News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by mrj on Friday October 29, 2010 @12:59PM (#1847953)
I don't get it. Their brand new phone doesn't support HTML5.
Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by mechanical_fish on Friday October 29, 2010 @01:09PM (#1847991)
Pivoting the Microsoft ecosystem is like trying to shove the Indian subcontinent a foot to the left.

On the plus side, continents may not move very quickly or in the precise direction that one might desire, but they do move.

Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by rbanffy on Friday October 29, 2010 @01:50PM (#1848190)
> Pivoting the Microsoft ecosystem is like trying to shove the Indian subcontinent a foot to the left.

It's not like pivoting an entire ecosystem. It's about launching a mobile browser that doesn't suck.

Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by treeface on Friday October 29, 2010 @02:52PM (#1848476)
The problem is that they're unwilling to jump on WebKit. I imagine this might have something to do with the historical prominence of the IE team at Microsoft.

Using WebKit (and possibly even the JS-processing code Google pushes back to the WebKit community), they could get it up and running in far less time than it would take to build it themselves. A small (or large, well-organized) company wouldn't have legacy issues like this (or at least wouldn't let them get in the way of making the right decision).

Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by rbanffy on Friday October 29, 2010 @09:56PM (#1849827)
The problem is that if they use Webkit, there will be a unified and cross-platform environment for deploying web applications. Microsoft cannot allow that - one of its strengths is how difficult it is to migrate to other platforms whatever was developed to be deployed to Windows.

The only reason Windows has a browser these days is that Microsoft succeeded in destroying Netscape, but, by the time they did it, it was too late to destroy the web. Had they arrived at the game when NCSA Mosaic was the dominant browser and succeeded in fragmenting the transport and presentation layers with competing protocols and formats, the web would be completely different today.

Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by bad_user on Friday October 29, 2010 @04:10PM (#1848821)
I wonder if shareholders are aware of this.
Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by rbanffy on Saturday October 30, 2010 @04:29AM (#1850452)
If they were, they wouldn't be shareholders
Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by shareme on Friday October 29, 2010 @05:32PM (#1849124)
you forget they once jumped to SpyGlass..ie the founding code of MSIE 1.0
Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by endtime on Friday October 29, 2010 @02:37PM (#1848407)
They don't even have a desktop browser that doesn't suck yet - it's in beta. I agree it'd be nice if WP7 had a better browser, but it's not a very realistic demand at this point.
Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by rbanffy on Saturday October 30, 2010 @04:16AM (#1850429)
Then why not just use a WebKit-based one like everyone else?
Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by kenjackson on Friday October 29, 2010 @04:25PM (#1848880)
Have you used the mobile browser? It's probably the best implementation of any mobile browser I've used, bar none. HTML5 would be a big plus -- the only problem is I can't think of any webpages that I go to that use HTML5 (although I'm sure there are plenty that exist).
Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by ihumanable on Friday October 29, 2010 @01:27PM (#1848089)
This doesn't make much sense, it's their phone software. All they have to do is leverage their own browser tech for IE9 for their phone. It may not be easy, but if you can't get all the legs walking in the same direction in your own company, why should people have faith in your ability to deliver a good user experience.
Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by bkhl on Friday October 29, 2010 @01:59PM (#1848247)
...Okay. IE9, which supports HTML5, is still in beta. WP7 has already been released, and I'm sure the folks in Redmond is working on the next release/updates. Do you get it now?

...Okay. It's not an easy job to align products and release cycles. Microsoft was already late on WP7. They probably missed a cycle and Android kicked in. Microsoft doesn't want to be late anymore. Meaning, they probably couldn't wait for IE9 for mobile to be released (which wouldn't be a HUGE job if you have a working, stable, and RC version of IE9).

In conclusion, Microsoft is being smart that they release the phone and let people dive/absorb/digest earlier instead of waiting for full featured phone OS with a HTML5 supported browser, which is still in beta for desktops. However, this just means..the next release of WP7 will be very interesting. Remember, Android and iPhone OS (which wasn't iOS at the time) weren't closed to feature complete with their first release. I'm an Android user, and I can remember when I first bought my Droid, it went through so many updates software updates. Companies just have to cut things if one or two things will block the entire release.

Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by SpikeGronim on Friday October 29, 2010 @01:44PM (#1848159)
"All they have to do" is take a hardware accelerated Vista/Windows 7 application (IE9) designed for mice and port it to much weaker hardware with a different OS and multi-touch. That's not easy.
Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by cpr on Friday October 29, 2010 @01:43PM (#1848156)
MS is a pretty ponderous beast. Remember Joel's pointer to the story about someone trying to fix the shutdown experience?

http://moishelettvin.blogspot.com/2006/11/windows-shutdown-c...

Sounds like it takes years to get the legs moving together, which means it's too late for IE9 on the phone for a while...

Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by judofyr on Friday October 29, 2010 @01:07PM (#1847979)
Their brand new phone is of course using the most stable browser they have, and their brand new browser supporting HTML5 is of course not the most stable browser they have.

In a perfect world they would have shipped the phone with WebKit, but we all know that Microsoft is not going to do that (I'd love to be proven wrong).

Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by cryptoz on Friday October 29, 2010 @01:04PM (#1847972)
Nor does any MS browser for Windows XP, which still has > 50% of the Windows market share. It's very doublespeak of them:

Yes we love HTML5, but we won't have any of it on our most popular OS or our new mobile phone

...wtf?

Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by contextfree on Friday October 29, 2010 @01:51PM (#1848197)
Here's what I suspect their strategic angle on this is:

I think when MSFT talks about HTML5, what they tend to mean by it is web applications with desktop-like rich UIs, fancy graphics (that, in particular, require hardware acceleration on powerful PCs to run smoothly), etc. They have decided it's in their interest to encourage the proliferation of such applications (expect to see a lot of tools to help this along - Microsoft have already released an Adobe Illustrator plug in to export to HTML <canvas> (http://visitmix.com/labs/ai2canvas/) and Blend 5 is strongly rumored to support SVG/<canvas> as a target platform) for two reasons:

1. They think it's a chance to differentiate their web properties, especially by moving them toward a rich-client model in which they already have experience. They tried to do that with Silverlight previously but didn't get enough acceptance from various quarters. They probably think it's an opportunity for their development tools business as well (in particular, <canvas> being a low level API leaves a lot of room for new frameworks on top of it).

2. If rich-UI, CPU/GPU-hungry HTML5 sites become common, people who haven't upgraded in a while will need newer browsers and PCs to view them correctly. Of course, Microsoft is hoping to encourage them to move to IE9 and therefore to Windows 7, but even if they go to another browser instead, if they're on older computers they'll still need to upgrade their PC for the sites to run well, regardless of what browser they're using, and by default that means moving to a W7/8/ ... machine. I think this is probably the most important consideration for them.

Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by contextfree on Friday October 29, 2010 @08:33PM (#1849657)
I'm actually curious what people think of my take on this. Does it make sense, am I crazy/deluded, or ... ?
[deleted]
Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by cryptoz on Friday October 29, 2010 @01:18PM (#1848041)
> Just because XP is their most popular OS doesn't mean that they need to keep supporting it.

Ballmer said "we're embracing HTML5". If they want to embrace this technology then yes, they do need to bring it to their older, more popular OSs. Otherwise, they're just putting in a halfassed, minimal effort to it.

All other HTML5 browsers run on Windows XP. Microsoft is the only company to produce an HTML5 browser that doesn't run on the world's most widely used OS, which happens to be made by them.

That's absurd. Definitely not "embracing".

Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by confuzatron on Friday October 29, 2010 @01:42PM (#1848148)
So there are multiple browsers that support HTML5 on XP.

What's the problem again?

Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by cryptoz on Friday October 29, 2010 @01:55PM (#1848222)
Since none of them are made by Microsoft, very few corporations will use them. This means that many web developers will still be developing for IE8 in the year 2020.
Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by confuzatron on Friday October 29, 2010 @02:10PM (#1848287)
You have a point, but at the same time MS have no obligation to pander to these hyper-conservative corporations in a way that makes no business sense for them. Perhaps they should promote usage of Chrome on XP ;-)

(http://techie-buzz.com/tech-news/using-chrome-for-hotmail.ht...)

Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by trezor on Friday October 29, 2010 @01:17PM (#1848036)
Again? XP is old. Seriously. Just get over it.
Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by cryptoz on Friday October 29, 2010 @01:23PM (#1848060)
If XP is old, then Microsoft should stop supporting it. They should stop selling downgrade licenses.

But they don't. They still support it and they still sell it. In fact, they will keep selling it until 2020. That's 10 more years! Source: http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9179109/Microsoft_ext...

Now, can you seriously sit there and tell me it's reasonable for MS to sell an OS for ten more years (totaling about 20 years!) without releasing a single HTML5 capable browser for it?

And then comment that they're "embracing" HTML5? Ridiculous.

Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by contentvoid on Friday October 29, 2010 @02:17PM (#1848323)
It will, they just focused on UI and development ecosystem first and I'm sure the updated mobile IE will be a derivative of IE9 which isn't complete yet.
Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by confuzatron on Friday October 29, 2010 @01:39PM (#1848138)
But isn't HTML5 a whole bunch of not-standardised-yet technologies? If so, I am not amazed that their brand new platform doesn't support it.
Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by rimantas on Saturday October 30, 2010 @11:30AM (#1851026)
iPhone did support it more than three years ago.
Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by confuzatron on Saturday October 30, 2010 @12:30PM (#1851177)
So mobile Safari 3.0 (looks like the best candidate for 'three years ago') supported all of HTML5? Really? Googling shows that safari 3.0 for Windows certainly didn't support HTML5. Did mobile safari 3 support '2010 HTML5', given that it's still in draft at the moment. Has 'HTML5' remained the same for 3 years?
Re:Microsoft picks HTML5 over Silverlight for Internet apps by rimantas on Saturday October 30, 2010 @03:54PM (#1851654)
What has safari for windows to do with Mobile Safari? If fact there were features that first were released on Mobile Safari, and only later came to Safari on OS X (hardware accelerated CSS transforms and animations). As for "all of HTML5" — no current browser AFAIK has support for full HTML 4.