News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by rolleiflex on Saturday November 03, 2018 @11:31AM (#18370656)
Hey guys - Burak here. Ouch, this was supposed to be a ‘soft’ launch.

I’m here to answer any questions as usual. I’ll pick the best and try to add it to the FAQ on the site.

Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by TekMol on Saturday November 03, 2018 @11:46AM (#18370741)
Looks good. But a native application? I would only install a native application if it comes from a source that has a proven trackrecord of being trustworthy.

Can you track how many people installed it, now that it is on HN?

You say it puts everyone on "one single universe with the same content". So it should be easy to put up an instance that provides a web interface to the content, right?

I would think that posting via the browser should also be possible without relying on a single server / authority. A user could hold a private key which they use to sign their posts. And then deliver the post via any server that offers an interface for it. Similar to how a Bitcoin transaction can be delivered via any server that offers such a service.

So it would still be decentralized but can be used via the browser.

Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by rolleiflex on Saturday November 03, 2018 @11:51AM (#18370774)
Yes I can, because this is a developer preview version, and it has anonymous metrics in. Stable versions are going to ask in the onboarding if you want to join the anonymous metrics program (like Firefox).

Yes it would be easy - that would just be an another node that showed it’s read-only UI on the web. (You still need to mint proofs of work, so you would need an actual computer for posting.)

Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by the_clarence on Sunday November 04, 2018 @12:55AM (#18374320)
What’s the proof of work? Is it something common to protect p2p network from spam?
Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by guachesuedehack on Saturday November 03, 2018 @11:26PM (#18374007)
is it open sourced ?
Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by balladeer on Sunday November 04, 2018 @02:22PM (#18377577)
It's not a native application. It's an Electron app. By the way it doesn't ask for an elevated permission.
Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by FlyingSnake on Saturday November 03, 2018 @04:38PM (#18372351)
Looks great, kudos on the `soft' launch.

* The FAQs say that the app is a p2p based app. What is the p2p protocol being used here? * How does it compare to libp2p, SSB, and others? * What's the security model, and how would the system mitigate Sybil attacks etc?

Are there any plans to have mobile apps (preferable native)? I think if people could use it on their mobile phones, it would be a game changer.

Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by rolleiflex on Saturday November 03, 2018 @05:34PM (#18372594)
Thanks!

> The FAQs say that the app is a p2p based app. What is the p2p protocol being used here? * How does it compare to libp2p, SSB, and others? * What's the security model, and how would the system mitigate Sybil attacks etc?

It's built from scratch. It runs c0 subprotocol of Mim. You can see some basic comparisons here: https://getaether.net/docs/how_is_it_different_from/

Other questions - all good questions, but it depends on what your definition of security model is. Sybil attacks are prevented by cryptographic signatures and proof of work. Unique names are available to provide a good human-friendly polish over cryptographic signatures, as well.

> Are there any plans to have mobile apps (preferable native)? I think if people could use it on their mobile phones, it would be a game changer.

Yes, I would _love_ to have mobile apps. The system supports it, but I don't have the money to spend the time building them, or to pay someone to build them. In essence, it depends on how popular the project gets - if enough people support it financially, it would certainly be a first priority.

Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by comex on Saturday November 03, 2018 @08:48PM (#18373360)
> It runs c0 subprotocol of Mim.

Can you elaborate? Googling these terms doesn't produce much other than a few papers using "MiM" to mean man-in-the-middle, as well as your comment itself!

Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by rolleiflex on Sunday November 04, 2018 @06:37PM (#18378679)
I actually posted the protocol spec somewhere a few months ago, but it might have gotten taken down when I flipped the beta site into the production site.

Mim (comes from 'mime' from 'to replicate') is a HTTP based stateless protocol where the nodes communicate with each other via bog-standard HTTP GET and POST requests. The nodes can create caches for oft-requested data. c0 is a subprotocol of Mim that defines six graph objects, boards, threads, posts, userkeys, votes and truststates. the first four are obvious, the vote is a userkey > b|t|p relation, a trustste is a userkey > userkey relation. It creates a directed graph that is mostly acyclic.

