News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The history of humans trying to reduce one another to a p... by scythe on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @09:15PM (#18396669)
>When we define ourselves, we become more like that which we define, in what philosopher Ian Hacking calls “the looping effect of mankind.” Biological phenomena will carry on regardless of what it is called. The heart will continue beating whether the act of muscle contraction is called “the heartbeat” or something else. Not so for the intricacies of psychology: the proud introverts become more introverted, the neurotic more neurotic, some people buy T-shirts that say no, i’m not a sociopath, I’m just an intj.

Is it even possible to construct a "personality test" that avoids suggesting people identify with negative traits?

Re:The history of humans trying to reduce one another to a p... by maxxxxx on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @09:31PM (#18396724)
I don't think that any traits are inherently negative. For example I have some autistic or Asperger's traits. I had spent many years being confused that I wasn't able to do some things socially that were super easy for others. After learning about this I just felt relief. These traits are part of me like my height and hair color. Not negative, not positive.
Re:The history of humans trying to reduce one another to a p... by njarboe on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @09:53PM (#18396802)
Depends what you want out of life. Your height is what it is, so best not to dwell on it, but, if you are a man, being 6'1 instead of 5'6 will change how most people view you. If the words have any meaning, it would be a negative to be that short compared to being tall.
Re:The history of humans trying to reduce one another to a p... by scythe on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @10:00PM (#18396827)
I disagree. I consider some parts of my personality to be unambiguously bad and prefer they would change. I prefer this kind of self-image to the current vogue of never seeing the negatives.
Re:The history of humans trying to reduce one another to a p... by maxxxxx on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @10:08PM (#18396845)
If you are able to change them, then view them as negative and change them. But others can't be changed or at least they are difficult to change. I have spent almost 50 years trying to figure out how to behave correctly in certain social situations but never found a way to do so. Now I just say "f..k it" and don't even try. Instead I focus on things I can change. I don't beat myself up anymore over things I can't change. I find this much more productive.
Re:The history of humans trying to reduce one another to a p... by faceplanted on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @08:58AM (#18399107)
If you don't mind my asking, could you give a few examples of these social situations and what troubles you had?

I only ask because I went through rather an opposite path of believing from a young age that because I couldn't manage certain social situations that I must be on the spectrum in some way^[1], and once I changed who I was in those situations with I was able to relearn how to work in them.

So it's interesting to me to hear what someone on other end experienced.

^[1] (even after my school sending me for analysis cleared me of that almost immediately, I assumed there must be something. Later it turned out I was in a very inhospitable environment growing up and had developed coping mechanisms for being around people that didn't express around psychologists or psychiatrists)

Re:The history of humans trying to reduce one another to a p... by maxxxxx on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @09:25AM (#18399281)
For example I have never done well in group situations. I see other people having fun and bonding while I am on the sidelines, don't have fun and don't make connections. I have tried a lot of things but I never got comfortable. This contrasts to other things like public speaking or talking to women. There I took advice and could implement it with a lot of effort and eventual improvement. But there are situations where I simply don't improve despite other people handling them naturally without effort. I also can identify with some typical autistic traits.

I would compare it to a dyslexic ex coworker. I can look at a sheet of paper and read it within seconds, understand it and spot spelling errors. He could stare at it for hours and only see a jumble of letters. I practiced a lot with him but he just didn't improve. On the other hand the same person could go to a bar, look at people, and immediately he knew who to talk to in what way. I go to a bar, see random people, but simply can't read the situation.

Does this make sense? I have improved a lot from a miserable childhood up to my 30s to now being socially reasonable functioning but I have some hard limits I can't overcome no matter how I try. Now I am accepting this and feel liberated from pressure.

Re:The history of humans trying to reduce one another to a p... by faceplanted on Thursday November 15, 2018 @08:43AM (#18459130)
> But there are situations where I simply don't improve despite other people handling them naturally without effort

When you say you don't improve, are you referring to internally or externally, as in, are you not improving in that you can't pass for someone handling the situation, or not improving in that you can pass for handling the situation but you don't get any more comfortable?

When I actually started to improve I found that I had previously been going about it the wrong way around, where I was trying to force myself to feel comfortable hoping the cues and behaviours would come later, what actually helped was getting basic (basic to others anyway) tips and advice on how to fit into the situations and then letting the comfort and confidence come later.

Obviously we're in different life situations, but your perspective is super interesting here.

Re:The history of humans trying to reduce one another to a p... by creep on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @08:13AM (#18398860)
100% agree with you. It's the difference between self-improvement and attempting to squeeze a square peg through a round hole. I can't change the autism any more than I can make myself taller, so why bother?
Re:The history of humans trying to reduce one another to a p... by analog31 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @09:47PM (#18396779)
Unfortunately, a lot of people harbor negative stereotypes about some traits, such as introversion and anti-authoritarianism. People may also believe that they have a better chance of manipulating you, if they know something special about you.

And "there are no wrong answers" may just be a deceit, to encourage you to reveal those traits. Of course there are wrong answers.

Re:The history of humans trying to reduce one another to a p... by neotrope on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @09:41PM (#18396758)
You’re confusing disorders from personalities.
Re:The history of humans trying to reduce one another to a p... by maxxxxx on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @09:50PM (#18396784)
What's the difference? Why would I try treat autistic tendencies differently from being introvert? I don't want to live my life feeling defective.
Re:The history of humans trying to reduce one another to a p... by ionised on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @05:40AM (#18398289)
because introversion isn't a defect anymore than extraversion is.

It certainly isn't a disorder like autism, though they may come in pairs.

Re:The history of humans trying to reduce one another to a p... by creep on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @08:09AM (#18398843)
Gender dysphoria was a "disorder" back in the day.

Disorders are defined by the society in which the trait (or "symptoms") arise. In South America, people who hear voices and have visions are recognized as having the potential to become a shaman. Shamans are seen as the protectors and healers of a village-- lauded and respected. In North America they are called schizophrenics. We distrust schizophrenics here and don't really know at all how to "help" them. They don't have a place here.

I have autism and I don't see myself as being disordered. I have trouble sometimes in North America, but any help I need is due to my non-alignment with the culture, not due to myself inherently.

Extroversion could be a disorder in a place like Japan, where personal space, privacy, subtlety, boundaries between strangers, and silence are highly valued. In America extroversion is often a huge advantage.

Nothing is a defect in the right context, just like anything could be in another.