Vacant blocks in prime real estate locations are taxed at their market value though, no? So if you've got that land sitting idle, and you're not collecting income from rent, nor using it yourself, you're going to lose money on it. This is an incentive to sell it to someone who will make money, or otherwise find a way to employ it more productively.
That said, I don't think I'd really like to see property taxes on domain names.
The biggest issue I see though is the implication for small projects.
For example, maybe in 1994 you snapped up pizza.com. You could have been using it ever since for a pizza price search engine which gets 100,000 unique visitors per month and earns you $5,000 per month. That's decent income, except the taxes on the domain's market value of $2.6 million[1] would be crippling. So despite using the domain in what most would think of as good way, you couldn't afford to have such a good domain. Now extrapolate this example for the thousands of sites that have a good domain name for a small project.
Could you also imagine the costs involved with any arbitration process to handle that. If you had to build it into the average domain cost, you wouldn't be paying $10 anymore, in fact you might find a lot of domains are cheaper through the free market system that exists now.
For me the annoyance comes from the fact that most of the parcels of land that are owned are actively being used for something, while it seems most of the domains in existence are owned by these squatter bastards.
If dn = number of domain names owned and du = number of domain names owned with valid DNS and no crappy domain squatter parking pages, then I contend du/dn < .5. In fact, I get the impression it's more like .1 or less (or perhaps something even more ludicrous).
Even if I'm totally wrong about the ratio of land used, there's no way that I'm wrong that lu/ln > du/dn.
The equivalent first step for domains though is for Google to stop treating made-for-adsense domains as real sites, so the $10/year/domain can't be offset by tricking advertisers and web neophytes.
I wouldn't have that much of a problem if getting a parked domain was just like getting an available domain except on the checkout page it said $300 or whatever instead of $10.
Each domain name is unique. Try another domain name? Probably "on the market for sale."
I believe, even with trademarks, you have to file an intent to use (http://www.uspto.gov/trademarks/process/appcontent.jsp). Maybe this is to stop trademark squatting?
I'm not surprised to see my comment being both up and down voted, but anyone down voting my comment, at least take the time to share your reasons for disagreeing. If there is any place a well considered domain purchasing discussion should be able to occur it's HN.
Regulators realised the best way to provide domains was to let the market determine their value and allow them to be traded at will (with respect for IP). So they wholesale at dirt cheap prices on a first-come first-served basis and people can then buy and sell them based on market value. Works for real estate so why not domains?
The problem derives from the initial price and the expectations that implants. Many expect a domain to cost $10. So when they are offered a price more than that, they are pissed off and blame the person selling it to them.
Nobody walks past a vacant block in a prime real estate location and goes "bastards, if they weren't squatting that land, I could snap it up". They know the land costs $x million and don't assume it should cost $10. However, because domains are a new real estate market and not every possible domain is out of wholesale, people base their expectation of price on the wholesale price.
Now, let's think of the alternative. Anyone who has tried to buy a top level domain for a country that heavily regulates the names would understand the pain of the alternative. It can cost hundreds or thousands for the wholesale price. You're required to own the trademark already (which adds additional cost for a new project) as well as have a registered company etc. I can think of dozens of my favourite projects/blogs which I'm sure don't have a company or trademark registered under that name. This system would not only be a pain for small business, it would stifle innovation on the web.
I'm not a domainer (I do own about a dozen though) and I get just as annoyed as the next guy when I come up with a name for a project and find some punk wants $15k for the domain. But then I think of the alternative.