News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by geuis on Friday October 29, 2010 @04:46PM (#1848954)
So I'm just wondering, what if you're a parent flying with children? I don't have kids, so I don't know what the rules are for TSA screening of them.

To me, it sounds like as a parent you either have the choice of letting some anonymous person in another room take naked pictures of your kids, or you have to let some strange man/woman touch and grope your children until they meet 'resistance'.

In the meantime, metal detectors are in place but it seems like there's some move to phase these out. And when I have kids, if some government minimum wage flunky thinks they're going to grope my daughter or son, my wife will be posting bail for me soon thereafter.

Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by tptacek on Friday October 29, 2010 @04:50PM (#1848972)
I'm flying with my kids in a few months; my plan is to simply record the whole thing with my iPhone (you may see me in the news shortly thereafter).

If my son gets upset, I plan to tell him "this is why you're going to take trig seriously; do bad in school and you might end up with this crappy job".

The pat-down is better than the machine. Even for kids. Maybe especially for kids. If you're going to violate my kids privacy, you'd better believe I'm going to want to be in the actual room.

Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by varjag on Friday October 29, 2010 @05:30PM (#1849115)
I don't know about the United States, but pretty much everywhere taking videos of airport security check is prohibited.
Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by tptacek on Friday October 29, 2010 @05:33PM (#1849128)
You can in the US.

We don’t prohibit public, passengers or press from photographing, videotaping, or filming at screening locations. You can take pictures at our checkpoints as long as you’re not interfering with the screening process or slowing things down. We also ask that you do not film or take pictures of our monitors.

Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by pyre on Friday October 29, 2010 @08:21PM (#1849628)
I was videoing a checkpoint during a lock-down and was told by the port authority/airport police that I wasn't allowed to point my camera at the 'secured area.' This was at Newark just this last January (when they locked it down because someone ran through the 'secured area' exit).

Missing context:

However… while the TSA does not prohibit photographs at screening locations, local laws, state statutes, or local ordinances might. Your best bet is to call ahead and see what that specific airport’s policy is.

Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by meelash on Friday October 29, 2010 @05:58PM (#1849207)
hmm... There were signs at JFK and also at SFO that prohibited cameras last time I traveled internationally (about a year ago). Where is this quote from?
Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by tommi on Friday October 29, 2010 @06:45PM (#1849368)
Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by ComputerGuru on Friday October 29, 2010 @06:50PM (#1849380)
I saw that quote at New Wark and Cincinnati.
Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by erikpukinskis on Friday October 29, 2010 @05:57PM (#1849203)
I wish I could upvote the idea about videotaping the proces and downvote you belittling those less fortunate than yourself.
Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by mfukar on Saturday October 30, 2010 @05:24AM (#1850510)
A job is a job is a job.
Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by zackattack on Friday October 29, 2010 @09:34PM (#1849787)
Many TSA workers are on a power trip. Get off your high horse.
Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by sp332 on Saturday October 30, 2010 @10:07AM (#1850869)
Maybe it's a coping mechanism. I mean how else could you do that job? If you and 50 people you work with are assigned to pat down strangers in an airport terminal, would you say no? Or would you find a way to deal, and just do it?
Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by joezydeco on Friday October 29, 2010 @10:23PM (#1849880)
Don't they usually want your phone on the conveyor belt going through the X-ray machine? How do you videotape the circus at that point?
Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by dmethvin on Friday October 29, 2010 @05:05PM (#1849027)
> If my son gets upset, I plan to tell him "this is why you're going to take trig seriously; do bad in school and you might end up with this crappy job".

That is a horribly disrespectful thing to say in front of someone who is doing their job. Would you say something like that to a proctologist as they stuck a finger up your butt? I doubt the TSA people like this either, perhaps some will even resign over it. But that person has a job and they are doing it as they are instructed to do. That is the job they use to pay their rent and bills, so that they won't need to go on the dole and have their bills paid by your trig-savvy son.

Bitch about the policy all you want, and do what you think needs to be done to change it. But don't belittle the TSA worker, they can't change anything.

Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by tptacek on Friday October 29, 2010 @05:07PM (#1849035)
If you have the job that forces you to feel up the crotches of children in order to encourage their parents to send them through a machine that takes naked pictures of them without probable cause of having committed any crime, then I suggest you quit that job.

