Re:Real Progress in Parkinson’s
by amelius on Sunday November 04, 2018 @09:57AM
(#18376120)
I thought this was a good comment on that page:
> Before we get too excited: it could be an epiphenomenon. For example, misfolded Alpha Synuclein leads to poor gut motility and that causes appendicitis, which leads to appendectomy. All retrospective studies are contaminated by that possibility, which is why treatments can’t be based on them. However, retrospective studies lead to hypotheses that can be tested in trials. Perhaps not doing appendectomies in people without appendicitis because they are “at risk” for PD–thats a bit extreme.
> Before we get too excited: it could be an epiphenomenon. For example, misfolded Alpha Synuclein leads to poor gut motility and that causes appendicitis, which leads to appendectomy. All retrospective studies are contaminated by that possibility, which is why treatments can’t be based on them. However, retrospective studies lead to hypotheses that can be tested in trials. Perhaps not doing appendectomies in people without appendicitis because they are “at risk” for PD–thats a bit extreme.