Thats not the best analogy for the complaint -- its more like insisting that instead of putting your arguments down on paper in words, you're using emoticons and forcing the reader to play charades. Though to your point, listing out your arguments is certainly a boring, bland way of conveying a topic...
Its a poor medium choice; I don't choose a 10x10px image to show you the Mona Lisa...
Except the tweets aren't emoticons and no-one is forcing the reader to guess anything - the authors are literally "putting [their] arguments down on paper in words", just in short paragraphs.
Not really, imho. There are some kind of media that are more appropriate than others for certain type of messages.
For example, would you have liked this as a video or a series of pictures with just text in it? Or as an audio file?
True, it wouldn't work as well if it was a video.
> a series of pictures with just text in it?
You mean like a presentation of slides? That sounds perfect (and not all that far from a tweet stream, really - small chunks of information presented in order.)
> Or as an audio file?
Given I've listened to podcasts with episodes on topics like this, yeah, that might also work.
(This is such a bizarre complaint to me - it's like insisting that people not speak to you in real time but instead put down their arguments onto paper and present them to you.)