I’m not saying we shouldn’t criticize Facebook, or that they shouldn’t be the ones to solve this problem. But I think it’s important to frame it as a problem to be solved instead of growing extremely cynical and saying Facebook is pure evil.
When Facebook says they don't know something there are a few possibilities, the least likely is that they don't know and don't have a reason not to find out.
I do agree with you that it is not up to them to fix. They should be limited to whatever extent possible in what research they can do on their own discretion to prevent them from staying ahead of public information and misleading research.
since we've already conceded that votes can be simply bought through advertising, the whole thing was already looking pretty sketchy.
its kind of pointless to rail at the parasites feeding off the open wounds.
The evidence out there suggests that social networks are being used to great effect to mobilize revolutions, mobs, and other "populist" movements, for better or worse. These days, it seems like largely "worse".
The same way that "flash mobs" were a funny joke in the early 2000's, and then were used as methods to commit mass-anonymous crime. The social cost of being able to organize large groups of people (many of which may not realize they are being used) is going to be a theme for the next decade.
The lesson FB execs are learning is that FB must filter all of its content very carefully so that the electorate is nudged more forcefully toward the correct candidate. Either that, or, more likely, just keep doing whatever makes the most money.
In general you should always start with "more money" as your first assumption, not the backup. They don't want to be regulated, that's all.
https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2016/04/how-f...
but very few serious analysts thought Trump would actually win.
so, Trump's 2016 electoral victory was not just surprising. it was positively shocking, especially to people in the media. the most reliable predictors and conventional wisdom strongly favored Clinton. Trump's campaign was basically a bad joke. so, when he won, we needed to explain it, to understand it, and, yes, to blame someone for it.
journalists continued to focus on Facebook as an explanation right after the election:
https://www.wired.com/2016/11/facebook-won-trump-election-no...
imho, it's reasonable to think that calls for increased scrutiny of FB were amplified and multiplied because of Trump's victory to a far greater extent than would have happened had Clinton won. our explanatory framework expected her victory. if that framework failed, there must be some new factor that confused it.
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/15/technology/myanmar-facebo...
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/oct/18/brazil-jair-bo...
Also yes, Genocide is terrible. But the amount of people that cigarettes kill every year is orders of magnitudes more than this.
That’s the thing: tobacco execs are still around! Making a product that literally kills millions of people every year. The only reason more outrage isn’t targeted at them is I think we believe that with enough backlash, we can change the situation with Facebook whereas cigarettes seem unstoppable.
Many people are dead, the number comparisons don't really matter. They're both evil, that's really it.
The role of Tobacco companies is much more direct (well established link between cigarettes and death), and the scale is far greater.
Everything has bad consequences, each technology. Just saying that someone dies as a consequence of a company product isn’t enough to disqualify it. If you want to apply that logic we need to shutdown basically all worlds economies.
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/15/technology/myanmar-facebo...
I’m arguing your statement that one death is too many. That’s very naive metric, as you can apply it to any big company.
EDIT: a lot of people are taking my statement as meaning not to criticize Facebook. That is not it at all! It just means not to lose perspective. At least I still consider tobacco to be far worse, directly causing ~7M deaths annually with no visible benefit.
EDIT 2: Genuine question: has anyone studied the rise of fascism post-FB vs. pre-FB? It's not like dictatorships and far-right governments didn't get elected pre-FB. Obviously I am one of those who doubt FB's direct responsibility vs. it being simply a media narrative against a business threat.
[1] http://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/tobacco