News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by blazespin on Monday November 12, 2018 @11:23PM (#18438577)
Employee ownership is a very old concept. All studies have shown that they are risk averse and have poor growth. I’d love for this to work, but you can’t fantasize your way to results.
Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by cazum on Monday November 12, 2018 @11:53PM (#18438694)
Both of those things sound very good. Corporate growth for the sake of growth is what got us to an atmospheric carbon dioxide level of 400PPM.

If your idea of a company's success is how much profit it accrues, maybe it's time to question why it is you think that's a good thing.

Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by tome on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @07:59AM (#18440583)
> Corporate growth for the sake of growth is what got us to an atmospheric carbon dioxide level of 400PPM.

Too right. If the USSR had come to dominate we wouldn't be using fossil fuels.

Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by beerlord on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @12:08AM (#18438755)
Market failure got us to 400PPM. The externalities of carbon and methane pollution have not been properly priced in. That can be resolved with a market mechanism - a carbon tax.

The free market has also brought us widespread electric cars, solar panels, gas power plants. The very things with which we will combat climate change.

Socialism has brought us expanding populations globally, by offering free food to people who are not productive enough to buy it. The biggest threat to the planet now are the expanding populations of countries who still have their fertility rate above replacement rate.

Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by beckler on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @12:58AM (#18438947)
There was an interesting observation at some day cares in Israel. When their day care closed, parents would drop everything to make sure they picked their kids up on time, but some would still be late. At some point, these day cares decided to start applying fines whenever the parents were late, and it completely backfired. Parents were suddenly always late and in large numbers, because parents felt guilty about making teachers stay late, and by adding a fine, they removed that guilt.

I view a carbon tax in the same way. It's an easy way for companies to continue with whatever their doing and they replace any guilt they may have with an easy payment. It certainly isn't going to solve much, because it removes any real chance of accountability. It is not a significant enough incentive for them to implement impactful change.

The free market may help create solutions, but it will not sustain them. Reversing climate change will not be a profitable endeavor in the short-term, and unfortunately market success is a greedy algorithm.

It's a complete contradiction that a free market could ensure conservation, since it relies entirety upon consumption, and market success is about who consumes the most.

Link to article about Israel day cares: http://freakonomics.com/2013/10/23/what-makes-people-do-what...

Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by slugiscool99 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @01:09AM (#18438986)
It's different because companies don't feel guilt. Instead, they are motivated purely by revenues and profits which makes a carbon tax a viable incentive for them to decrease carbon emissions. As of now, there are almost no real repercussions for companies who destroy the environment.
Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by beckler on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @01:34PM (#18443443)
It might not be guilt per se, since it was only an example, so consider it what you want. Be it bad PR, obligations, compliance, etc.
Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by starbeast on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @12:33AM (#18438833)
>The free market has also brought us widespread electric cars, solar panels, gas power plants.

Massive government investment brought us each of those.

>Socialism has brought us expanding populations globally, by offering free food to people who are not productive enough to buy it. The biggest threat to the planet now are the expanding populations of countries who still have their fertility rate above replacement rate.

If we are attributing threats, I'd look closer to home.

Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by brbrodude on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @08:18AM (#18440692)
The hard right solution: lets have some way to let the bottom half of the population drop out of the world. At least it's an honest take on capitalism ideology, gotta give it him!
Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by cazum on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @12:26AM (#18438811)
If we're just going to attribute anything that happened during capitalism as a result of the "free market" then I get to say that communism invented satellites, discovered stem cells, and cured maternally transmitted HIV.

Electric cars and solar panels won't save us. You're not fooling anyone with that. Solar panels are not nearly efficient enough to replace anything major any time soon, and electric passenger cars will certainly help, but they are not hitting the pavement fast enough to have any kind of impact in the timelines we need to see to avoid apocalyptic catastrophe.

Also how will gas power plants help climate change? Unless this is a different use of the word 'gas' than i'm used to, I think you're referring to natural gas, aka: one of the largest contributor to carbon emissions.

And damn, I've heard a lot of dumb anti-socialist arguments before, but "people who are not able to provide labor to a market economy should starve to death" is a new one.

Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by Plastikdusche on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @02:01AM (#18439197)
Do you have a source that natural gas is the largest carbon emissionss contributer? Genuinely curious, because over here in Germany gas companies (Gazprom.. ;)) market themselves as the opposite and the same argument is used for cars running on natural gas. I know that's just PR, but I thought it produces less emissions because it burns more efficiently than other fossil fuels.
Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by Symbiote on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @03:43AM (#18439580)
CO2 emissions are essentially the same, but other pollutants are much lower. There are less contaminants in natural gas, so burning it in a cheap and inefficient engine like a bus in a city is better than using petrol.
Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by cazum on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @07:37AM (#18440469)
I should have written "one of the largest", not the largest, my apologies.
Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by jahaja on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @04:52AM (#18439841)
> And damn, I've heard a lot of dumb anti-socialist arguments before, but "people who are not able to provide labor to a market economy should starve to death" is a new one.

