Re:Minecraft server built in Node.js
by chapel on Friday October 29, 2010 @09:31AM
(#1847227)
Ah, thanks. I didn't notice at first. Though the fork has more recent commits where as the main hasn't had any for a while now. Still pretty cool and hope it goes somewhere.
Re:Minecraft server built in Node.js
by andrewgodwin on Friday October 29, 2010 @03:53PM
(#1848754)
Even more impressively, this appears to be for the new protocol version - the new protocol is significantly harder to implement a server for than the old one (I say this having written custom servers for both in Python), and requires, among other things, a full lighting implementation in the server.
I'd be curious to see how this compares to the Java one for speed (and some other SMP servers that are springing up) - it's quite difficult to store an infinite size map efficiently in memory and still keep good random access times.
Re:Minecraft server built in Node.js
by metachris on Friday October 29, 2010 @12:07PM
(#1847759)
UDP is not always the best protocol for networked games. TCP can be a good choice for games which exchange only or mostly important messages which must not be dropped and delivered in sending order (eg. most round-based games). To make that work with UDP you'd end up re-implementing a lot of already existing functionality inside TCP.
UDP is supposed to be better for real-time games, but both Minecraft and World of Warcraft actually do great with TCP.
Re:Minecraft server built in Node.js
by daredevildave on Friday October 29, 2010 @10:26AM
(#1847400)
Doh, sorry, obviously.
In which case, I wonder whether he (notch) is going to have trouble with the online performance. I've tried online play briefly and it didn't seem bad, I guess it isn't really twitch based.
Re:Minecraft server built in Node.js
by jasondavies on Friday October 29, 2010 @11:00AM
(#1847503)
I've played online (a few weeks ago) and there did seem to be problems with the server due to periodic GC causing massive lag and disconnections every so often.
Re:Minecraft server built in Node.js
by abronte on Friday October 29, 2010 @03:36PM
(#1848686)
This is pretty awesome, can't wait to try it out. The current minecraft server is such a memory hog and can be sort of hard to run a decent server on a small VPS. I wonder how this version compares.
I'd be curious to see how this compares to the Java one for speed (and some other SMP servers that are springing up) - it's quite difficult to store an infinite size map efficiently in memory and still keep good random access times.
UDP is supposed to be better for real-time games, but both Minecraft and World of Warcraft actually do great with TCP.
In which case, I wonder whether he (notch) is going to have trouble with the online performance. I've tried online play briefly and it didn't seem bad, I guess it isn't really twitch based.
[1]: Datagram Congestion Control Protocol: http://read.cs.ucla.edu/dccp/