Are plenty of hardworking people going to have their feelings and self esteem hurt by this process? Good. Systemetized violations of our most private areas should cause all sorts of pain.

I might feel differently if these were sworn law enforcement officers we're talking about, for a number of reasons. I'm generally very respectful of law enforcement. Fortunately (or not), I'm not forced to confront that conundrum, since these aren't police officers, but low-skilled "security" contractors whose sole purpose is to harass citizens in order to create the illusion of control.

By the way, in the history of all-time worst rationalizations for behavior, do we even need to talk about "that person has a job and they are doing it as they are instructed to do"?

Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by RyanMcGreal on Friday October 29, 2010 @08:09PM (#1849593)
>If you have the job that forces you to feel up the crotches of children in order to encourage their parents to send them through a machine that takes naked pictures of them without probable cause of having committed any crime, then I suggest you quit that job.

Thank you for making my day. That is all.

Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by pbhjpbhj on Saturday October 30, 2010 @11:20PM (#1852393)
>If you have the job [...] then I suggest you quit that job.

Very easy to say.

I also like how you attacked with full prejudice anyone who might attempt to contradict you.

You're attacking the wrong people. Did these TSA people in the terminal get up one day and decide that they wanted to do pat-downs on everyone? I'm pretty sure it's been very hard for some of them to stay in their post with the new conditions but they're there because they do have families to feed and rent to pay, etc.. They're people too.

So, yes we do have to talk about the reason that you think you can dismiss people for not simply quitting their jobs because of enforced change that is not their fault and not their choice. We do have to talk about why you feel they should be potentially impoverished.

Why don't you leave your job in protest? That would be as effective as a TSA officer leaving theirs I'm sure.

Yes if all people in your country refused to do security pat-downs then this wouldn't happen. Also no flights would leave the ground (for at least a time).

IMO if you feel so strongly that you're demanding other people leave their jobs then you need to be doing 2 things. You need to be directly supporting those people leaving their jobs financially, and you need to be lobbying hard for a change in the rules/law.

If you're doing both those things then more power to you, TSA people will be happy you're paying their wages whilst they find work.

So, there you have it, in your opinion the "[worst] in the history of all-time worst rationalizations for behavior".

Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by CWuestefeld on Friday October 29, 2010 @09:18PM (#1849743)
I wish I had the ability to up-vote more than once. This deserves to be printed and framed.
Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by dgordon on Saturday October 30, 2010 @11:36PM (#1852421)
I'd just like to point out the difference between this and some comments below that basically say "LOL NAZIS JUST DID THEIR JOB" -- 134 points and counting vs. -4 and probably even lower in fact.

This is how you make this sort of argument. And I'm not just saying that because I agree with it. (That's what my upvote was for.)

Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by cjbprime on Saturday October 30, 2010 @01:41AM (#1850205)
Awesome.
Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by dinkumthinkum on Saturday October 30, 2010 @03:41PM (#1851621)
Well, presumably proctologists are making a decent living, right? Certainly more than TSA reps, or am I mistaken?
Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by jawngee on Friday October 29, 2010 @05:47PM (#1849167)
Yeah the same goes for those poor sap guards at Auschwitz.

I mean, really, they we're just doing their jobs to pay their bills, etc. etc.

TSA is not a far step from that, btw.

Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by tptacek on Friday October 29, 2010 @05:51PM (#1849180)
I accidentally upvoted you. TSA is quite a far step from that. Don't suck all the oxygen out of the conversation.
Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by StavrosK on Friday October 29, 2010 @06:33PM (#1849328)
In quantity only, not quality. If someone orders you to do something you consider immoral and you still do it, you're just as much to blame.

See the Milgram experiment and the Nuremberg trials. The "just doing their job" excuse isn't good enough for passengers or for employees, they should do the right thing and quit/disobey.

Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by sliverstorm on Friday October 29, 2010 @07:54PM (#1849550)
You sure about that? I always got the impression the real problem in the camps, besides the fact they existed etc, was guards enjoying their immoral job and taking liberties. And that is indeed a whole step above.
Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by StavrosK on Friday October 29, 2010 @08:20PM (#1849625)
There's no simple reason. Who's to say that the enjoyment wasn't a coping mechanism? Who's to say they didn't think it was necessary to protect their country? I don't think they woke up one day and thought "today I'm going to torture and murder me some Jews", there was a very gradual manipulation process that led them there.

