News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Media Industry and the “Make-Google-Pay” Fantasy by vorpalhex on Monday November 19, 2018 @12:12PM (#18487851)
I'm sure you'll be able to fill out a form and get an email a day later, "We're sorry, we've reviewed your case but have decided against you (because we have no reason to ever take any risk)"

The DMCA is a shining example of just how well these appeals processes work...

Re:The Media Industry and the “Make-Google-Pay” Fantasy by AnssiH on Monday November 19, 2018 @01:13PM (#18488367)
I don't think that would satisfy the requirements of the directive:

> Any complaint filed under such mechanisms shall be processed without undue delay and be subject to human review. Right holders shall reasonably justify their decisions to avoid arbitrary dismissal of complaints.

It also requires Member States to ensure "that users have access to an independent body for the resolution of disputes as well as to a court or another relevant judicial authority to assert the use of an exception or limitation to copyright rules".

(source PDF http://www.europarl.europa.eu/sides/getDoc.do?pubRef=-//EP//... )

Re:The Media Industry and the “Make-Google-Pay” Fantasy by zaroth on Monday November 19, 2018 @02:11PM (#18488845)
So damned if you do and damned if you don’t? How does this right here not destroy the prospect of any small company trying to scale operations in this space?

From the company’s perspective, it’s like a DDoS attack that is illegal to defend yourself against.

Re:The Media Industry and the “Make-Google-Pay” Fantasy by IanCal on Monday November 19, 2018 @05:58PM (#18490502)
Small companies have lower requirements for what they need to do under the directive.

About the measures taken, for example:

> The measures should be proportionate in order to avoid imposing disproportionately complicated or costly obligations on certain online content sharing service providers, taking into account notably their small size.

For small/micro enterprises this then means that for the DDoS attack you'd need the rightsholders to invalidly notify of large amounts of content that needs removing (each one specifically) which must be done with the intent of killing off the platform. Would that be legal? To submit false claims deliberately to hurt the company?

Re:The Media Industry and the “Make-Google-Pay” Fantasy by zaroth on Monday November 19, 2018 @07:15PM (#18490881)
You are aware this is exactly what happens under DMCA?
Re:The Media Industry and the “Make-Google-Pay” Fantasy by krageon on Tuesday November 20, 2018 @10:28AM (#18494468)
Yes, and that is ok in the US. We're talking about Europe, where the legislators at least pretend to care about the people they're making laws for.
Re:The Media Industry and the “Make-Google-Pay” Fantasy by gray_-_wolf on Wednesday November 21, 2018 @10:29AM (#18503359)
> Right holders shall reasonably justify their decisions to avoid arbitrary dismissal of complaints.

Isn't "not wanting to take the legal risk" reasonable justification?

Re:The Media Industry and the “Make-Google-Pay” Fantasy by IanCal on Monday November 19, 2018 @01:11PM (#18488346)
> The measures taken by the online content sharing service providers should be without prejudice to the application of exceptions and limitations to copyright, including in particular those which guarantee the freedom of expression of users. For that purpose the service providers should put in place mechanisms allowing users to complain about the blocking or removal of uploaded content that could benefit from an exception or limitation to copyright. Replies to the users’ complaints should be provided in a timely manner. To make these mechanisms function, cooperation from rightholders is needed, in particular with regard to the assessment of the complaints submitted and justifications for the removal of users’ content.

Emphasis mine.

The section also says member states are free to put in place independent authorities to assess these, although I'm sure somewhere else it in this is a requirement rather than simply a suggestion. I'll update if I can find it.

https://www.consilium.europa.eu/media/35373/st09134-en18.pdf