News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Proof Shows Infinite Curves Come in Two Types by ars on Sunday November 11, 2018 @12:52AM (#18425182)
It's essentially aleph 0 / aleph 1. Aleph 1 is so much larger than aleph 0 that this equation "equals" zero.

The real problem here is that this equation doesn't really make any sense: You can't divide infinity and expect answers that make sense in ordinary language.

So you can have an infinite number of curves of rank > 1, and yet there is 0% chance you'll come across one by accident (since you'll need to sample an infinite number of rank <= 1 curves in order to do that - but of course, you can't, there's an infinite number of them).

Re:New Proof Shows Infinite Curves Come in Two Types by vostok on Sunday November 11, 2018 @01:15AM (#18425239)
They're not really dividing aleph_0 by aleph_1. The important thing is that it has measure 0, but you can easily have a set with cardinality aleph_1 and measure 0.

There are also no ironic quotes around "equals". The measure really is 0.