News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by jakelarkin on Sunday November 04, 2018 @06:47PM (#18378728)
this is the Nash Equilibrium type problem that exists with US federalism and extreme poverty. Cities just ship people around hoping to reduce their share of cost, while the homeless just become more physically sick or addicted, and mentally traumatized, so they become more costly to care for in aggregate over a lifetime. Everyone is worse off. It would be so much simpler, cheaper if society just got people back on their feet as quickly as possible with focused care & rapid re-housing.
Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by PhantomGremlin on Sunday November 04, 2018 @07:56PM (#18379007)
It would be so much simpler, cheaper if society just got people back on their feet as quickly as possible with focused care & rapid re-housing.

I think everyone can agree that it would greatly benefit society to get "people back on their feet".

But how? There's a virtually unlimited stream of drugs coming into this country. There are many people who have mental illness. In many places, The Rent Is Too Damn High.

IMO solving this problem is by no means "simple". How expensive is it to do "focused care"? Has it been tried, and what's its track record?

Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by michaelchisari on Sunday November 04, 2018 @09:40PM (#18379468)
There's a virtually unlimited stream of drugs coming into this country. There are many people who have mental illness.

Anybody with a drug problem should be able to walk into a hospital, say "I'm addicted to X" and get into treatment immediately, free of charge.

Anybody with a mental illness should be able to walk into a hospital, say "I can't take care of myself because X keeps happening in my brain" and get into treatment immediately, free of charge.

If you've ever tried to help someone get clean or get mental health inpatient care in the U.S., you can completely understand how people end up on the streets who could otherwise be productive members of society.

Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by mikemotherwell on Sunday November 04, 2018 @10:38PM (#18379704)
If you look at this - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_homeless_... - the US has quite low homelessness rates. The problem is the USA is a massive country in area and population. The opportunities vary greatly, as do the resources. REALLY low macro homelessness (think nationally) can still lead to very high rates at a micro level (think Tenderloin).

Where can the USA look for similarities? Singapore is one city state, as is Hong Kong. Australia's cities are 600 miles apart. The EU has a language issue moving from city to city, despite London to Paris being 1/10th as far than SF is to NYC. The USA is pretty unique here.

The one similar country is China. The GDP per capita by Chinese prefecture makes the US look positively egalitarian: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_prefecture-level_citie...

China solves their issues by essentially banning movement between areas. The US could never solve their issues that way, for a variety of reasons.

So I'm not sure what the solution is to micro level high homelessness, but macro level low homelessness.

Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by adventured on Monday November 05, 2018 @12:03AM (#18379991)
We've found one partial solution to homelessness that works extremely effectively. It was enacted during the George W. Bush Administration, and continued + expanded under the Obama Administration, called the housing first program. We put homeless people into permanent housing, taking care of their shelter needs first, and then focus on treating them for things like addiction. It reduced chronic homelessness by 30% in just three years 2005-2007.

We added to it with the Homeless Prevention and Rapid Re-Housing Program, as part of the stimulus program in 2009. It helped a million homeless people in two years.

That the US homelessness rate looks relatively good now, owes a lot to this chain of programs.

Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by glangdale on Monday November 05, 2018 @04:12AM (#18380913)
Seriously this. What a lot of people don't grasp is that the sort of things that 'housing first' can (fairly expensively) help with are things that are even more expensive if the situations wind up being treated by mechanisms like hospitals, the mental health system or the police or jail/prison systems as crises.

Getting people into houses and then helping them clean up their acts, rather than setting a high moral bar (we won't house you until you clean up your alcohol/drug addiction and take treatment for your mental health issues) is just plain good sense.

Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by Broken_Hippo on Monday November 05, 2018 @04:31PM (#18386165)
Getting people into houses and then helping them clean up their acts, rather than setting a high moral bar (we won't house you until you clean up your alcohol/drug addiction and take treatment for your mental health issues) is just plain good sense.

I've always thought the "clean up then get help" seemed cruel and from a position of ignorance. I couldn't imagine being homeless and having to clean up to get a dry place to sleep or food to eat. Sobriety would just add another layer of misery: Withdrawal from any substance would add even more layers.

Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by briandear on Monday November 05, 2018 @12:58AM (#18380176)
There are exactly those programs in San Francisco, but, unless you’ve ever dealt with the extremely mentally ill, you would know that they have to ask for the help. 5150s are temporary, so unless the person actually asks for help, there isn’t anything that can be done under current law.
Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by conanbatt on Monday November 05, 2018 @12:28AM (#18380076)
> free of charge.

I think you should understand what this really means. Are you willing to pay 10, 15% extra of your income to sustain 10~25k a month bills for mentally ill people?

Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by raphlinus on Monday November 05, 2018 @12:55AM (#18380165)
Totally. If it means they live an actually good life rather than a form of hell, I would consider it a very good deal. (Of course, things get a lot dicier when there are "treatment programs" optimized for siphoning money as opposed to helping people, a criticism that can be leveled against large swathes of the drug treatment industry. I would of course not feel good about 10-15% of my income lining their pockets)
Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by conanbatt on Monday November 05, 2018 @01:17AM (#18380252)
Well, you can start by donating that to Housing First in SF:

https://www.homefirstscc.org

Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by glangdale on Monday November 05, 2018 @04:14AM (#18380921)
I'm guessing that you imagine that otherwise, homeless mentally ill people are a zero cost to society. Like it won't cost anything to put them in a jail or treat them in the ER, right?
Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by michaelchisari on Monday November 05, 2018 @02:14PM (#18385030)
Are you willing to pay 10, 15% extra of your income

Without hesitation. I want to live in a healthier America.

Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by Ericson2314 on Monday November 05, 2018 @12:31AM (#18380087)
Yes
Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by conanbatt on Monday November 05, 2018 @01:18AM (#18380253)
You can start here: https://www.homefirstscc.org. There are multiple SF charities.
Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by tjr225 on Monday November 05, 2018 @12:38AM (#18380109)
Same here. I would rather that the disproportionately rich pay for it, however.
Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by briandear on Monday November 05, 2018 @01:04AM (#18380205)
You would rather someone else pay for your beliefs? The disproportionately rich already pay a disproportionate share of taxes. The top 1% earn 19% of the income but pay 35% of the taxes in the US. I’m not sure that’s fair. Rich people also create the jobs: if they pay more, they have less incentive to invest more which means fewer businesses being funded and fewer jobs.
Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by TangoTrotFox on Monday November 05, 2018 @02:07AM (#18380438)
I generally agree with you here, but as an aside there is one nuance you have to consider. And that's taxation vs disposable income. Imagine somebody earns $50k and spends $30k on their living expenses and pays a 30% tax rate. They have $20k left after their basic living expenses, but $15k of that is eaten up by taxes. Looking at their disposable income, they're paying a ridiculous tax rate of 75%.

I think it's more reasonable to compare taxation on disposable income. In my opinion a fair tax would only tax disposable income anyhow. Of course that creates an incentive to have $0 disposable income but it's no different than the problem of corporations aiming to report $0 profit.

Progressive tax schemes aim to achieve this, but in a completely broken and inconsistent fashion. For instance somebody earning $100k in San Francisco is going to be spending a rather different percent of their income on basic living expenses than somebody living in Bodunk earning the same, and so applying the same scheme to both does not make sense. It'd be much easier to just make everything that qualifies as a 'basic living expense' fully deductible, and then you pay e.g. 15% on the rest.

Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by conanbatt on Monday November 05, 2018 @10:39AM (#18383102)
This is a convoluted interpretation of utilitarianism, which is the moral justification for progressive taxation in the general case.

The last 10 bucks of a rich person are worth less to him than the last 10 bucks of a poor person in terms of diminishing returns.

What I dislike enormously about utilitarian arguments is that, provided some evidence, you can justify anything. For example: why ever spend money on homeless people that will not work: its better to spend that money in literally anything else.

Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by Bahamut on Monday November 05, 2018 @02:27AM (#18380514)
There's more to it here - the wealthy generally are able to better play long games to further save more, better able to handle unexpected life events that could devastate the less prepared, and have better alignment with the government fighting/optimizing for their use cases.

There are a lot more reasons as to the exponential advantages the wealthy generally enjoy suggest that the wealthy should indeed get taxed more, but it's probably better suited for discussion elsewhere than HN.

Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by TangoTrotFox on Monday November 05, 2018 @03:15AM (#18380696)
Sure, but I think this starts getting into ideology. I think people should be taxed rates that, in a vacuum, can be considered fair. I pay 15% of what I can, you pay 15% of what you can is about as fair as you can get. The reason I'm not fond of going beyond this is because you start getting into very subjective territory.

For instance while I agree with all you've said, excepting your conclusion, I'm sure you'd also agree that lower income individuals would also be much more likely to end up as the direct beneficiaries of where lots of government money goes to such medicaid/medicare and various social programs. Since these lower income individuals are going to be disproportionately more likely to utilize the benefits of these government programs, would it then not make more sense for them to shoulder a greater percent of the costs to account for this? I absolutely do not agree with this conclusion, but at the same time I also don't see any clear logical flaw in it.

So you can do an ideological tug of war, one way or the other, to no end on these issues. One ideology might have the wealthy give nearly all of their income away to help the rest of the population. The other end of ideology might have people give none away and rely entirely on market dynamics. I think a fixed and fair sum is one of the more reasonable ways to step outside of ideology and try to create a system that nobody really loves, but also nobody can create rational arguments suggesting is, in and of itself, unreasonably biased towards one group or another.

Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by conanbatt on Monday November 05, 2018 @10:42AM (#18383133)
> but at the same time I also don't see any clear logical flaw in it.

Great example! And I agree. The example you give is one of the reasons I have with progressive taxation, by the definition of %. Someone with 1,000,000 income and someone with 30,000 paying the same rate, the richer pays a lot more than he will use from the state. So in effect, a flat-tax rate is most likely already progressive.