It allows for efficient flood-network propagation of this graph based on time intervals, and it comes with certain patch semantics, so given a delta communicated from one node to another, there is always a way to apply that delta into the local node's graph in a way that does not create merge conflicts.

Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by FlyingSnake on Sunday November 04, 2018 @04:08AM (#18374974)
> I would _love_ to have mobile apps, The system supports it

If there's a library/protocol that could be embedded in a native app, I would love to play with it. I'm a mobile developer with some free time at hand. I'll drop you an email.

Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by rolleiflex on Sunday November 04, 2018 @10:11PM (#18379608)
Not yet! The protocol docs should be out there, but I think they accidentally got taken down when I replaced the old site with the new one. It's actually a fairly simple, stateless protocol that works over HTTP, so you can very easily script it — it just outputs JSON api responses to GET and POST requests. There are JSON schemas available for it as well. You really won't need any special tools or libraries, just any bog standard HTTP library in any language should be able to handle it. If you're willing to give it a go send me an email (on profile) and I'll let you know when that is ready to give a shot.
Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by guachesuedehack on Saturday November 03, 2018 @11:26PM (#18374003)
Hit me up if you need help ! Email in profile
Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by brokenmachine on Sunday November 04, 2018 @08:00PM (#18379024)
Can you post to this from Tor?

edit: oops, just found this https://meta.getaether.net/t/how-to-use-aether-behind-tor/53

Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by rch on Saturday November 03, 2018 @12:25PM (#18370995)
Seems to overlap with what SSB is trying to accomplish. Do you see any opportunities for integrating with that or other protocols, maybe for tracking unique identities over time?

(backed on patreon btw)

Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by rolleiflex on Saturday November 03, 2018 @03:32PM (#18372026)
Thank you! I’m a little hair on fire at the moment but if you want to claim your unique username, please reach out to me (I’m not sure if I have a way of reaching out to you through Patreon) and I’ll issue it.
Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by smokeyj on Saturday November 03, 2018 @04:35PM (#18372328)
I think parent was asking for your take on the secure scuttlebot protocol (SSB) and the overlap of goals. I would also be interested, thanks!
Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by rolleiflex on Saturday November 03, 2018 @05:38PM (#18372616)
I think it's covered here: https://getaether.net/docs/how_is_it_different_from/#secure-...

In summary, SSB is, from what I can see, designed for non-public sharing of Twitter-like content between friends, and your data only traverses to people who follow you.

In contrast, Aether is explicitly designed to be a public space where you talk to people you don't know. It communicates everyone's information to everybody. To make that possible, Aether only accepts and transmits text (you can still link to stuff), while SSB can transmit other formats directly in the protocol itself.

(I might be horribly wrong: I'm not a SSB expert. Please correct me if so.)

Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by tomsmeding on Saturday November 03, 2018 @02:52PM (#18371820)
Do threads refresh automatically in the Aether client, or is there some magic way in which one can do so?

c.f. aether://board/86e782e80681ac580b4d6d102b12e787c066e59f194fee57bb0bf83cc1e42fc6/thread/4932c494227ccd4f632c2ace1012f58fd79d0d531b2dcd148463491598c841d8

Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by rolleiflex on Saturday November 03, 2018 @03:28PM (#18372000)
Check the status page reachable from bottom left - it will tell you the last frontend compile, how long it took. That’s the ‘refresh’ rate. Essentially, every minute or so.
Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by brokenmachine on Sunday November 04, 2018 @06:46PM (#18378723)
Is the proof-of-work likely to be too much for a mobile to be able to do? If a mobile client were to be made, that is.

Also, does the proof-of-work scale, eg how the bitcoin network gets harder and harder as the hashing power increases.

Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by ValentineC on Saturday November 03, 2018 @12:25PM (#18370998)
Thanks for creating this!

How does the unique username perk for patrons work? Does it mean that people can still create "normal"-coloured usernames, but there can only be one orange "verified" one?

Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by tomsmeding on Saturday November 03, 2018 @12:27PM (#18371018)
Yep, that's how it works.
Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by dcow on Saturday November 03, 2018 @12:50PM (#18371151)
I would like to give Aether2 a test run. The only version I can find is the old 1.2.3 release on GitHub. Others here seem to have version 2. Where can I get it?
Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by rolleiflex on Saturday November 03, 2018 @12:54PM (#18371185)
https://getaether.net has the new one. If you get a green site, delete your browser cache and try again.
Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by dcow on Saturday November 03, 2018 @05:09PM (#18372503)
I get the "you've caught it before launch" alert when I click download.
Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by rolleiflex on Saturday November 03, 2018 @06:16PM (#18372800)
There's something with Cloudflare and Netlify interacting in a weird way. I just removed CF caching from the frontend, so you should be able to use it normally now.
Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by billconan on Saturday November 03, 2018 @01:16PM (#18371307)
I thought about doing something like this with orbitdb. maybe large content, like video, could be using ipfs.
Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by rolleiflex on Saturday November 03, 2018 @01:51PM (#18371489)
That would be very cool! Let me know if you ever implement it, Aether only delivers text at this moment.
Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by se7entime on Saturday November 03, 2018 @12:24PM (#18370987)
will you provide .AppImage or Flatpak or Snap? or all of them?
Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by nixarian on Saturday November 03, 2018 @02:59PM (#18371859)
You state that one of the purposes of this platform is to allow you the freedom to be wrong, but if people can save something before 6 months, how would you prevent someone from saving an embarrassing comment for future use against you? Or are you the only one capable of saving your own comments?
Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by rolleiflex on Saturday November 03, 2018 @03:30PM (#18372011)
They can definitely save yours - and if you’re someone whose comments should be saved, be pseudonymous. What they can’t do is they can’t go back 14 years of history like they can on Twitter, after the fact, and find something out of context there.

Pseudonymity and ephemerality are the two sides of the same coin. One doesn’t protect without the other.

Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by inequity on Saturday November 03, 2018 @04:21PM (#18372244)
Have you considered the inequities that such a retention policy introduces into HOW history can be used?

The entrepreneurial (and governments) will archive everything to serve the wealthy (including governments), who will be able to use history to their ends. Those without resources will live in an eternal present, except where history is used against them.

To sell this kind of retention policy as a user-protecting feature is (in my view) at best naive, and at worst, disingenuous. This model increases the economic cost of mining history, but in doing so, entrenches existing wealth and power structures.

Thanks to the ever-decreasing cost-per-bit of storage, the internet is forever. The only hope for redemption lies in this permanence affecting everyone equally; otherwise we're doomed to (continue to) live in a world where only the wealthy and politically connected have read and write access to history.

Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by rolleiflex on Saturday November 03, 2018 @05:22PM (#18372545)
There is an argument to be made there, but you're off on the difficulty of storing data. Reddit, even with its 250M+ users, generates only 8.5Gb per month of data. A $100 Western Digital hard drive could hold the entirety of Reddit's comment history. In other words, if you want to collect data, you can do it just as well if you're just a random guy on the street just as well as any government can. Aether can't prevent anyone from collecting data, just like Snapchat also cannot. But what it can do is that it can reduce the availability of historic data as much as possible, so the data is at least not accidentally collected.

> ... but in doing so, entrenches existing wealth and power structures.

What entrenches existing wealth and power structures is wealth and power. That's why it's valuable to have wealth and power. In other words, you could prefix that sentence with almost anything, and you'd still be right.

Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by the_clarence on Sunday November 04, 2018 @12:57AM (#18374328)
The 6 month thing is a storage problem where every node needs to store the app’s content.

The privacy thing is free marketing that came out of that constraint.

This is really a good marketing move tbh. Everybody wants privacy and nobody understands what it technically means.

Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by brokenmachine on Sunday November 04, 2018 @06:52PM (#18378746)
The way I see it, it has some privacy. No node after the first hop will have any way to get ip information of the poster, or even know how many hops they are away from the poster.
Re:Aether – Free, privacy-sensitive public communities by a_t48 on Saturday November 03, 2018 @03:08PM (#18371916)
There’s always the ‘analog hole’. Someone can take a screenshot. Probably won’t unless you are egregious about something. What this should prevent is someone going back in time and digging through your stuff for something embarrassing, if they weren’t associated with you before.