For example, if Turkey and Russia got into a spat over access to the Black Sea and Russia triggered blackouts in Turkey that (perhaps unintentionally) killed people. Would that trigger Article 5? (NATO Mutual Defense Treaty?)
What if a state sponsored (but not state controlled) group managed to do a massive uncontrolled release of dam water, drowning hundreds. Would the US be justified in a kinetic retaliation against the sponsoring state?
This is one reason why people are calling for a cyber version of the Geneva convention- we need norms to help make the signaling and consequences inherent in these actions clear to all parties.
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/16/us/politics/pentagon-nucl...
Messaging and intentions aren’t clear in this domain yet, that’s the worry about unintentional escalation.
If N Korea caused something like the 2008 crash,is it worth a regional nuclear war by invading them? You're also assuming it's just one country that will attack and they haven't already prepared an invasion against mainland US
Probably because the “evidence” Russia hacked the DNC is dubious at best.
Here are two links to the joint reports from the three letter agencies involved:
https://www.dni.gov/files/documents/ICA_2017_01.pdf
https://www.us-cert.gov/sites/default/files/publications/JAR...
If you're an aggressor, you don't need to break infrastructure or blow things up. For the cost of a few troll farms, a few training classes in infowar, and maybe a mainstream news outlet or two, you can split any country along its political fault lines and encourage division, sectarianism, social unrest, "spontaneous" terrorism, and perhaps eventually civil war.
A country like the US, which has extremely deep social fault lines, is almost ridiculously vulnerable to this kind of attack.
And with the right financial and/or political incentives, there will always be potential fifth column interests who would support such an effort, as long as they gain personally.
The US has sponsored efforts like these in other countries in the past. There doesn't seem to be much understanding that it's also vulnerable to them - far more than it used to be, thanks to the amplifying effects of social media.
So cheap in fact that I'm not surprised if we witness exactly that very, very nearby.
Sounds like a great excuse to take out all the "usual suspects" at once.
Practically (and without usage of nuclear weopons), the USA can barely handle attrition. Also the USA have not fought a conventional war with another competent regional power since World War 2 and that too was with many allies.
How will you divide them equally and pit them against each other?
1) The offending country is willing to escalate/desires to provoke skirmishes that may lead to major battles with or without conventional military.
2) The offending country is so desperate, the only way to reboot their economy is to start a losing battle so it can be rebuilt.
3) the economy of the offending country is so skewed at the top of the leadership, they are willing to thin the herd using foreign intervention, and build up a zealous supporter base who is out for blood for vengeance.
TLDR: The adversarial state will launch a 'cyber nuclear' attack when it thinks is fully ready to take the brunt of 12 American carrier groups armed with manned and unmanned stealth fighters.