I am in favor of a flat tax-rate for all, without deductions or exceptions. And I would go a step further and make the contributions public or pseudo-public.

Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by FiveSquared on Monday November 05, 2018 @01:01PM (#18384405)
But what about the extremely poor?
Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by conanbatt on Monday November 05, 2018 @05:49PM (#18386728)
Aid that comes equally from the rest out of the flat 15%.

Its a different system one where the top 90% each cheap in to help the distressed 10%, another one where the top 10 give to the top 20, the top 20 to the top 30, etc.

Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by conanbatt on Monday November 05, 2018 @01:20AM (#18380266)
World's tiniest golden violin. I am also against disproportionate taxes on the rich, but lets not start pitying them or assigning value to their well being above societies.

Liberty above everything else, and I dont want anyone to suffer any consequence under the veil of "trickle-down econ", which is not what people think it is.

Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by isoskeles on Monday November 05, 2018 @11:47AM (#18383760)
Nah, I feel for the disproportionately rich. They’re constantly blamed for society’s ills, for the sin of having wealth, to the point where I’m sure something like 15% of the population would be happy with dragging them into the streets and beheading them. I’m tired of hearing about the “disproportionately rich” and the unoriginal idea that their resources are the only solution. It’s tiring to see people continue piling on with that rhetoric.
Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by FiveSquared on Monday November 05, 2018 @12:58PM (#18384372)
And not knowing whos real and whos fake. But, they should pay a fair share. BTW, The best income is 299k at Reigh NC.
Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by darkarmani on Monday November 05, 2018 @03:00PM (#18385421)
Are you talking about wealth or income?
Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by SolaceQuantum on Sunday November 04, 2018 @08:34PM (#18379156)
From what I understand there have been several successful pilot projects that are variously shut down or are considered inappropriate for other cities (politically unpopular). Utah just straight up housed people to great success. NYC has a massive homeless population but they also put a ton of money into housing their homeless- also to fairly decent success. For drug addiction, there have been successful needle providing clinics in Canada and America currently has methodone clinics to great success. There are various police programs just for connecting homeless people to resources to get clean and start working, and otherwise providing them what they need to survive until they’re ready, and we know these have had success also. None of them are politically popular and there’s a lot of opposition to implementing any of them.
Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by jonathankoren on Sunday November 04, 2018 @10:03PM (#18379573)
Utah’s program of housing the chronically homeless has a lot of misunderstandings. Mainly about that it serves the chronically homeless, which are a minority among the homeless.

https://www.deseretnews.com/article/865678779/Is-Utah-still-...

Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by jakelarkin on Sunday November 04, 2018 @10:42PM (#18379719)
we've rebuilt like 15 countries (after bombing them) in the past ... somehow its totally impossible to temporarily house a fractional percentage of people in our country and make sure they get a job or their meds instead of addicted to heroin

theres so many bs political excuses; bad zoning, bad building regulation, bad union rules, bad health regulations, bad drug laws, civil legal liability, cost of Rx drugs ... as if government doesnt have have power to fix those things. it's a feigned helplessness because the poor inherently have no political leverage/value to those in power.

Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by rectang on Sunday November 04, 2018 @09:41PM (#18379472)
The intractable problem is that helping the homeless is seen as moral hazard by a large segment of the American populace. Our programs are incoherent because some want to provide assistance and others to withhold it.
Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by SturgeonsLaw on Sunday November 04, 2018 @10:45PM (#18379728)
Great strides in helping the homeless can be achieved by giving them housing. It almost sounds like a tautology, and it triggers outrage in certain segments of the population, but once people have that stable foundation they can then work towards rebuilding their life.
Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by lsc on Monday November 05, 2018 @02:18AM (#18380474)
>IMO solving this problem is by no means "simple".

I think providing people housing is simple. It's just expensive.

Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by briandear on Monday November 05, 2018 @12:55AM (#18380163)
With the hundreds of millions SF spends on the homeless, it could be fair to say that a large number of homeless don’t want “care” or “re-housing.” The city spends more and more and it doesn’t make a dent in the numbers. An objective observer might suggest that the more you subsidize something, the more of it you get. Compared to most places, it’s easier to be homeless in San Francisco, which could create a disincentive for the homeless to care about getting off the street.
Re:Bussed out: how America moves thousands of homeless peopl... by jakelarkin on Monday November 05, 2018 @11:44AM (#18383731)
i agree SF needs less coddling and way stronger sticks (at least for the young & able-bodied), but fundamentally theres no where for these people to go to try to get it together. cost of housing way above welfare/SSID in a 50 mile radius. there's zero net shelter space. because the political incentives on the west coast (nimby, mellow weather, already high taxes) are to not bother to build them.

theres also not enough jail space or PD headcount, so dealers, petty burglars just cycle in and out without consequence. its a vicious cycle of extreme poverty that starts and ends with a corrupt, poorly run local government