News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Zulip Server 1.9: HipChat import and much more by hiisukun on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @05:09PM (#18402811)
I'd love to set this up at my part time workplace, but it's a forensics shop where the network is offline, and doesn't have email. Team is small (<20) so manual accounts would be fine.

Am I reading the docs correctly in that email is absolutely required? I haven't checked thoroughly for this new release, but previously it was for missed message notification as well as account creation, if I'm remembering right.

It's not a for profit place, so I'm simply looking to self host, sans email, to make communication easier across the teams. Current solution is definitely inferior to Zulip!

Re:Zulip Server 1.9: HipChat import and much more by tabbott on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @05:15PM (#18402848)
We support this, it's just enough of a corner case that it's not well documented. If you don't care about missed-message emails, you can install the Docker image (easiest to setup when offline), and then use https://zulip.readthedocs.io/en/latest/production/authentica... with an Apache .htaccess file as the thing that sets REMOTE_USER.

Send a message in "#production help" in chat.zulip.org if you have trouble figuring it out, and I'll extend the docs until you can get it working.

Re:Zulip Server 1.9: HipChat import and much more by hiisukun on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @05:23PM (#18402886)
Well, that's a great reply. Having read quickly through the docs, I think in particular the "Life of an Apache-based SSO login attempt" had enough information to clarify the process for me - until then I wasn't as sure.

I don't think I would have located this option while filtering for "works without email, and I'm okay missing messages". If it was present a year ago I definitely didn't. Very glad it's a supported corner case!

Re:Zulip Server 1.9: HipChat import and much more by tabbott on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @05:27PM (#18402907)
Yeah, the front-page documentation focuses pretty heavily on "you should setup email" because it helps folks in a normal environment successfully setup Zulip quickly and reliably. I'm not sure whether this use case is common enough that we should put it in the front-page docs, but possibly we should write something that Google will find...
Re:Zulip Server 1.9: HipChat import and much more by bj0 on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @06:46PM (#18403297)
I looked at Zulip vs Mattermost several months ago and, if I recall correctly, this was one of the primary reasons I went with Mattermost. I just wanted something I could spin up in docker on a vps without having to setup anything else (like an email server). Mattermost lets you generate "invite links" that you can just paste in a chat or text message.

The other really neat feature was having multiple "teams" on a single server.

Re:Zulip Server 1.9: HipChat import and much more by seedie on Thursday November 08, 2018 @04:31AM (#18405269)
Hi, I don't know enough about Mattermost to be sure I understand you correctly about 'multiple "teams" on a single server' but you can host multiple organizations (realms in zulip-speak) on a single zulip server https://zulip.readthedocs.io/en/latest/production/multiple-o...

edit: link updated to point to official documentation instead of github

Re:Zulip Server 1.9: HipChat import and much more by bj0 on Thursday November 08, 2018 @12:09PM (#18407809)
That's neat, I may look at zulip again if I need to setup another server.

From a quick glance, the differences I see are: * In mattermost, different "teams" (or "realms" or "namespaces", whatever) exist on the same server (same url), and a user account that logs in will only see the teams they are assigned to. A single user account can be assigned to multiple teams (they appear on the left, similar to how the slack desktop app shows multiple server connections).

* Zulip requires a different subdomain for each "realm", and it sounds like users have to log into each one separately. It is not clear if the same account is shared between organizations or a user must have separate accounts.

So it sounds like Zulip's approach is separate, isolated "organizations", like slack, just hosted on the same server. Where Mattermost's approach is more like having separate, but integrated teams/groups/namespaces that a single account can be part of.

Re:Zulip Server 1.9: HipChat import and much more by vishnu_ks on Thursday November 08, 2018 @12:21PM (#18407918)
> So it sounds like Zulip's approach is separate, isolated "organizations", like slack, just hosted on the same server.

Correct. But Zulip does allow to import settings, profile picture etc from an existing account during signup if the email remains the same.