> But what chance does this sort of ambitious effort have when more and more states don't even want to deal with the ordinary problem of reducing CO2 output?
There are cheaper geo-engineering methods that don't attempt to directly reverse the problem, just (locally) mitigate some of the consequences, that could be done unilaterally by a state. E.g. stratospheric aerosol injection (less glamorous but a much cheaper than parking sunlight-filtering-satellites between the earth and the sun).
> Unlike the control of greenhouse gas emissions, which must be undertaken by all major emitting nations to be effective and is likely to be costly, geoengineering could be undertaken quickly and unilaterally by a single party, at relatively low cost. Unilateral geoengineering, however, is highly likely to impose costs on other countries and run risks with the entire planet’s climate system.
i agree that e.g. aerosol injection proposals seem rather stupid, won't actually fix the problem, but may just mitigate some of the many consequences of the problem, and also cause entirely new problems.
on the other hand, i suspect it is much more likely that geoengineering proposals will actually happen in preference to hypothetical negative emission technology, as geoengineering doesn't need a group of countries to agree on doing it, and (some of them) are relatively cheap and easy to do using existing technology.
We may, however, get there via improved economics and technology happening in renewable energy right now. With an unreasonable amount of luck, we might buy ourselves enough time to make peace with the human condition and find a replacement for global capitalism that does a better job of integrating the reality of our needs and the planet’s.
The vast majority of scientists do agree that global warming is real and that humans are causing it.
Yet the go-to argument for deniers is to claim that the science is not there.
Not being a scientist myself, I have to assume that you're talking out your ass, and the scientists are correct.
"Serves them well!" people snickered. "Risking one's career on unsettled science!"
Without trying to get into a flame war here, this claim is very iffy. As a scientist myself, there's (for better or worse) nothing better to make a career out of than showing where other scientists have made a mistake.
You don’t like the assumptions the model made? Fine, make an argument as to why they’re the wrong assumptions or the model is flawed. The model with the best predictive power wins the day.
Basically everything we have says that: * Humans are causing basically all of the warming happening, either directly or indirectly * All of that warming will eventually be enough to kill most or all of us within 40-100 years, especially if nothing is done, but even still eventually if we stick to current commitments.
There's literally no reason to faff about anymore - we have direct, quantifiable evidence that people are being killed and displaced by climate change related events today, and it will only get worse as time goes on. Hurricanes are stronger, wild fires are wilder, sea levels are rising and driving people off of low lying islands, glaciers are melting, the northwest passage has stayed opened for literally the first time in living memory, coral reefs are overheating to death, species are migrating north or just straight up going extinct. This is a problem now and immediately that the human race needs to address in force.
Exaggeration is counter-productive and dishonest, not a virtue.
http://www.ipcc.ch/publications_and_data/publications_ipcc_f...
But what chance does this sort of ambitious effort have when more and more states don't even want to deal with the ordinary problem of reducing CO2 output?
It seems to me that anyone caring about climate change needs to have a generally pro-science position politically.