I'm not sure what the justification is to assume that Starlink will not be horribly oversubscribed, either. Last I checked it was supposed to be about 32Tbps with all satellites operational. A substantial amount of that is completely wasted over water, so the effective capacity for customer that actually have the money for SpaceX to generate revenue is very small. The types of services people need in remote areas, whether it be a plane or in a village that has never had internet are not those that require low latency. They are either streaming media (plane), or web browsing. In that sense, I don't see how Starlink has and advantage there.
I would be shocked if they could deliver something better than cable on DOCSIS 3 to even 10% of cable customers with comparable service. My guess is it will be tailored more to high-paying customers that happen to not be able to get decent cable.
A lot of the technology press has misunderstood the most desirable applications and locations for it. People think that it's going to compete for a residential internet service in a suburb of a city like Portland, or Sacramento, or Denver. If you can get 300 megabit per second DOCSIS3 service in one of those locations, that would be drastically better. where it is going to be a game-changer is all of the locations that are right now dependent on highly oversubscribed geostationary small vsat services, and extremely rural areas where there isn't even a single last-mile terrestrial Wireless ISP. and for ships in the middle of the ocean, if the gigabyte per dollar cost is significantly less than inmarsat or other options.
I agree that the service could be better in theory, but at the same time, existing satellite internet service also could be better by taking on fewer customers and not being as congested. But that's a cost trade-off. And in this case, I believe SpaceX has a higher cost per customer to recoup, so it seems in their best interest to also be congested to increase revenue.
It will be ~80Tbps after the first three phases (the LEO constellation), ~240Tbps after VLEO.
I agree with you that they probably cannot offer enough bandwidth to compete with residential internet in densely habited areas.(1) The system is really interesting in less densely inhabited places, and for backhaul. The complete system has more transcontinental bandwith between almost any two (distant enough) places than all submarine cables between them put together. This alone will likely pay for the whole system, with plenty to spare.
(1) With a few exceptions. After the full constellation is up, New Zealand will have ~30 times more downlink capacity than the entire bandwidth use of the country as of right now, and will also have tens of times more connecting capacity with North America and Australia than it currently has. But that requires a country of only 6 million in the starlink sweet spot that gets all of the bandwidth of all visible satellites to the east of it.
If the space segment only adds 120ms to what would be an otherwise same latency rtt ping, it's not so bad, people in the US have been spoiled by having CDNs very near all major ix points.