Re:I Buy and Sell Domain Names AMA
by thenbrent on Thursday October 28, 2010 @07:10AM
(#1842470)
At first I liked the idea of market value based taxes and clearly a bunch of HN readers agree with the idea.
The biggest issue I see though is the implication for small projects.
For example, maybe in 1994 you snapped up pizza.com. You could have been using it ever since for a pizza price search engine which gets 100,000 unique visitors per month and earns you $5,000 per month. That's decent income, except the taxes on the domain's market value of $2.6 million[1] would be crippling. So despite using the domain in what most would think of as good way, you couldn't afford to have such a good domain. Now extrapolate this example for the thousands of sites that have a good domain name for a small project.
The biggest issue I see though is the implication for small projects.
For example, maybe in 1994 you snapped up pizza.com. You could have been using it ever since for a pizza price search engine which gets 100,000 unique visitors per month and earns you $5,000 per month. That's decent income, except the taxes on the domain's market value of $2.6 million[1] would be crippling. So despite using the domain in what most would think of as good way, you couldn't afford to have such a good domain. Now extrapolate this example for the thousands of sites that have a good domain name for a small project.
[1] http://news.cnet.com/8301-10784_3-9912380-7.html