News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I’m Giving $1.8B for College Financial Aid by closeparen on Monday November 19, 2018 @03:41AM (#18484940)
Scum or not, the difference in outcomes is real [0]. Cultural memes about the importance of college are one part of how middle-class-ness is made to stick. The other part is money. For better or worse, the social contract is that education is paid forward across generations, from the middle class to their own children and from the rich to everyone. Crushing student debt load is the scar tissue that forms when when that social contract is violated, and a child receives the value system without the 529 account.

No one should want their child to be buried in a six-figure debt. But the answer, at least on the median HN reader's salary, is to save and invest 4-5 figures over each of your child's 18 years. That is what universities will expect when deciding what to charge you, and what the government endorsed when creating tax-advantaged accounts for that purpose.

I guess you could say "Not fair!" but the families that do this outperform the ones that don't, by wider and wider margins, and that right there is "rising inequality."

Just a few years out, my parents' investment has paid off handsomely. They don't want it back. They want it paid forward to my own kids. Morality notwithstanding, this particular belief system seems to be a winning a strategy.

[0] https://www.statista.com/statistics/233301/median-household-...

Re:Why I’m Giving $1.8B for College Financial Aid by CalRobert on Monday November 19, 2018 @05:11AM (#18485301)
You're completely right. But those memes aren't only targeted to middle class kids.

I'm doing fine, and am not really worried about my kid affording college.

But too many of my friends are _not_ doing fine, and I have a strong suspicion college was not a good ROI for them. The combination of :

* "You MUST do this to be a successful adult"

* "Oh btw it costs several years' worth of your future income"

* "But guess what! Here's a big pile of debt that you can never discharge no matter what" (aside from death and some very, very extreme tax circumstances)

* "And because we're responsible adults who care about the next generation we made sure you attended horrible schools through your youth and have no cultural appreciation for mathematics giving you none of the tools you'd need to accurately determine if this is a good decision"

Re:Why I’m Giving $1.8B for College Financial Aid by chiefalchemist on Monday November 19, 2018 @07:34AM (#18485927)
Past performance is not indicative of future success. Add in AI / automation and __many__ middle office jobs are going to be replaced.

Finally, as covered in Duckworth's book "Grit" brains / education isn't the key.