Have you seen the video of US marines airbombing journalists (or civilians? I don't remember). They seem to enjoy it a whole lot... We, of course, know this is nothing like that, but are we sure? In both cases people were doing what they thought was necessary for the good of their country (of course, it's much easier to see how killing people is justified when you think they're about to shoot anti-aircraft missiles at you). It's very easy to demonise people in retrospect, and say "we would never do these things today", but the guards in concentration camps probably said the same thing for other atrocities of the past, while actually doing the same thing themselves.

This is just a lot of speculation on my part, but I find it hard to believe that an entire country just happened to consist of monsters who would enjoy killing people or endorsing that genocide. I'm just saying that these are probably the same principles at play, but we have the benefit of hindsight and should take steps to nip this erosion in the bud.

Of course, that's very hard to do, so we'll probably just shut up and take this too.

Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by pyre on Friday October 29, 2010 @08:29PM (#1849647)

  > I find it hard to believe that an entire country just happened to
  > consist of monsters who would enjoy killing people or endorsing
  > that genocide.
A couple of points:

1. The guards at the concentration camps were not 100% of population of Germany.

2. Did the general populus of Germany really know everything that was happening at the concentration camps? Did they know that Jews were being killed at stuck in mass graves or were they (the public) just told that they (the Jews) were being 'sent to camps' to 'keep them separated from the general population?'

Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by StavrosK on Friday October 29, 2010 @08:41PM (#1849670)
Well, by that logic, TSA employees are not 100% of the population of the US either. I can't say how much they knew, but that makes it even worse, because the citizens of Germany were unwitting accomplices, whereas everyone knows what's going on in airports and still consents to it.*

* I'm not equating pat-downs to genocide.

Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by sp332 on Saturday October 30, 2010 @10:15AM (#1850884)
People who win the lottery are generally not any happier six months later. Individuals seem to have a kind of equilibrium of happiness. I think it's reasonable that the guards would acclimate to a really crappy situation as well.
Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by adnam on Friday October 29, 2010 @06:07PM (#1849244)
Yeah but it's true
Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by tomjen3 on Friday October 29, 2010 @07:27PM (#1849485)
That is a horribly disrespectful thing to say in front of someone who is doing their job.

Good, maybe if we are lucky he will kill himself over it.

If that happens I will urge everybody to go piss on his grave, because he is not a human, but a criminal mindless drone.

JUST DOING YOUR JOB WAS WHAT THE NAZIS WHERE HUNG FOR - IT IS NO EXCUSE.

Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by philwelch on Friday October 29, 2010 @05:45PM (#1849161)
Oh, God. There's a brilliant plan somewhere in here; the trick is to make the pedophilia witch hunt and the terrorist witch hunt collide.
Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by marclove on Friday October 29, 2010 @08:15PM (#1849612)
How long before child molesters realize what a "great gig" it is?
Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by tertius on Friday October 29, 2010 @07:16PM (#1849449)
Once some of the stored files leaks onto the internet... Then this whole thing would just be over.
Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by wedfvgberfgbh on Friday October 29, 2010 @07:25PM (#1849473)
It's 'funnier' in the UK - they ruled the scanners aren't a problem for kids, scanning them isn't obscene.

But images taken by the machines may be obscene - so possession of the pictures gets you prison + lifetime on the sex-offenders register.

This came up after they were going to use them in schools.

Re:For the First Time, the TSA Meets Resistance by Silhouette on Friday October 29, 2010 @10:02PM (#1849838)
I think the whole paedophilia thing is a weak argument against the virtual strip search machines. While I totally agree that subjecting children to that kind of abuse is completely inappropriate, I don't see how it somehow becomes any less completely inappropriate if you abuse someone the same way just because they have passed their 18th birthday.

As far as I'm concerned, everyone responsible for setting the policy to use these machines or actually using them should be one trial away from the sex offender's register, just like anyone else who takes "naughty photos" of someone without their consent. They can have their hearing right after we're done with the agents described in the article who take such apparent delight in groping people inappropriately.