Horrible indeed. The callousness of it reminded me of this exchange, loosely recalled, in the "Conspiracy" HBO movie about the Wannsee conference:

Some nazi bureaucrat: - "Hard labour? But many haven't picked up anything heavier than a pencil in their entire life?!"

Heydrich: - "Yes, and subsequently most will perish of natural causes." casually moves on the the next point

Some nazi bureaucrat: leans back visibly shaken.

Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by usrusr on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @04:31AM (#18439748)
Very high on the list of things that capitalism has brought: socialism. It literally would not exist without capitalism. Therefore, whatever you can attribute to socialism, it's also an indirect outcome of capitalism.
Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by starbeast on Monday November 12, 2018 @11:40PM (#18438641)
On the other hand, Aardman is in the business of making cartoons for children out of clay. And actually has a business doing this.

They are experts in successfully fantasizing their way to results.

As far as being risk averse or having poor growth, their employees are animators. It is not a trade you take up if you tend to be risk averse.

Growth will be judged a frame at a time, but growth is only vitally important to investors and is not that sane a metric of success.

Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by ascar on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @02:10AM (#18439229)
Growth at the inflation rate is at least important for employees in terms of pay-raises to actually maintain a stable standard of living.
Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by blazespin on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @01:12AM (#18439000)
That's true. it might work in this instance. My guess though is a competitor will see this as an opportunity to copy and have a more efficient studio.
Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by laumars on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @02:18AM (#18439250)
Aardman didn’t invent stop motion nor claymation. So plenty of companies have been in the business of creating stories using those techniques. However I’m pretty sure Aardman could have grounds for legal action if another company copied their iconic character designs (which will be copyrighted).
Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by TylerE on Monday November 12, 2018 @11:35PM (#18438626)
Why does everything have to be growth, growth, growth, growth?

What's wrong with being stable and providing a decent livelihood?

Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by marcinzm on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @02:41AM (#18439356)
The world is not stable, technology is not stable, your competitors are not stable and your customers' desires are not stable. If you don't try to grow then eventually you'll start to shrink.
Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by bloak on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @05:06AM (#18439901)
A company shrinking is only a problem for a certain kind of shareholder. Employees may be perfectly happy to retire or move on to new jobs as the company gradually reduces its workforce while remaining true to its core business, for which there is a gradually decreasing demand.

As an example, I believe there are some car manufacturers who have stated that rather than diversify into electric cars they intend to stick with internal combustion engines for as long as there is demand, then close down. It seems like a reasonable plan to me. Some investors will be happy with the larger short-term profits that derive from not having to invest in a struggle to go electric, which they'd probably fail at anyway. Other investors can sell their shares and reinvest elsewhere.

Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by laumars on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @02:14AM (#18439242)
There’s nothing wrong with a company existing to specialise in its own field. Not every business has to be an Amazon nor Google. not everyone wants to work in such a company and a great many business owners equally don’t really care that much either just so long as their business sustains them a comfortable life.

We live in the bubble in the technology sector because growth is easy (data can be redistributed cheaply and we can work on an international scale right from the off). But for an animation studio that would mean having to write more scripts and thus potentially diluting their brand with inferior stores.

When You think about where Aardman began (stop motion animation that could take years just to produce one half hour TV movie), you can really see that the company is built around the love of animation rather than being a mass producer of family content.

Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by gisely on Monday November 12, 2018 @11:32PM (#18438614)
Is that necessarily a bad thing? Aardman has a well established artistic niche. Perhaps good governance for them emphasizes stability over risky growth opportunities.
Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by vanderZwan on Monday November 12, 2018 @11:56PM (#18438710)
And how long-lasting are these companies? Do they fail at providing a steady income for their employees?
Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by michaelchisari on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @01:11AM (#18438995)
Mondragon Cooperative is 62 years old, employs ~75k people and has revenues in the billions.
Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by geezerjay on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @02:09AM (#18439224)
Mondragon collapsed a few yeas ago, though, with a very capitalist series of cascading bankruptcies across subsidiaries

https://www.economist.com/business/2013/11/09/trouble-in-wor...

Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by SmellyGeekBoy on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @04:13AM (#18439686)
> All studies have shown that they are risk averse and have poor growth.

You say this like it's a bad thing?

Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by C1sc0cat on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @04:53AM (#18439849)
Not really coops go back to 19th century Uk and Italy - oh and part of KFC is a producer coop.
Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by cbayram on Monday November 12, 2018 @11:28PM (#18438595)
Solid model as long as one profits
Re:Aardman Animation Is Giving the Company to Their Employees by thrillgore on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @12:04AM (#18438733)
Hacker News is an effective parody of itself.