Re:Here are the 'cyber 9/11' scenarios that really worry the...
by panarky on Sunday November 18, 2018 @11:47PM
(#18484283)
"Pentagon Suggests Countering Devastating Cyberattacks With Nuclear Arms"
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/16/us/politics/pentagon-nucl...
Re:Here are the 'cyber 9/11' scenarios that really worry the...
by nradov on Monday November 19, 2018 @12:44AM
(#18484437)
The US already has a policy to use kinetic means to retaliate against state sponsored terrorism. Whether that terrorism is carried out through "cyber" or other means is irrelevant. And the US did trigger Article 5 after the 9/11 attacks.
Re:Here are the 'cyber 9/11' scenarios that really worry the...
by topkai22 on Monday November 19, 2018 @08:14PM
(#18491138)
Ok, the dam scenario is excessive (and kinetic already), but where that threshold crossed? If a string of on going attacks caused 10s of billions of damage but with no fatalities, would it crossed? What about incidental fatalities such as preventable deaths in a blackout?
Messaging and intentions aren’t clear in this domain yet, that’s the worry about unintentional escalation.
For example, if Turkey and Russia got into a spat over access to the Black Sea and Russia triggered blackouts in Turkey that (perhaps unintentionally) killed people. Would that trigger Article 5? (NATO Mutual Defense Treaty?)
What if a state sponsored (but not state controlled) group managed to do a massive uncontrolled release of dam water, drowning hundreds. Would the US be justified in a kinetic retaliation against the sponsoring state?
This is one reason why people are calling for a cyber version of the Geneva convention- we need norms to help make the signaling and consequences inherent in these actions clear to all parties.