law could be that bad, but certain classes might be relatively immune. And so on.

And correlation is different from causation, but in this case, it's deductively provable that prohibition acts as fuel for these things. It's not merely correlated in some indirect way.

Re:The quest for freedom and safety: Why I donated $100,000 ... by rick888 on Saturday October 30, 2010 @10:15AM (#1850885)
"Nope. There are many other possibilities. The law could be that bad, but enforcement could be inconsistent. The law could be that bad, but certain classes might be relatively immune. And so on."

Nope. Intervention is on national television. A cop somewhere has to be seeing it. If it was as bad as you say, those people would be arrested asap. and certain classes might be immune? Please. the people on the show are from different classes.

"it's deductively provable that prohibition acts as fuel for these things."

So you are making the argument that the prohibition of drugs causes someone to form a gang? Why do people decide to do drugs in the first place?

Pot for example gets you high. It allows you to forget, for a short time, any of the bad things happening in your life and gives you a temporary happiness. Anyone that needs to do this has problems. It's those same bad problems at home that make gangs so enticing. Gangs provide family, a support network, and power.

Re:The quest for freedom and safety: Why I donated $100,000 ... by sliverstorm on Friday October 29, 2010 @07:37PM (#1849510)
Nobody is trying to protect people from themselves- they are trying to protect themselves, those close to them, and those unable to protect themselves. You may try to argue drugs are a purely personal experience, but anyone who had an alcoholic for a parent will tell you otherwise.
Re:The quest for freedom and safety: Why I donated $100,000 ... by cubix on Saturday October 30, 2010 @12:26AM (#1850093)
Nobody is trying to protect people from themselves- they are trying to protect themselves, those close to them, and those unable to protect themselves.

It's not too often you see such a blatant contradiction in the same sentence.

Re:The quest for freedom and safety: Why I donated $100,000 ... by InclinedPlane on Friday October 29, 2010 @10:02PM (#1849837)
This is why we have laws against murder, theft, rape, etc.
Re:The quest for freedom and safety: Why I donated $100,000 ... by itistoday on Friday October 29, 2010 @08:29PM (#1849646)
And note how little prohibition did to stop the existence of alcoholic parents. They were still around, but you had to deal with Spatz Columbo running around too, shooting up the place.

If you want to fix the alcoholic parent problem, create a society that reacts to them in a compassionate manner instead of throwing people in prison.

Re:The quest for freedom and safety: Why I donated $100,000 ... by rick888 on Saturday October 30, 2010 @12:28AM (#1850098)
"If you want to fix the alcoholic parent problem, create a society that reacts to them in a compassionate manner instead of throwing people in prison."

Why, so we can continue to enable them? If you coddle someone and are compassionate, people will never stop.

Re:The quest for freedom and safety: Why I donated $100,000 ... by InclinedPlane on Saturday October 30, 2010 @05:23AM (#1850506)
Perhaps, dear sir, you could recognize that there is an entire spectrum of possibility that falls outside of the choices "coddle them" and "stomp on their necks with boots until they stop".
Re:The quest for freedom and safety: Why I donated $100,000 ... by rick888 on Saturday October 30, 2010 @10:24AM (#1850903)
"Perhaps, dear sir, you could recognize that there is an entire spectrum of possibility that falls outside of the choices "coddle them" and "stomp on their necks with boots until they stop"."

The only way people ever stop is when they hit "rock bottom" and realize the terrible choices they are making. This usually means going to jail for at least a little while.

Re:The quest for freedom and safety: Why I donated $100,000 ... by sukuriant on Saturday October 30, 2010 @02:12AM (#1850252)
Yes, but you can still start by being compassionate. Being kind and loving isn't necessarily enabling. It may very well become it, but it isn't always enabling. Tough love is not generally the first step, and every single case is different and must be treated as such. Please remember this.
Re:The quest for freedom and safety: Why I donated $100,000 ... by rick888 on Saturday October 30, 2010 @10:30AM (#1850916)
"Tough love is not generally the first step, and every single case is different and must be treated as such. Please remember this."

If you look at any documentary about addicts (or hear real doctors talking about it), it's the step families are FORCED to take because every other method just results in the addict thinking they can continue.

"Being kind and loving isn't necessarily enabling."

If I tried to be kind to my addict friends and tell them in a sweet voice that what they are doing is hurting themselves, they would tell me to fuck off. People aren't stupid. They know that being addicted to Meth, Coke, or Heroin is shitty and unhealthy.

Tough love is the kindest and most loving thing you can do for an addict. It just might save their life. If they know that the result of being an addict will mean that you might not talk to them again, they will think twice about shooting up.

Re:The quest for freedom and safety: Why I donated $100,000 ... by sukuriant on Saturday October 30, 2010 @04:03PM (#1851677)
These are details I did not know. I suspected it would come to that point in most cases, but perhaps not all. It was because of those "not all" cases that I wanted to give some people the benefit of the doubt, at least for the first. If it's an "all", or at least very close to it, as you're suggesting, then I understand the need and revoke those parts of my statement.